Partial Knee Replacement or Not ?

Posted , 13 users are following.

I am having a partial knee replacement in the next few months but have read quite a lot of articles mostly negative and I am now wondering if I should go ahead with it or just put up! 

Im 57 I like to walk each day I wear sensible shoes and have soles in them from the podiatrist to keep my leg aligned. Will I still be able to walk each day once fully recovered and if so how far will distance be restricted?

i have also read that your sleep is very disturbed after this kind of operation is this correct and if so is this forever or just during recovery.

Also very occasionally I wear a heal about 2.5 inches if I go to a function or have a meal out I only have them On for about 4 hours so would this still be possible after a partial knee replacement?

Finally am I right in thinking that have a partial knee replacement leads to a full replacement within a couple of years?

Any information would be greatly accepted.

 

0 likes, 46 replies

46 Replies

Prev Next
  • Posted

    I'm nearly 13 weeks following patellafemoral arthroplasty (new plastic knee cap and metal trochlea, the bit behind it). I'm 56 (currently feeling 76!) And waited 11 years for op because I was considered too young before. For those 11 years I wore a knee support as knee was so unstable and I needed to live my life, but in doing so the support did the job of my muscles and they've now forgotten what to do. My knee is healing fine but the muscles are a different matter. I've been having weekly physio sessions and only in the last couple of days have I managed without my stick in the house, and I seem to have lost my confidence to walk outside without it. Knee is gradually beginning to feel easier (hurray!), and I'm trying not to overdo things - which is very tempting when you've been used to leading an active life. My life saviour has been a static exercise bike that I use daily.

    I've worn trainers and jogging bottoms for last 13 weeks and as soon as I'm recovered I'm going to have a bonfire - trainers, joggers, knee supports lol! I've never been a high heels wearer but do wear a moderate heel so am hoping to do so again!

    Sleep? Yes it has been disturbed, so if I feel tired in the day I have a kip - hope I get out of this habit or else I'm going to be splayed across the keyboard at work snoring my head off! And 56 - also menopausal and although I was suffering with the occasional night sweats these have returned ten fold - so my sleep disturbances is more to do with these than pain from my knee.

    We are all different, we  suffer things differently - I have friends who have had partial or full knee replacements - one was fine at 6 weeks, the other at 8 weeks. I think I've been despondent because I've not done nearly as well and I had a lesser (I say that tongue in cheek!) op. But, I've learnt to be patient and I'm hoping things now continue to improve.

    Go for it, be prepared for good days and bad days, be patient (easier said than done on occasions!) and when you come out the other side........YIPPEE! 

    • Posted

      Thanks pam1313 you sound positive & I hope all ends well for you after 11 years!!! Haha the bomfire i bet you can't wait. As I said earlier I iccasionally wear heels not often but I do like to if going somewhere special & the thought of wearing a pair of trainers with insoles in with a posh frock to say a wedding or night out OMG.

      After reading all the lovely replies it is very true everyone different how they come out the other end.

    • Posted

      I didnt realise you also have fibromyalgia. I have that too, diagnosed in 1996. Yet another cross to bear, but I try to control it (not always successfully!) with nurofen, massage, reflexology, hot water bottles......and alcohol. I was told that fibromyalgia considers surgery as "trauma" and responds accordingly, i.e. more pain, and I do think this has contributed to my problems. I also think using ice packs, although it helped tremendously with swelling, also annoyed my fibromyalgia, so I have also used a hot water bottle for stiffness in last few weeks. You'll know what to use......and when! 
    • Posted

      Yes pam1313 I was diagnosed in 1997 much to my disappointment as I am such a active person but this really held me back from doing a lot of things I would have loved to do. I take Nurofen on & off & sometimes tramadol depending on what ive got in store for the day. I never take tramadol at night because it keeps me awake & im a poor sleeper to start with.

      As for my knee im really now totally undecided!!!!

