Partial Knee Replacement or Not ?

Posted , 13 users are following.

I am having a partial knee replacement in the next few months but have read quite a lot of articles mostly negative and I am now wondering if I should go ahead with it or just put up! 

Im 57 I like to walk each day I wear sensible shoes and have soles in them from the podiatrist to keep my leg aligned. Will I still be able to walk each day once fully recovered and if so how far will distance be restricted?

i have also read that your sleep is very disturbed after this kind of operation is this correct and if so is this forever or just during recovery.

Also very occasionally I wear a heal about 2.5 inches if I go to a function or have a meal out I only have them On for about 4 hours so would this still be possible after a partial knee replacement?

Finally am I right in thinking that have a partial knee replacement leads to a full replacement within a couple of years?

Any information would be greatly accepted.

 

0 likes, 46 replies

46 Replies

Next
  • Posted

    Hi Maysol, stop panicking, I don't no where you got this rubbish info , I have had one parcial 7 week ago, it is a slow process but you'll get there, I'm doing well,not pain free yet but that's the nature of the surgery, I'm 54 by the way, you will not need full replacement in couple of years, if your knee is that bad, then they would do full now, you may need a full in 15 to 20 years. I am on the list to have the second parcial done , in about six more weeks. Once your fully recovered, yes you will be able to walk as you would normally, , I have 2 very lively border collies, and they go out for at least 2 hours at a time. Then weekend, we go off for the day, surgeon has said I will be able to do that no problem, . Heeled shoes yes once again , when your recovered enough and feel comfortable, I tried a 1 and a half inch heel a week ago, and that just wasn't gonna happen, but I was just trying to early, sleep wise yes it is disturbed , but then it is a major op, I still have nights where I don't sleep so well, sometimes I wake crying cause it hurts, but it passes, you will have your pain killers, ice packs ( very important) and massage,  and it will be worth it in the end, . I just want my life back, haven't been able to walk my dogs on a proper walk, for over a year, it's been driving me crazy, . Keep coming on here , you get loads of encouragement, and always someone will no the answer to any questions you have. Go for it I would say, and ignore what you've heard before, that from the dark ages,. Good luck.😀
    • Posted

      Hi

      Thank you so much for the encouragement I feel a lot more confident about it now and your have a second one so can't be that bad.

      May I ask how big is your scar im only 5 feet short!!! so mine will probably take over my leg haha,..

    • Posted

      My scar is about six inches , already very tidy looking, I'm only 5f 4 , to be honest, I'd rather be able to walk a decent walk than have nice legs, they were never that wonderful in the first place, but they did at least get me around, lol. And any way I have quite a few scars,on my body at least, but as long as they leave my face alone I can cope, . Glad you feel a bit better about having it done, it's to depressing to think of not being able to go for walks, it's what I love doing. 
    • Posted

      Hi , me again, just read what Susan says, I to was bone on bone, which limits your walking greatly, Vvvvvvery painful, I even had powdered my bone, . How bad are yours?
    • Posted

      Hi Mandy

      I'm also bone to bone & the sound when im sat & bend it is horrendous! But I still manage to walk the dog every day it is quite painful to start with but then seems to ease off as I get going.

    • Posted

      Then your knees are not as bad as mine were just before they did my first one, I was booked for the 23may, they ended up bringing it back to the 1st may, because I could no longer walk 10 meters with sticks , get on and off loo, stairs, forget it, couldn't cook, as I couldn't stand , on morphin, basically a mess, . They messed about for so long before they offered me surgery, with phisco ( which my surgeon said made it 10times worse, steroid injections, waste of time, they were treating phibromialga, as I get that to, ( lucky me) . But they never thought to do an X-ray, which showed it straight away, . My ariganal appointment was only six weeks from seeing the surgeon, so from seeing him I only waited couple weeks, come the finish, which was just as well in light of my situation. If you can still walk an hour quite comfortably, I think I'd be inclined to hang on a bit.😀
    • Posted

      This is why I am undecided when I listen to how bad some are. I too have fybromyalgia & osteoarthritis I am at present waiting for injection in my wrist that is very swelled & extremely painful so more steroid injections! I would say it worse than knee at the minute.

      Oh it's such a big decision because the surgeon has said I need it but to be honest I felt very rushed Into making decision at my appointment I wasn't given much time to sit & discuss it & ask questions. I'm seriously thinking of asking if I could see him again to discuss it further but getting an appointment is like getting an audience with the queen!!!

