BigTOE Trial
Arthritis in the big toe joint is a very common condition that causes aching, stiffness, and swelling. It can make walking painful and interfere with work, hobbies, and everyday life. Doctors often recommend shoe inserts (insoles) to support the joint, but we do not yet know which type works best. The BigTOE trial is a UK research study run by the University of Warwick and funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research. It aims to test two different types of shoe inserts to see which is better at reducing pain and helping people stay active. Participants will be given a pair of shoe inserts to wear inside their normal footwear and asked to complete four short questionnaires over 12 months. The results will help the NHS choose the best treatments for people with big toe arthritis in the future.
At a glance
What is this study about?
Every time you take a step, your big toe joint bends and carries a significant amount of your body weight. When osteoarthritis develops in this joint, the smooth cartilage that cushions the bones wears down. This often leads to pain, swelling, and reduced movement, making ordinary tasks like walking to work, gardening, or shopping uncomfortable.
To manage this pain, healthcare teams in the NHS often prescribe shoe inserts. These inserts are designed to support the foot and change the way pressure is spread across the toe joint when walking. While many patients find them helpful, there has not been enough clear research comparing different designs to see which one works best.
The BigTOE trial was created to answer this question. By directly comparing two types of inserts already used in NHS clinics, researchers hope to discover which design offers the greatest pain relief and best improves everyday quality of life. The findings will help doctors and podiatrists make better, evidence-based recommendations for patients across the country.
Key takeaways
- The BigTOE trial is testing two common NHS shoe inserts to see which is better at relieving big toe arthritis pain.
- The study is open to adults aged 18 and over with persistent big toe joint pain.
- Participation lasts for 12 months and involves wearing the inserts and completing four brief questionnaires.
- The shoe inserts are already widely used in healthcare, and the risks of serious side effects are very low.
- The trial is funded by the NIHR and managed by the University of Warwick.
Who may be eligible?
You may be eligible to take part if you are 18 or older and have a diagnosis of osteoarthritis in one or both of your big toe joints. Your joint pain must be linked to activity, have lasted for at least three months, and be rated at least a 4 out of 10 on a pain scale.
You will not be able to take part if your joint stiffness in the morning lasts longer than 30 minutes, or if your pain is caused by other conditions such as gout, rheumatoid arthritis, or an infection. You are also not eligible if your pain is mainly underneath the ball of your toe rather than within the joint itself, or if you have moderate to severe bunions.
Finally, people who have had foot surgery in the past year, have surgery planned in the next 12 months, have received a steroid injection in the foot within the last three months, or have recently used prescribed medical insoles will not be able to join.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I am aged 18 or over.
- I have had pain in my big toe joint during activity for at least three months.
- My toe pain is at least a 4 on a scale of 0 to 10.
- My morning joint stiffness does not last longer than 30 minutes.
- I have not had foot surgery or a steroid foot injection in the past few months.
- I do not have inflammatory arthritis (such as rheumatoid arthritis), gout, or severe bunions.
What does participation involve?
If you join the trial, you will be given a pair of shoe inserts to wear inside your everyday footwear on your affected foot or feet. You will use these inserts as you go about your normal daily activities.
Your participation will last for 12 months. During this time, you will not need to take any new medications. You will be asked to fill out four questionnaires over the year to report how your toe feels, how easily you can walk, how the inserts feel, and whether your general health has changed. A small group of participants might also be invited to take part in a short, optional interview to talk about their experiences. You can decline this interview without leaving the trial.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (13)
- Midlands Partnership University NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyStafford, England
- University Hospital SouthamptonCity onlySouthampton, England
- East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust HqCity onlySt. Leonards-on-sea, England
- Dorset Healthcare University NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyPoole, England
- Salisbury District HospitalApproximateSalisbury, England
- Torbay HospitalUnverifiedTorquay, England
- Freeman HospitalUnverifiedNewcastle upon Tyne, England
- John Radcliffe HospitalUnverifiedOxford, England
- Hounslow and Richmond Community Healthcare NHS TrustUnverifiedTeddington, England
- Leeds Community Healthcare NHS TrustUnverifiedLeeds, England
- Walsgrave General HospitalUnverifiedCoventry, England
- Midlands Partnership University NHS Foundation TrustUnverifiedStafford, England
Common questions
Will I have to pay for the shoe inserts?
No. The shoe inserts used in the study are provided free of charge to all trial participants.
Can I choose which type of shoe insert I receive?
No. Participants are put into groups at random by a computer. This ensures the trial results are fair and reliable.
What should I do if the inserts cause blisters or discomfort?
If you experience irritation, rubbing, or worsening pain, you should contact the trial team or the clinic that gave you the inserts for advice.
Do I have to attend lots of hospital appointments?
Most of the study follow-up is done through questionnaires that you can complete from home over the course of the 12 months.
Can I stop taking part if I change my mind?
Yes. You have the right to withdraw from the study at any point, and doing so will not affect your standard NHS care.
How to find out more
Lauren Betteley
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Interested in taking part?
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.