    • Posted

      How strange! Also diagnosed with fibromyalgia, and I find I can only sleep if I DO take half a tramadol at night!  We are all so different!
    • Posted

      Yes we are all different & after reading all the nice replies ive received I eealise everyones recovery is differnt. Decisions Decisions ???????
    • Posted

      Yes, I had the TKR although to tell the truth I was nowhere near as bad as a lot of people on here.  I could walk, with my leg straight . . it was only bending the knee which hurt.  the first few weeks I would have given anything to go back and not to have had it done . . .but now, of course, I am very glad that I DID have it done!  Even at 22 weeks, it's still sometimes a bit stiff, and I don't have as much bend as some people achieve, but I can do whatever I want to do except really get on the floor to clean into corners. . . and walking is fine, even quite long distances.  It is a difficult decision!
  • Posted

    I can only share with you my experience of a Total Knee Replacement 3 years ago. Yes it is hard work and a long recovery period but well worth it in the end.

    You mention problems with sleep. I have to be honest with you here.

    I had problems with sleep after operation. I initially went to sleep fairly quickly. after 1 or 2 hurs i then used to wake up in pain and discomfort. This meant I could not get back to sleep for a long time. Even now 3 years later i still wake up nearly every night, though not i n pain anymore and usually get back to sleep fairly quickly. However I think my sleeping pattern has changed and will probably never be the same as it was.

    All this came as a huge shock . I had always been such a good sleeper and was something Ihad not really anticipated.

    But ofcourse everyone is different and this does not mean you will have problems sleeping, I am only sharing with you my own experience.

    On balance I would say have the operation but yu have to do what is right for you and only you can decide that.

    Take care and keep in touch

    Praying for you

    Love Sarah xx

  • Posted

    Hi Maysol, yes, it is a very difficult decision to make. I wouldn't rush into making it if I were you as you are still managing to walk really well. I was lucky I think as my surgeon gave me time to make my decision (mine was TKR) . He told me it was only a total replacement would help.  He let me go away and think about it and I had a further appointment  6 weeks later. I then waited 6/7 months on his list. I was offered a consultation with another consultant to try to get it done sooner. I took up the offer and was astounded when he suggested trying an injection and waiting a bit longer before the op! He could see my reaction to that after me taking so long to come to my decision and changed his mind and said ok we'll go ahead and he put me on his list too. So, what I'm trying to say is even the specialists find it a difficult decision to make and can have differing opinions.

    i eventually had a TKR last July and although it's been a long recovery and I still have some secondary problems, I don't regret having it done. I can now do long walks again which I was unable to do for a year or so before the op. It was that goal that motivated me to have it done. You need to weigh up what your aim is. It isn't a magic cure and I can't tell you what the chances of you needing a total after a partial replacement. I feel like I've got a new knee and can do most things I want to do but it's not a "normal" knee. 

    Sorry I've rambled a lot. I hope you make the decision that's right for you.

    Jen (11 months pot op)

  • Posted

    Hi Maysol I am almost 3 weeks post op from having partial knee replacement and am getting there slowly! Like you I waited nearly a year on the NHS going through an arthroscopy, steroid jabs and a hylanuronic acid injection with one consultant who agreed there was nothing more that could be done apart from knee replacement then to be fobbed off by the 2nd consultant I was referred to because of my age I'm 51!! Fortunately I have private medical ins through work so used it and within 3 weeks of seeing my surgeon I was booked in for surgery! I too was bone on bone but only in my inner joint outer and knee cap fine and I have osteoarthritis as well?

    it is a slow process but I have gone from using 2 crutches to 1 and sometimes don't even use it when pottering around the house

