Should we replace the back of the knee cap all of the time or some of the time in patients having knee replacement surgery? A trial comparing patient outcomes and the cost to the NHS.
Knee replacement is a very common NHS operation to treat pain and stiffness from severe arthritis. During surgery, doctors replace the worn ends of your thigh and shin bones. However, surgeons disagree on what to do with the kneecap. Some believe the underside of the kneecap should always be replaced with a plastic cap. Others prefer to decide during surgery, only replacing it if it looks badly damaged. This trial compares both approaches across several NHS hospitals in England. Half of the patients will have their kneecap resurfaced as standard. For the other half, the surgeon will decide during the operation. Aside from this, everyone receives standard surgical and recovery care. By filling out questionnaires over 12 months, participants help researchers discover which approach gives better long-term pain relief, fewer complications, and the best value for money for the NHS.
At a glance
What is this study about?
Severe knee arthritis can make simple tasks like walking or climbing stairs painful and tiring. A total knee replacement helps restore movement and reduce pain by replacing worn joint surfaces with artificial parts. During this routine operation, surgeons also inspect the back of your kneecap. Some surgeons always attach a smooth artificial surface to it, while others only do this if the natural kneecap is worn down. Both methods are widely used and safe, but experts want clearer evidence on which approach works best.
This clinical study, known as the PART trial, aims to resolve this uncertainty. By comparing these two common surgical choices directly, doctors can see whether always resurfacing the kneecap leads to better everyday function, or if leaving a healthy kneecap alone is just as effective.
Finding the best approach matters deeply for future knee replacement patients and the NHS. If one method consistently provides better pain relief and prevents the need for future operations, it could become the clear standard of care across the country. It also helps the NHS spend its budget wisely by avoiding unnecessary steps during surgery.
Key takeaways
- Compares two standard, safe ways surgeons treat the kneecap during knee replacement.
- Aims to discover which method gives better pain relief and mobility over 12 months.
- Open to adults in England having a first-time total knee replacement for arthritis.
- Requires no extra hospital visits; follow-up is done via home questionnaires at 3, 6, and 12 months.
- Taking part is voluntary and will not change your standard hospital recovery or care.
Who may be eligible?
You may be able to join this study if you are 18 or older, live in England, and are planning to have a standard, first-time total knee replacement on the NHS for common wear-and-tear arthritis (osteoarthritis).
You will not be eligible if you are having a partial knee replacement, a repeat operation to fix a previous replacement (revision surgery), or if you have had a past joint infection. You also cannot take part if you need special hinged joint parts, or if your surgeon finds during surgery that your kneecap bone is too thin to safely attach a new surface.
To take part, you must be able to give your informed consent and be happy to complete short follow-up questionnaires over the year following your operation.
Could this study suit you?
Answer these quick questions to see if you may be eligible. This is a guide only — the research team makes the final call.
- I am aged 18 or older.
- I am scheduled for a first-time total knee replacement on the NHS in England.
- My knee problem is caused by primary osteoarthritis (wear-and-tear arthritis).
- I have not had a replacement or severe infection in this knee before.
- I am willing and able to complete three short follow-up surveys over the next year.
What does participation involve?
If you agree to take part, you will be placed into one of two groups by chance, like flipping a coin. In one group, the surgeon will always replace the back of your kneecap. In the other group, your surgeon will look at your kneecap during surgery and decide whether it needs resurfacing. You will receive the same standard hospital care, anaesthetic, and physiotherapy as any other knee replacement patient.
Taking part will not require any extra hospital visits beyond your normal routine appointments. You will be asked to fill out short questionnaires at 3, 6, and 12 months after your surgery. These can be completed at home and ask about your knee pain, how easily you can move around, your general health, and any extra care you may have needed. Your active involvement in the study finishes once you complete the 12-month survey.
Potential risks and benefits
Locations (23)
- Bedfordshire Hospitals NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyLuton, England
- Milton Keynes University Hospital NHS Foundation TrustCity onlyMilton Keynes, England
- Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation TrustCity onlySheffield, England
- North Bristol NHS TrustCity onlyBristol, England
- Musgrove Park Hospital (taunton)ApproximateTaunton, England
- Royal Liverpool University HospitalUnverifiedLiverpool, England
- Royal Cornwall Hospital (treliske)UnverifiedTruro, England
- Walsgrave General HospitalUnverifiedCoventry, England
- Darent Valley HospitalUnverifiedDartford, England
- Salisbury District HospitalUnverifiedSalisbury, England
- York HospitalUnverifiedYork, England
- University Hospital LewishamUnverifiedLondon, England
Common questions
Will taking part change my date of surgery?
No. Joining the study will not cause delays or change when your knee replacement is scheduled.
Will I have to pay for any part of this trial?
No. All treatment is provided as part of standard NHS care, so there are no costs to you.
Will I know which group I was placed in?
You will usually not be told which group you are in during the follow-up period, so that your questionnaire answers about pain and recovery remain unbiased.
Do I have to attend extra hospital appointments?
No extra hospital visits are needed. The study questionnaires are filled out from home at 3, 6, and 12 months after your operation.
Can I leave the study if I change my mind?
Yes, you are free to withdraw at any time. Doing so will not affect your routine medical treatment or recovery plan in any way.
How to find out more
Adam Boon
Always speak to your GP or specialist before deciding to take part in a study.
Discussion
Community discussion
Powered by our forum at community.patient.info. Please be respectful — this is not medical advice.