Female urgency, trial of Urodynamics as routine evaluation
Overactive bladder causes a sudden, urgent need to pass urine, often leading to leaks and frequent toilet trips. While lifestyle changes and tablets help many women, they do not work for everyone. When symptoms continue, doctors may consider next-step treatments such as bladder injections or nerve stimulation. Before starting these treatments, doctors often carry out a test called urodynamics. This measures bladder pressure using small tubes, but it can be uncomfortable, carries a small risk of infection, and often does not give a clear answer. This study compares two approaches: receiving standard clinical checks alone versus having standard checks plus the urodynamics test. Women aged 18 and over who still have troublesome symptoms will be randomly placed into one of the two groups. Researchers will track their symptoms using postal questionnaires over 15 months to see which approach works best.
At a glance
What is this study about?
Overactive bladder (OAB) affects more than one in ten adult women in the UK. Common symptoms include an overwhelming urge to pass urine, leaking before reaching the toilet, and waking up multiple times during the night. These symptoms can be distressing and make working, travelling, and socialising difficult.
Doctors usually recommend simple steps first, such as drinking less caffeine, pelvic floor exercises, and prescription medications. However, around one in three women find that these treatments do not provide enough relief. For these women, advanced treatments like Botox injections into the bladder wall or small nerve-stimulating implants may be considered.
Before offering advanced options, standard medical guidelines often suggest an invasive test called urodynamics. This involves inserting two very thin tubes—one into the bladder and one into the back passage—to measure pressure and check for leaks. Many women find the test embarrassing or painful, and some develop bladder infections afterwards. Moreover, in nearly 40% of cases, the test fails to show what is causing the problem.
This trial aims to find out whether routinely doing this test actually leads to better treatment decisions and better quality of life for women, or whether standard specialist assessments without the invasive test work just as well.
Key takeaways
- The study explores whether an invasive bladder pressure test (urodynamics) is truly necessary before advanced treatments.
- Open to women with overactive bladder that has not improved with pelvic floor exercises and at least two medications.
- Half of the participants receive standard clinical checks, while the other half also have the urodynamics test.
- Follow-up is done entirely from home using postal questionnaires over 15 months.
- Taking part is voluntary and does not change your right to standard NHS treatment.
Who may be eligible?
This study is open to women aged 18 and older who have persistent overactive bladder symptoms where a sudden, uncontrollable urge to pass urine is their main problem. To be eligible, you should have already tried pelvic floor exercises, bladder training, and at least two different bladder medications without finding enough relief, and you are now being considered for next-step treatments.
You cannot join this study if your main symptom is leaking when you cough, sneeze, or exercise (stress incontinence), or if you have had a urodynamics test in the past 12 months. Women who have had bladder Botox or nerve stimulation implants in the past, or who have neurological conditions like Parkinson's disease or spinal injuries, are also not eligible.
In addition, you cannot take part if you are pregnant, planning a pregnancy, currently have bladder pain syndrome, have had pelvic cancer or radiation therapy, or suffer from severe prolapse.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I am a woman aged 18 or older.
- My most bothersome bladder problem is a sudden, urgent need to wee (with or without leaks).
- I have tried lifestyle changes, pelvic floor training, and at least two different bladder tablets without success.
- I am currently discussing advanced treatments (like Botox or nerve stimulation) with my doctor.
- I have not had a urodynamics test in the last 12 months.
- I am not pregnant and do not have a neurological condition like Parkinson's or a spinal injury.
What does participation involve?
If you take part, you will be randomly assigned to one of two groups by a computer, giving you a 50/50 chance of being in either group. Women in the first group will receive a comprehensive clinical assessment with their specialist as part of standard NHS care. Women in the second group will have the same clinical assessment plus the urodynamics test.
After your initial assessment and test, your doctors will discuss your treatment plan with you as normal. Your ongoing medical care will continue through your local hospital. You will not need to attend extra hospital visits purely for the study; instead, researchers will send you questionnaires in the post at 3, 6, and 15 months. These surveys will ask about your bladder symptoms, daily quality of life, and your thoughts on your care. Your participation lasts for about 15 months in total.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (7)
- Aberdeen Royal InfirmaryApproximateAberdeen, Scotland
- Royal Hallamshire HospitalApproximateSheffield, England
- Queen Elizabeth University HospitalApproximateGlasgow, Scotland
- Southmead Hospital BristolApproximateBristol, England
- St Mary’s HospitalApproximateManchester, England
- Princess Anne HospitalUnverifiedSouthampton, England
- Royal Victoria InfirmaryUnverifiedNewcastle upon Tyne, England
Common questions
What is a urodynamics test?
It is a hospital test that checks how well your bladder holds and releases urine. It involves gently placing a tiny tube into your bladder and another into your back passage to measure pressure while your bladder is slowly filled with fluid.
Will taking part delay my bladder treatment?
No. The study runs alongside your normal NHS appointments, and you will proceed to discuss advanced treatment options with your clinical team without unnecessary delays.
Can I choose whether I have the urodynamics test?
No. A computer randomly decides which group you join. This is necessary so researchers can fairly compare how well patients do with and without the test.
What happens if I develop a urine infection after the test?
If you have the test and develop symptoms of a water infection (such as stinging or fever), your hospital team or GP can test your urine and prescribe antibiotics if needed.
Will I have to travel for extra appointments?
No. Follow-ups are completed at home using simple paper questionnaires sent to your address at 3, 6, and 15 months.
How to find out more
Suzanne Breeman
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.