All studies
CompletedObservational

Comparing the accuracy of hospital clinic notes written by an AI medical scribe with notes written by doctors

When you visit a hospital doctor, they spend a lot of time writing down what was said. Sometimes important details can be missed, or small errors can slip into the notes. This study, called SHADOW, is testing an artificial intelligence (AI) tool called Heidi to see if it can listen to consultations and write accurate notes. Taking part will not change your medical care. If you agree to join, your normal hospital appointment at NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde will be recorded using a small microphone. Your doctor will write their normal notes, while the AI drafts its own set in the background. Hospital staff will only use your doctor's notes for your treatment; the AI notes are kept purely for research. Afterwards, independent doctors will compare both sets of notes against a written transcript to see which is more accurate. The audio recording is deleted once transcribed.

At a glance

What is this study about?

Doctors in NHS hospitals have to spend a large part of their day writing down medical notes after seeing each patient. Because consultations move quickly, it can be hard to capture every detail perfectly. Important information is sometimes missed, or notes can contain accidental errors. Finding safe ways to make note-taking faster and more reliable could give clinicians more time to focus on caring for patients.

This research project, called the SHADOW study, tests an artificial intelligence (AI) tool called Heidi. The tool works like an assistant: it listens to the conversation between you and your clinician and drafts a set of clinical notes. Researchers want to compare the AI-generated notes directly against notes written by hospital doctors to see which version has fewer mistakes and whether the notes are clear and safe.

Taking part in this study will not change your treatment in any way. The AI notes are created only for research purposes and will never be used to make decisions about your health. Your hospital doctor will write their usual notes as they always do, and only those standard notes will go into your official medical record.

Key takeaways

  • Tests whether an AI assistant can write hospital notes as accurately as human doctors.
  • Open to adults attending selected in-person appointments at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow.
  • Involves recording a single, routine hospital appointment with no extra visits or tests.
  • The AI notes are strictly for research and are never used in your medical care.
  • Audio files are permanently deleted once they have been turned into typed text.

Who may be eligible?

You may be able to take part if you are aged 18 or older and are attending an in-person hospital appointment within NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde, such as at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital. This includes visits to the Emergency Department, Same Day Emergency Care, hospital wards, or outpatient clinics.

Because the AI tool is currently being tested on English-language consultations, your appointment must be held in English. You must also be well enough to understand what the study involves and be able to give your own written consent.

You cannot take part if your appointment takes place over the phone, if you need a translator, or if poor sound quality makes it impossible to record clearly. People who are temporarily unable to make their own decisions due to severe illness, confusion, or distress will also not be included.

Could this study suit you?

Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.

  1. You are aged 18 or over.
  2. You are attending an in-person appointment at Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow.
  3. Your consultation will be spoken in English.
  4. You feel well enough to understand the study and make your own decision about taking part.
Answer every question to see your result.

What does participation involve?

Taking part happens entirely during your scheduled hospital visit. There are no extra hospital trips, blood tests, or follow-up appointments. Before your consultation, a researcher will give you an information sheet, answer any questions, and ask you to sign a consent form. During your visit, a small microphone will record the conversation between you and your clinician while your appointment carries on as normal. Your clinician writes their notes as usual, and the AI drafts a separate version in the background. Once your appointment is finished, your role in the study is complete. The research team converts the recording into a written transcript and deletes the audio file.

Potential risks and benefits

You will not receive any direct medical benefit from joining the study, but your help could show whether AI can safely reduce paperwork for NHS staff and free up more time for future patients. There is no risk to your health or treatment because the AI notes are never used in your care. The main consideration is your privacy, as your appointment will be recorded. To protect your details, recordings are kept securely in the UK, the audio file is deleted as soon as it is transcribed, and your personal details are removed before the notes are checked. Taking part is completely voluntary, and you can change your mind and withdraw at any time without it affecting your medical care.

Locations (1)

  • Queen Elizabeth University Hospital
    Approximate
    Glasgow, Scotland

Common questions

Will the AI make any decisions about my care?

No. The AI notes are created purely for this research project. Your doctor will not see them, and they will never be used to plan or deliver your treatment.

Who will listen to my voice recording?

Nobody listens to your recording for entertainment or marketing. The audio is run through a secure system to make a written text transcript, and the audio recording is deleted straight afterwards.

Will taking part make my hospital visit take longer?

No. The recording takes place during your scheduled consultation, so taking part does not add extra time to your hospital visit.

What happens if I change my mind during the visit?

You can tell the staff to stop the recording at any moment. You do not need to give a reason, and it will not affect your care in any way.

Does it cost anything to take part?

No. Taking part is free, and because it happens during your regular appointment, there are no extra travel costs involved.

How to find out more

Benjamin Austin

Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.

Discussion

Community discussion

Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.