Frozen-thawed embryo transfer in a natural versus artificial cycle: a randomized clinical trial.
When having fertility treatment with frozen embryos, doctors need to prepare the lining of your womb so the embryo can attach safely. There are two main ways to do this: following your natural monthly cycle or using hormone medicines to control the timing artificially. This clinical trial compares these two methods directly to see which one works best. Women taking part will be placed by chance into one of two groups. One group uses their natural cycle, while the other takes hormone tablets and vaginal capsules (Progynova and Utrogestan). Researchers will track success rates, looking closely at healthy pregnancies with a detectable heartbeat, live birth rates, and any complications during pregnancy or birth. They will also look at clinic visits, costs, and how satisfied women feel with their care.
At a glance
What is this study about?
For many people trying to start a family, in vitro fertilisation (IVF) involves freezing healthy embryos to transfer back into the womb at a later date. Before doctors can move an embryo into the womb, the lining of the womb must be thick and ready to receive it. Currently, clinics prepare the womb in different ways, and doctors want to know if one method offers a better chance of a healthy baby.
One common option is a 'natural cycle', which relies on your own body's natural hormones and egg-release schedule to time the transfer. The other option is an 'artificial cycle', where you take hormone medicines—specifically oestrogen tablets and progesterone capsules—to build up the womb lining and control the exact timing. Both methods are widely used, but it is still unclear whether one method leads to better success rates or fewer complications.
This trial compares the two approaches side by side. By gathering detailed information from participants, researchers hope to discover which method gives the highest chance of a positive pregnancy test and a healthy heartbeat. They also want to understand which option is more comfortable for patients, requires fewer hospital visits, and leads to the safest outcomes for both mother and baby throughout pregnancy.
Key takeaways
- The trial compares natural and medicated methods for frozen embryo transfers.
- It aims to find out which method leads to higher pregnancy rates and safer births.
- Participants are assigned to either a natural or hormone-assisted group at random.
- Both methods are already commonly used in routine fertility care.
- Taking part is voluntary, and you can withdraw at any time without losing your care.
Who may be eligible?
This study is open to adult women aged 18 and older who are having fertility treatment and plan to have a frozen-thawed embryo transfer.
Because this study compares natural menstrual cycles with medicated cycles, participants will generally need to have predictable periods to be considered for the natural cycle group. Your fertility team will review your medical history and past treatments to see if taking part is suitable for you.
Women who are unable to take hormone medications or who have specific medical conditions affecting the womb lining may not be able to take part. Your clinic team will guide you through all the details before you make any decisions.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I am a woman aged 18 or older.
- I am planning to have a frozen embryo transfer (FET).
- I am currently receiving care for fertility challenges.
- I have regular monthly periods (required for the natural cycle option).
- I am able to attend regular clinic appointments for monitoring scans.
What does participation involve?
If you join the trial, you will be placed into one of two groups at random, like flipping a coin. If you are in the natural cycle group, your clinic will monitor your body's natural cycle using ultrasound scans and blood tests to pinpoint the right day for transfer. If you are in the artificial cycle group, you will take hormone tablets called Progynova to prepare your womb, followed by Utrogestan vaginal capsules to support the transfer.
During your cycle, you will visit the clinic for monitoring scans to check the thickness of your womb lining. Once the lining is ready, your frozen embryo will be thawed and transferred into your womb during a routine, short procedure.
After the transfer, you will have a pregnancy test. If you become pregnant, the study team will follow your progress through early scans to check for a heartbeat, and track your health through pregnancy and delivery. Total participation lasts from the start of your treatment cycle until after your baby is born, or until a negative test result.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (1)
- —UnverifiedBelgium
Common questions
What is the main difference between the two cycles?
A natural cycle relies on your own body's hormones and natural ovulation, while an artificial cycle uses hormone tablets and capsules to prepare the womb lining.
Can I choose which group I am in?
No. A computer randomly decides which group you join so the comparison remains fair and scientifically accurate.
What medications are used in the artificial cycle?
The trial uses Progynova (oestrogen) tablets to build the womb lining and Utrogestan (progesterone) capsules placed in the vagina to prepare for embryo implantation.
Will taking part lower my chances of getting pregnant?
Both methods are already standard, widely used options in fertility clinics worldwide, so you will receive proven care either way.
What happens if my cycle is cancelled?
If your womb lining does not develop as needed, your doctor may pause the cycle for your safety and try again later. Your team will support you throughout.
How to find out more
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Interested in taking part?
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.