    • Posted

      Yes mine is osteoarthritis to, in knees hands and jaw, leading to neck, I hate to think what I'll be like at 65😒 I have put off surgery on my jaw, because my knees are so bad, and your pretty stuffed if you can't walk, I can at least use a straw for soup, if my jaws that bad, lol. I've been told that having all this in my knees has been made worse, or speeded up, because I've always done a lot of walking, and then my grandmother had arthritis, but only in 70 .😒
    • Posted

      I’m suppose to have a partial but had to have a papacemakerfirst I was wondering how’s bad was the pain , I have had a lot of surgery’s  and this one scares me a lot of people told me stuff about how bad they were in pain
  • Posted

    Hi Maysol, i had a partial knee replacement in January. I would say it depends how bad you are now as to whether to go ahead with op. In my case I could barely walk as I had bone on bone on the outer side of my left knee. I was on two crutches and even then could only manage a few step. Now at least I am able to walk on the flat with only one crutch. I am disappointed, as I have written in previous posts, as I thought I would be virtually back to normal by now. I also have a dog and I can only manage a 20 minute walk every other day and going up and down steps or slopes and standing from sitting is still very painful. I think you have to weigh up how you are now, I really had no choice but to try something. It is a difficult decision and it is a painful operation . Sorry to sound so negative, I think I may have been just unlucky with mine. I have spoken to many people with full replacements and they seem to be getting on by far better than me.
    • Posted

      Hi Susan

      Sorry to hear that. This is why I have started this forum because I have read & listened to mixed reports.

      I don't think my knee is as bad as your was as I can walk an hour everyday which is painful but very manageable. Up & down is very painful & I try to avoid areas like this.

      I am very undecided wether or not to go ahead because I am coping at the moment !!!!!

  • Posted

    If you are in pain or your life is increasingly limited and you are frustrated go ahead. Everything for most people is temporary. I doubt you would be offered a partial or total if it isn't needed. My Physio said to me yesterday no pain no gain and this is so true. Some sail through, some have problems that go after three six or twelve months and exceptionally some take longer to resolve. It's your decision as we all have different lifestyles and expectations. Personally and even though I am dreading and postponing my second leg I would say get it done and the sooner it's done the sooner you get your life back. I would see if a partial is temporary and depending on age would go for total if it's inevitable. Why have two surgeries if you can have one. My arthroscopy delayed my tkr but next time I'm going straight for the tkr. What about your other leg? Finally this forum is mainly those with issues to share and there are thousands out there who are more typical but it does show how much we all have in common whether we recover smoothly or not so smoothly. But we are also all in different contexts so use it to help and inform but go with your instinct and surgeons advice if you trust him/her
    • Posted

      Thank you caroline46398 for that. I know it's a personal decision & everyones different plus needs must. I think I just need to hear from others on thier personal views.

      I think I'm just worried I get it done & I end up worse than I am now!

    • Posted

      If you leave it until it's really bad it's harder and takes longer to recover. Time does heal and it is a challenge for sure but do you really have a choice? I didn't and although it has been very tough this forum has really helped. Five months still not totally recovered but could certainly walk with v little discomfort most days and know I will get better and batter as muscles get stronger
    • Posted

      You say 5 months Caroline & not fully recovered but walking ok how far can you walk?

      I have foot problem aswel I have fallen arches (flat feet) so that is painful because the tendons are all stretched & it swells up from time to time. Doctor thinks this has contributed to my knee problem & is why I wear insoles.

    • Posted

      've got fallen arches too  . also use insoles, and they have helped enormously, but sometimes I wonder if they were a bit too much, and helped to cause the knee problem!  some of them did seem to push the foot sideways a lot more than others!  Still, before the insoles, I had plantar fascitis, heel spurs and tendinitis of the achilles tendon, and it all cleared up in a matter of weeks!  No specialist ever helped though . . I found an advert in the sunday newspaper and was willing to try anything by that stage!  Hope your op goes well if you decide to have it. The TKR is hard work to begin with, but at 21 weeks I am feeling the benefit!
    • Posted

      Well you sound very positive at 21 weeks good to hear. Yes my feet have definitely contrubuted to my knee problems. I'm very undecided as I am coping to walk the dog each day & wondering if I should hang on a while longer. I think I'm going to ring & see if I can see the specialist again to discuss it further.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.