    I have my good days and bad and I find the worst part is getting comfortable in bed but with the right medication this has also been addressed and I'm getting much better nights now

    i had dissolvable stitches and my scar is really neat

    good luck with everything

    regards

    Mandy

  • Posted

    Only know from others that the pkr isn't a quick bypass to pain and recovery. The nerves and sod tissue are damaged and must heal. You have the same therapy and recovery process. When I originally heard they were doing this proceedure I thought there had to be a huge advantage but after discussions on here and a with therapists I'm beginning to believe it's largely a cost cutting measure. Being a male, I didn't have the concern for style in footwear but after several discussions on this forum I don't think you will be w o trying about shoe selection for several months. Safe and comfortable will be your goal. As far as walking, you will be a few weeks to months but you won't lose your freedom to pursue that pleasure. A lot of what you do afterwards is pretty much the same as before but hopefully without the bone on bone pain. Just remember that recovery from either surgery is not a direct line from point A to point B. There are a lot of ups a d downs, which sometimes has you think you are going in circles. Keep asking questions. You will find this group to be the most compassionate, caring group you could find and the reason........we've all been through it, some more than once or twice.
    • Posted

      Oldfatguy1 I love you lol!. Everything you say is so sensible and calming and although us folk on this forum will probably never ever meet, I must just comment and say it's a pleasure reading your comforting and reassuring words. Thank you. 
    • Posted

      Thank you...I appreciate your kind words. I find this forum to be very interesting as there is so much diversity in not only the thoughts and actions in the medical community but from country to country and within national borders. It amazes me that with all of the differences, we all seem to heal eventually
    • Posted

      Thanks......I've been pimping this leg for sympathy so long it may be hard to adjust.😅
    • Posted

      I too hope things will soon start to improve for you.

      I'm in Derbyshire, England......where in this big wide world are you?

    • Posted

      I am about 30 minutes on a good day southwest of Kansas City. When I moved here 54 years ago it was a little town of 8000. Today it's a spread out city of 135000. The 4 lane interstate highway wasnt completed into the metro area. Today it's 8 and 10 lanes and packed. Then there was one high school with 600 kids , now 4 with over 2000 eac h and a 5th under construction. So happy to be retired and don't have to fight that traffic any more. Kansas city is made up of 5 counties in the states of Kansas and Missouri split down the middle by a river and state line. I live in the Kansas side.
    • Posted

      Wow! Doubt we will ever meet then, but thank goodness for technology! 
    • Posted

      Isn't that the truth. In case you didn't see my post of last weekend, we were able to see ours son's wedding 1500 mi. away. Due to my wife's advancing Parkinson's disease and my leg we couldn't do the trip. My brother in law took his go pro camera and we both logged on to a web site called "live stream". We saw the wedding live and that evening they h a d the reception at a winery. We hooked up to Skype and had an interactive visit through the laptops. Got to talk live and in person to all of the family and friends......all of this at absolutely no cost and with no more than 5 to 8 second time delay plus the wedding is archived in our account. By using a $15 cord we were able to see it on the big screen t.v. would t have been possible even 10-15 years ago
    • Posted

      I did see your post and I'm so glad you were able to 'participate'. I have two kids, both left home now, but they keep me and my hubby 'up to date' with technology.......even though they think we're "oldies" - since when has middle 50's been old! They forget I first used a computer when I was 22, huge thing that my boss bought second hand, gave me the manual that was 4" thick and said "teach yourself this". Well teach myself I did and I've managed to make the keyboard sing for the last 34 years (I can touch type and use all my fingers, not just the index fingers like they do!).

      If only my knees had had as much exercise as my fingers have over the years they might not have seized up! 

    • Posted

      My wife was a secretary all of her working years.......she was even very fast and accurate in shorthand. Don't try to have that skill described by today's kids. She was the administrative asst to the director of special ed for the school district, a district of 35000 students with about 12 to 15% of them in special ed services ranging from gifted to severely handicapped. She was going to work another year until she found out they were going to do a major IT update and she would be required to upgrade her skills. I came home from a two week road trip and she handed me a letter to review........it was her notice of retirement at the end of the contract year. She said she would't put herself or me through that for one more year of work. I don't know which one of us was t h e happiest.

    • Posted

      I loved pitman's shorthand. . I could write at 140  wpm when I left secretarial college, but I imagine I was a lot faster after a couple of years working!  and my husband was a Special Education teacher. . so lots of coincidences!  And strangely, I decided to leave my job as a lecturer at Bristol University when they started to introduce information technology!

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.