What are the best ways to improve shared decision-making for all patients booked for surgery?
Every year in the UK, millions of people agree to have planned surgery. It is vital that patients and doctors talk openly about the risks, benefits, and personal preferences before choosing treatment. This process is called shared decision-making. However, many people feel they do not get enough say in their care. Researchers at the University of Bristol are developing a new system to collect real-time feedback from patients about how decisions are made. The goal is to share this feedback with hospital teams so they can improve how they communicate before an operation. The study focuses closely on groups often left behind, including older adults, ethnic minorities, and people living in lower-income areas. By testing new support tools, the project aims to ensure every patient feels heard, respected, and fully informed before going into surgery.
At a glance
What is this study about?
Having an operation can be life-changing, and deciding to go ahead with surgery is a major step. Ideally, doctors and patients work as a team to weigh up treatment options, risks, and personal goals. This joint approach is known as shared decision-making. Unfortunately, research shows that many patients do not feel fully included in these conversations. People from older age groups, ethnic minority backgrounds, or areas facing economic hardship are often the most likely to be left out of key decisions about their care.
This study, led by the University of Bristol and funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research, aims to change that. Researchers want to design a new system that gathers feedback directly from patients about how their surgical choices were discussed. Hospital staff can then see this information and learn what is working well and where communication needs to improve.
By testing these new decision-making tools in everyday NHS settings, the study aims to build a fairer, more open healthcare system. In the long run, ensuring patients feel informed and supported can lead to better surgical results, less anxiety, and care that truly matches what matters most to each individual.
Key takeaways
- Aims to give patients a stronger voice when deciding whether to have surgery.
- Focuses on improving communication for older adults, ethnic minorities, and lower-income groups.
- Does not alter your medical treatments, medications, or planned operation.
- Involves sharing your views through surveys, interviews, or group discussions.
- Completely voluntary, and you can withdraw at any point without impacting your NHS care.
Who may be eligible?
The study is open to adults aged 18 and over who are booked for planned (non-emergency) surgery at participating NHS hospitals. This includes operations across many areas, such as heart, bone, bowel, blood vessel, brain, and women's health procedures. NHS doctors, nurses, and other surgical staff at these hospitals are also invited to join.
Researchers also want to hear from members of the general public aged 18 and older, particularly people from communities that often face barriers to good healthcare. This includes older adults, people living in economically disadvantaged areas, and people from minority ethnic backgrounds, with a specific focus on British Asian and South Asian communities.
People under the age of 18 cannot take part. The study also excludes anyone needing emergency surgery, patients booked only for simple camera checks (endoscopies), and individuals who are unable to give informed consent for their care.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I am aged 18 or over.
- I am scheduled for a planned (non-emergency) operation at a participating NHS hospital, OR I am a healthcare worker, OR I am an interested community member.
- I am able to give informed consent to share my views.
- My surgery is not an emergency procedure or an endoscopy.
What does participation involve?
Taking part does not involve taking new medications, having extra medical tests, or changing your planned surgical treatment. Instead, your involvement focuses entirely on sharing your thoughts, experiences, and feedback.
Depending on how you take part, you may be asked to attend an interview or small group discussion in person or online. You might also fill out short questionnaires before or after your hospital appointments to share how your surgical options were explained to you. Hospital staff will take part in meetings to review patient feedback and test new communication tools. The overall research project runs from 2022 to 2026, but your personal involvement will typically consist of one or two feedback sessions or brief surveys around the time of your care.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (3)
- North Bristol NHS TrustCity onlyBristol, England
- University Hospitals Bristol and Weston NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyBristol, England
- Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyBradford, England
Common questions
Will taking part change my planned surgery or date?
No. Your surgical care, appointments, and operation date will proceed as planned by your medical team.
Do I have to take any experimental medications?
No. This study only looks at how decisions are made and how doctors and patients talk to each other. No new drugs or treatments are involved.
How long will my involvement last?
Most people only need to complete a few short surveys or take part in an interview or discussion meeting around the time of their hospital care.
What happens if I change my mind about taking part?
You can step down from the study at any time. Doing so will not affect your relationship with your healthcare team or the quality of your care.
Who is funding and running this project?
The research is led by the University of Bristol and funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR), the research partner of the NHS.
How to find out more
Christin Hoffmann
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.