Can we save the rectum by watchful waiting or transanal surgery following (chemo)radiotherapy versus total mesorectal excision for early rectal cancer?
The STAR-TREC study is researching new ways to treat early-stage rectal cancer. The usual treatment is major surgery to remove the rectum (total mesorectal excision). While this operation cures many people, it can cause lasting bowel problems or mean living with a stoma bag. This trial compares standard surgery against gentler options aimed at saving the rectum. Patients in the trial receive either standard surgery or a course of radiotherapy (sometimes combined with chemotherapy tablets). If radiotherapy shrinks or completely clears the tumour, patients might only need a minor procedure through the bottom or careful monitoring instead of major surgery. Researchers want to find out if these organ-saving treatments are just as safe and effective at stopping cancer from returning, while offering patients a better long-term quality of life.
At a glance
What is this study about?
Bowel cancer is one of the most common cancers in the UK. The rectum is the lower part of the bowel that stores poo before it leaves your body. When rectal cancer is found early, the standard treatment is a major operation known as total mesorectal excision. During this surgery, doctors remove the rectum and surrounding tissue. While this operation is very successful at treating cancer, it is a big procedure. It can lead to long hospital stays, changes in how your bowel works, and sometimes the permanent need for a stoma bag.
Doctors are now exploring whether some people with early rectal cancer can safely avoid this major operation. Modern radiotherapy and chemotherapy can be very effective at shrinking tumours. In some cases, the cancer disappears completely after treatment. The STAR-TREC study was designed to compare standard major surgery against two different radiotherapy-based approaches aimed at 'saving the rectum'.
In the study, people receiving radiotherapy have their cancer checked carefully after treatment. If the tumour has completely gone, they may be offered close monitoring (often called 'watchful waiting') without any surgery at all. If a small lump remains, doctors may be able to remove it using a minor procedure through the back passage, rather than major abdominal surgery. The overall goal is to see if doctors can cure the cancer just as well while preserving normal bowel function and improving overall quality of life.
Key takeaways
- STAR-TREC is testing whether radiotherapy can replace major surgery for early rectal cancer.
- The primary aim is to safely preserve the rectum and avoid a permanent stoma bag.
- Patients whose tumours disappear may be monitored closely without needing an operation.
- The study is suitable for adults with early-stage, biopsy-proven rectal cancer who are otherwise relatively fit.
- Participation is entirely voluntary, and standard surgery remains available if needed.
Who may be eligible?
This trial is for adults in the UK (aged 16 and over) who have recently been diagnosed with early-stage adenocarcinoma of the rectum. The tumour must be confirmed by a biopsy and must not have spread deeply into surrounding tissues or to other parts of the body, as checked by an MRI scan or ultrasound.
To take part, your hospital cancer team (multidisciplinary team) must agree that all the trial treatments are safe and suitable options for you. You also need to be reasonably active and well enough to carry out daily tasks, and able to attend regular hospital appointments.
You cannot join if the cancer has spread further, or if you have had certain other cancers recently. Because radiotherapy can harm an unborn baby, women who could become pregnant will need a negative pregnancy test, and both men and women taking part must agree to use reliable contraception during and shortly after treatment.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I have been diagnosed with early-stage rectal cancer confirmed by a biopsy.
- My cancer has been checked with an MRI or ultrasound and has not spread to distant organs.
- I am aged 16 or over and live in the UK.
- I am well enough to look after myself and attend regular hospital visits.
- I am willing to use reliable contraception during the trial if relevant to me.
What does participation involve?
If you join the study, you will be placed into a treatment group. Depending on your group, you may have standard surgery to remove the rectum, a short course of radiotherapy, or a longer course of radiotherapy combined with chemotherapy tablets. Radiotherapy is given as outpatient visits at the hospital. If you receive radiotherapy, you will have detailed checks a few weeks later, including MRI scans, camera tests (endoscopy), and physical exams to see how well the tumour has responded.
If the tumour has cleared completely, you will be monitored very closely with regular scans and check-ups rather than having surgery. If a small amount remains, you may have a minor operation through your bottom to remove it. If the cancer does not shrink enough, you can still have standard surgery. Follow-up continues for several years to make sure the cancer has not returned and to monitor your bowel health, with check-up visits every few months at first.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (34)
- Cardiff & Vale Health BoardCity onlyCardiff, Wales
- Velindre NHS TrustCity onlyCardiff, Wales
- Manchester University NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyManchester, England
- The Christie NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyManchester, England
- East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyColchester, England
- University Hospitals Birmingham NHS TrustUnverifiedBirmingham, England
- University Hospitals Birmingham NHS TrustUnverifiedColdfield, England
- The Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS TrustUnverifiedLeeds, England
- Tayside Health BoardUnverifiedDundee, Scotland
- Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals NHS Foundation TrustUnverifiedNorwich, England
- North Bristol NHS TrustUnverifiedBristol, England
- Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation TrustUnverifiedOxford, England
Common questions
What is the main goal of the STAR-TREC trial?
The study aims to find out if radiotherapy can treat early rectal cancer effectively so that patients can avoid major surgery and keep their rectum.
Will I definitely avoid major surgery if I take part?
Not necessarily. If your cancer does not shrink enough after radiotherapy, or if it grows back later, your doctors will recommend standard surgery to keep you safe.
What is 'watchful waiting'?
Watchful waiting means having very frequent scans and camera checks to ensure the cancer has not returned, avoiding surgery as long as there is no sign of disease.
Can I choose which treatment I receive?
The trial compares different approaches. Your doctors will discuss the study design with you, including how treatment groups are decided and what options are open to you.
What happens if I change my mind during the study?
You are free to leave the trial at any point. Your hospital team will support your decision and provide the standard NHS care best suited to your needs.
How to find out more
Simon Bach
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.