A feasibility trial of psychological therapies for trauma survivors at risk of severe mental health difficulties
Going through distressing life events can take a lasting toll on mental health. Some people who have lived through trauma begin to experience unusual sensations or thoughts, such as hearing faint sounds, feeling confused, or feeling unsafe. In the NHS, this is sometimes called an 'at-risk mental state'. Standard care does not always directly address past trauma for people having these experiences. The RESTART study is finding out whether two established trauma therapies—Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (TF-CBT) and Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing (EMDR)—are safe, helpful, and easy to take part in. Participants aged 16 or older are placed by chance into one of three groups: receiving TF-CBT, receiving EMDR, or continuing with their usual NHS care alone. The results will help researchers design larger studies to improve NHS mental health services in the future.
At a glance
What is this study about?
Many people who go through scary or deeply distressing life events find that it affects their mental wellbeing much later in life. Sometimes, people begin to have unusual experiences. These might include hearing faint voices or noises that others do not hear, feeling like the world around them is altered, or feeling intensely suspicious and unsafe. Doctors often refer to this as an 'at-risk mental state' because it can occasionally lead to more severe mental health problems if left unsupported.
Even though past trauma is very common among people having these unusual experiences, standard NHS talking therapies do not always focus directly on traumatic memories. Two therapies known to help with trauma are Trauma-Focused Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (TF-CBT) and Eye Movement Desensitisation and Reprocessing (EMDR). TF-CBT helps people make sense of difficult memories through talking, while EMDR uses eye movements or other gentle taps to help the brain reprocess traumatic events.
This study, called the RESTART trial, is a 'feasibility' trial. This means researchers want to see whether offering these two therapies within NHS services is workable, acceptable to patients, and safe. The findings will help doctors and researchers understand if a much larger, nationwide NHS study should be run to bring trauma therapy to more people who need it.
Key takeaways
- The RESTART study tests two talking therapies (EMDR and TF-CBT) for people with past trauma who have unusual mental health experiences.
- It is open to people aged 16 and over supported by specific North West NHS mental health trusts.
- Participants are randomly assigned to receive up to 24 therapy sessions over nine months, or to carry on with usual care alone.
- All participants keep their normal NHS care, doctors, and medications throughout the trial.
- Taking part is entirely voluntary, and you can change your mind and leave at any time.
Who may be eligible?
This study is open to people aged 16 and over who are currently receiving care from participating NHS mental health teams in the North West of England. To take part, you must have experienced at least one traumatic or deeply distressing life event in the past, and you must currently be having unusual experiences (such as feeling confused, paranoid, or noticing strange sounds) that your care team considers an 'at-risk mental state'. Because assessments are currently only available in English, participants must be able to complete sessions in English without an interpreter.
The study is not suitable for people who have already had a full-blown, diagnosed episode of psychosis lasting a week or more, or those who have taken higher doses of antipsychotic medication for several weeks. It is also not suitable for people who are currently in an acute mental health crisis, have had a recent suicide attempt within the past two months, or do not have stable housing, as safety and stability are essential before starting trauma-focused therapy.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I am aged 16 or older.
- I have lived through a stressful, frightening, or traumatic event in my past.
- I am having unusual thoughts, sounds, or experiences (assessed as an 'at-risk mental state').
- I am currently receiving support from an NHS mental health team in the North West of England.
- I am not currently in an immediate mental health crisis and have safe, stable living arrangements.
What does participation involve?
If you are interested, you will first meet with a researcher to talk about your experiences, your past, and your current NHS care to see if the study is right for you. If it is, you will complete some questionnaires and then be assigned by chance (randomised) to one of three groups: TF-CBT plus your usual care, EMDR plus your usual care, or usual care alone.
If you are placed in one of the therapy groups, you will be offered up to 24 sessions over nine months with a qualified trial therapist. Sessions last around 90 minutes each and can happen in person, over the phone, or by video call. You and your therapist will decide together how often you meet. If you are in the usual care group, you will continue your normal NHS support without trial therapy.
Everyone continues with their standard NHS appointments, support workers, and medications as normal throughout the study. Around nine months after joining, you will meet a researcher again to complete follow-up questionnaires. You may also be invited to share your thoughts about how the study went. With your permission, the research team will briefly check your NHS health records at 12 months to see how you are doing.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (5)
- Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyManchester, England
- Manchester University NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyManchester, England
- Pennine Care NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyAshton-under-lyne, England
- Mersey Care NHS Foundation TrustApproximatePrescot, England
- Lancashire and South Cumbria NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyPreston, England
Common questions
Will I have to stop taking my usual medication?
No. You will continue with all your usual NHS care, including any prescribed medications and regular appointments with your doctor or care coordinator.
Can I choose which therapy group I join?
No. A computer randomly decides which group you are in to ensure the comparison is scientifically fair. You have an equal chance of receiving EMDR, TF-CBT, or usual care alone.
What happens if talking about the past becomes too upsetting?
Therapists and researchers are specially trained to go at your pace and keep you feeling safe. If you feel overwhelmed, you can stop the session, take a break, or leave the study completely at any point.
Does taking part cost anything?
No, taking part is completely free as part of this NHS-supported research project.
Will my personal details remain confidential?
Yes. All your research information is kept strictly confidential and stored securely. Any reports published about the study will not identify you in any way.
How to find out more
Aidan Flinn
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.