WHITE 12-DUALITY: An investigation of people 65 years and over with a broken hip to determine whether using a hip replacement with modified mobility (Dual mobility cup) can reduce the rate of hip dislocation in the first year after hip fracture surgery
Around 70,000 people in the UK break a hip each year. For many older adults, the best treatment is a total hip replacement, where surgeons replace both the ball and socket of the joint. Currently, doctors use two main types of hip replacement: a standard design and a 'dual mobility' design, which has an extra moving part designed to keep the joint stable. Doctors do not yet know which type provides better results. The WHiTE 12-DUALITY study compares both options across UK hospitals. Patients aged 65 and over who need a hip replacement are placed into one of two groups by random selection. Everyone receives normal NHS surgery and recovery care. The study checks in with patients after 4 and 12 months to see how well they are walking, check their pain levels, and see if either design prevents the hip from dislocating.
At a glance
What is this study about?
A broken hip is a serious injury that usually happens after a fall. For breaks near the top of the thigh bone inside the joint socket, surgeons often recommend a total hip replacement. This operation replaces the damaged bone and cartilage with artificial parts so that you can walk again and live without severe pain.
When carrying out a hip replacement, surgeons can choose between two main implants. The traditional type uses a small artificial ball that fits directly into a replacement socket. The newer 'dual mobility' type places a ball inside a larger plastic ball, which then moves inside the socket. This extra moving part is designed to give the joint more movement and prevent it from dislocating (popping out of its socket).
A dislocated hip can be very painful and often requires another hospital stay to fix. While many surgeons have started using the dual mobility implant, there is not yet clear evidence showing whether it truly prevents dislocations better than the standard design or if it offers good value for the NHS. This clinical trial aims to settle this question so that future patients receive the safest and most reliable treatment.
Key takeaways
- Compares standard hip replacements with 'dual mobility' hip replacements for broken hips.
- Open to people aged 65 and over having surgery within a week of arriving at hospital.
- Aims to find out which design best prevents the hip from dislocating.
- Your operation and hospital physiotherapy will follow standard NHS routines.
- Follow-up checks happen at 4 and 12 months, usually by phone or post.
Who may be eligible?
You may be able to take part if you are 65 or older and have broken your hip inside the joint capsule within the last seven days. Your hospital surgical team must have already decided that a total hip replacement is the right standard treatment for your injury, following national NHS guidelines.
You cannot take part if your surgery has been delayed by more than a week since you arrived at hospital. The study is also not suitable for people whose break was caused by cancer or bone disease, or for people who already have metal plates or screws in that same hip from an earlier operation.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- Are you 65 years of age or older?
- Did you break your hip within the past 7 days?
- Has your doctor recommended a total hip replacement?
- Is this a new injury without any old metal plates or screws in the same hip?
- Was your fracture caused by an accident or fall rather than bone disease or cancer?
What does participation involve?
Taking part does not change your main hospital care. If you agree to join, a computer will randomly choose which of the two hip designs you receive. This ensures the comparison between the two groups is fair. Your surgery, anaesthetic, and hospital stay will follow normal NHS procedures, and you will receive standard physiotherapy to help you get back on your feet.
After you go home, the research team will contact you at 4 months and 12 months after your injury. These check-ins are usually done by post or over the telephone. You will be asked simple questions about your recovery, your walking ability, your general health, and whether you experienced any problems like a dislocated hip. In total, your participation lasts for 12 months.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (3)
- University Hospital of WalesApproximateCardiff, Wales
- Royal United Hospital, BathApproximateBath, England
- Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS TrustCity onlyTruro, England
Common questions
Will taking part delay my hip surgery?
No. Your operation will happen as quickly as normal according to standard hospital scheduling.
Can I choose which hip replacement I get?
No. A computer assigns the implant by chance. This makes sure the results of the study are completely fair and unbiased.
Do I have to attend extra hospital appointments?
No. The follow-up questions at 4 and 12 months are designed to be completed by post or over the phone.
What happens if my hip pops out of place?
You will receive immediate, standard NHS care to put the hip back into joint, regardless of which group you are in.
Will joining the study cost me anything?
No. All care is provided as part of your standard NHS treatment, and there are no extra costs to you.
How to find out more
Kate Herbert
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.