All studies
CompletedInterventional

Surgery for knee articular cartilage injuries

Damage to the smooth cartilage lining your knee joint can cause long-term pain and make walking difficult. Because cartilage has no direct blood supply, it struggles to heal on its own. A common NHS operation called microfracture creates tiny holes in the bone to release healing cells that encourage new tissue to grow. Surgeons can also place a natural patch, called a scaffold, over the area to help guide tissue growth. However, this patch adds about 20 minutes to the operation and costs roughly £900. This study compares standard microfracture against microfracture with the patch. Participants are placed into one of the two treatment groups by chance. Researchers will follow each person's progress over two years to find out if the patch provides better pain relief and helps people return to their normal lives.

At a glance

Status
Completed
Sponsor
North Bristol NHS Trust
Enrolment target
176
Start
28 Oct 2021
Estimated completion
25 Oct 2022

What is this study about?

Knee cartilage is a tough, slippery layer that cushions the ends of your bones so your joint can move smoothly. When cartilage gets damaged through an injury or wear and tear, it can cause persistent swelling, catching, and pain. Because cartilage lacks a natural blood supply, the body cannot easily heal these damaged patches on its own. Each year in the UK, around 10,000 people have severe knee cartilage damage that needs surgical care.

One common way surgeons treat this is with an operation called microfracture. During this procedure, the surgeon makes tiny holes in the surface of the bone underneath the damaged area. This allows blood and bone marrow cells to seep out, stimulating the body to build new repair tissue. In recent years, surgeons have also started placing a biological mesh, known as a collagen scaffold, over the holes to act as a template for the new tissue.

Adding this scaffold makes the operation slightly longer and costs the NHS about £900 per patient. At present, doctors do not know for sure whether adding the scaffold actually leads to better long-term pain relief or joint function than microfracture alone. This trial aims to answer that question so the NHS can provide the most effective treatment for future patients.

Key takeaways

  • Compares standard microfracture knee surgery against microfracture with an added collagen patch (scaffold).
  • Aims to discover if the £900 scaffold provides better healing, less pain, and good value for the NHS.
  • Open to adults aged 18 and older with knee cartilage damage measuring 4 cm² or less.
  • Participants are assigned to one of the two surgical options by random selection.
  • Follow-up appointments and health questionnaires take place over a two-year period.

Who may be eligible?

This study is open to adults aged 18 and older who have painful cartilage damage on the thigh bone (femur) or kneecap (patella). The damaged area must measure 4 square centimetres or smaller once the surgeon cleans the joint surface.

You cannot join the study if you have an untreated ligament injury or an untreated tear in the meniscus (the shock-absorbing cartilage in the knee). It is also not suitable for people who have lost more than half of their meniscus from past operations, or whose leg bones are out of alignment and require corrective surgery.

Additionally, you cannot take part if the damaged patch has already been treated with microfracture or a scaffold in the past, or if the cartilage damage is on the top of the shin bone (tibia).

Could this study suit you?

Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.

  1. You are aged 18 or older.
  2. You have ongoing knee pain caused by a diagnosed cartilage defect.
  3. The damaged area of cartilage is small to medium-sized (under 4 cm²).
  4. You do not have an untreated knee ligament or meniscus tear.
  5. You have not had microfracture or scaffold surgery on the same knee patch before.
Answer every question to see your result.

What does participation involve?

If you take part, you will be placed into one of two groups by a computer system to ensure the test is completely fair. One group receives standard microfracture surgery, while the other receives microfracture plus the collagen scaffold. Both operations are performed in hospital under anaesthetic. After your surgery, you will attend hospital follow-up visits at 3 months, 6 months, 1 year, and 2 years. The first three visits match routine NHS care, while the 2-year appointment is an extra check-up for the study (for which reasonable travel costs are refunded). At each visit, you will complete questionnaires asking about your knee pain, everyday activities, ability to work, and any other healthcare appointments you have needed. Your involvement lasts for two years in total.

Potential risks and benefits

You may not receive any direct personal benefit from taking part, but the information collected will help improve knee surgery for NHS patients in the future. Both surgical options carry standard surgical risks, such as infection, bleeding, joint stiffness, or the cartilage failing to heal fully. If you receive the scaffold, your operation may take about 20 minutes longer. Taking part is entirely voluntary, and you are free to leave the study at any time without your regular NHS care or your relationship with your doctors being affected.

Locations (1)

Some site locations are approximate. We're improving this — please verify with the trial team before travelling.
  • North Bristol NHS Trust
    City only
    Bristol, England

Common questions

Why does knee cartilage have trouble healing on its own?

Unlike skin or muscle, cartilage does not have blood vessels running through it. Without blood flow, the body cannot easily deliver the nutrients and healing cells needed to repair damaged tissue.

What is microfracture surgery?

It is an operation where a surgeon creates tiny pricks in the bone beneath the damaged cartilage. This allows bone marrow and blood to seep out, encouraging new scar-cartilage to form.

What is a cartilage scaffold?

A scaffold is a small patch made of collagen (the natural protein found in joints). It covers the microfracture holes to hold healing cells in place and guide new tissue growth.

Can I choose whether I get the scaffold?

No. A computer allocates participants randomly to either microfracture alone or microfracture with a scaffold. This ensures the results are completely unbiased.

Will joining this study cost me anything?

No. Your surgery and regular visits are part of normal NHS care. For the extra study visit at two years, reasonable travel expenses will be paid.

How to find out more

Lucy Dabner

Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.

Discussion

Community discussion

Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.