All studies
CompletedInterventional

Talking With Voices II

Hearing voices can be very upsetting and can make everyday life difficult. Standard treatments like medication and regular talking therapies can help, but they do not work for everyone. Voices are often linked to past stressful events or trauma, which can make them harder to manage. The 'Talking With Voices II' study is testing a new psychological treatment in the NHS. Instead of trying to ignore the voices, a therapist speaks directly to them, while the person repeats what the voices say out loud. The goal is to build a calmer, more peaceful relationship between the person and their voices. The study is for adults aged 16 and over who have heard distressing voices for at least a year. Half of the participants will receive their usual NHS mental health care, and the other half will receive their usual care plus up to 26 sessions of this new therapy.

At a glance

Status
Completed
Sponsor
Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Foundation Trust
Enrolment target
296
Start
01 Sep 2023
Estimated completion
30 Jun 2025

What is this study about?

Hearing voices, also called auditory hallucinations, is a common experience for people with conditions like schizophrenia, but it can also affect people with other mental health difficulties. For many, voices are tied to past trauma or periods of extreme stress. The things the voices say can echo these painful memories, making them very difficult to cope with. This can lead to problems with sleep, work, relationships, and emotional wellbeing.

Most current treatments focus on dampening voices with medication or challenging unhelpful thoughts using cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). However, these options do not suit everyone, and they do not always address the specific meaning behind what the voices are saying. The 'Talking With Voices' therapy takes a different approach. It views voices as meaningful responses to life events. During sessions, the therapist talks directly to the voices with the person's permission, asking questions while the person repeats the answers back. Over time, the aim is to help the person understand their voices, reduce fear, and regain a sense of peace.

An earlier study showed that this therapy is safe and practical to run in the NHS. This larger trial is taking place to see whether it genuinely helps a wider group of people feel better and get on with their lives. By comparing people who receive the therapy to those who receive standard NHS care, researchers can find out if this approach should be offered more widely across the UK health service.

Key takeaways

  • Tests a new NHS talking therapy that communicates directly with distressing voices.
  • Aims to help people develop a calmer, more manageable relationship with their voices.
  • Open to people aged 16 and over who have heard distressing voices for at least a year.
  • Participants continue with their usual NHS care, with half also receiving up to 26 therapy sessions.
  • Taking part is voluntary, and you can withdraw at any time without losing your regular care.

Who may be eligible?

This study is open to adults aged 16 and over in the UK who are in touch with NHS mental health services and have been for at least six months. You must have been hearing distressing voices for at least a year and be looking for support to manage them. Because of how the therapy works, you need to feel able and willing to listen to your voices and repeat what they say out loud to a therapist.

The study is not suitable for people who are currently having another individual talking therapy. It is also not open to anyone who has a moderate or severe learning disability, people who do not have a fixed address, or those whose voices are caused by a physical brain condition or severe drug or alcohol dependence.

Finally, for safety reasons, the study cannot accept individuals who are currently in crisis or at immediate risk of harming themselves or other people.

Could this study suit you?

Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.

  1. I am aged 16 or over.
  2. I have been hearing distressing voices for at least 12 months.
  3. I have been supported by NHS mental health services for at least six months.
  4. I am willing and able to repeat what my voices say out loud to a therapist.
  5. I am not currently receiving another one-to-one talking therapy.
Answer every question to see your result.

What does participation involve?

Taking part lasts for about eight months. If you join, you will continue with your normal NHS mental health care and any medications you currently take. A computer system will randomly place you into one of two groups. One group continues with their usual care alone. The other group receives usual care plus the 'Talking With Voices' therapy.

If you are selected to receive the therapy, you will attend up to 26 one-hour sessions over an eight-month period with a specially trained therapist. Everyone in the study, no matter which group they are in, will complete research questionnaires and interviews at the start, partway through, and at the end. These check-ins help the researchers see how you are feeling and measure whether the therapy makes a positive difference.

Potential risks and benefits

Taking part may help you understand your experiences better, and if you receive the therapy, it may help you feel calmer and more in control of your voices. The information gathered will also help improve NHS treatments for others in the future. However, because this is a trial, benefits cannot be guaranteed. Talking about voices and past painful events can feel challenging or emotionally draining at times. You will be supported by trained professionals throughout, and you are free to step back or leave the study at any time without it affecting your standard NHS care.

Locations (4)

  • Prestwich Hospital
    Approximate
    Manchester, England
  • St Nicholas Hospital
    Approximate
    Newcastle upon Tyne, England
  • Warneford Hospital
    Approximate
    Oxford, England
  • Maudsley Hospital
    Approximate
    London, England

Common questions

Do I need to stop taking my mental health medication?

No. You will continue to take your prescribed medication and receive your usual NHS care throughout the trial.

Can I choose whether I receive the new therapy?

No. A computer puts people into groups by chance. This fair comparison is the only way researchers can tell if the new therapy truly helps.

What happens if talking to my voices feels too upsetting?

You are always in control of the pace. The therapist will support you, and you can take breaks or stop the session whenever you need to.

Does it cost anything to take part?

No. The trial is funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) and is free to take part in through the NHS.

What happens if I change my mind after joining?

You are completely free to leave the study at any point. Leaving will not change or harm your normal NHS mental health support in any way.

How to find out more

Eleanor Longden

Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.

Discussion

Community discussion

Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.