Anyone have any recommendations? surgery or no?

Posted , 3 users are following.

Log in / Register


Surgery or ride it out?


I've had knee problems since I was around 10, with the first of 5 dislocations occurring when I was 10. The first time my knee buckled while I was standing and I just fell, no pain or swelling afterward, just a loud pop and I fell to the ground. The second time is a bit hard to explain, but someone jumped on my leg, not hard, but enough to slip my kneecap to the outside. The third time was a wrong twist, the fourth time was wrestling and the 5th and most recent time were walking into an object that hit the inside of my leg, pushing my kneecap to the outside. So my issue is that with all of these dislocations, I haven't ever had apparent swelling, only bruised once behind the knee. I've had 2 MRIs done, first, one after the wrestling event came back with a very small hairline fracture of the patella and a bone bruise. The second MRI was done last month about 1 year after the most recent dislocation and showed no change between the 2 injuries and only a very small change in cartilage, nothing significant enough to freak out about. I have tried physical therapy twice now. The first time I saw some improvement, the second time after the most recent injury I found no improvement and more lingering pain than before. I ran out of sessions covered by insurance so I stopped physical therapy and kept doing my exercises at home which I ended up stopping due to working two jobs and going to school full time. Now I am stuck with deciding between surgery or dealing with the issue and possible damage?

My current state of injury is a lingering pain when the weather changes, climbing steep stairs, random stabbing pains behind the kneecap and lingering soreness after any movement of the kneecap itself. I recently was sent to an orthopedic surgeon that has given me the option of MPFL surgery to basically tether the kneecap to lessen the likelihood of future excessive movement of the kneecap. He told me I have loose joints in my knees, not excessive but enough to possibly be the cause of the issue. I have only had the problem in my left knee though. I am so conflicted on getting the surgery or living with the issue.

I am a 20-year-old female, would it be better to get the surgery now when I'm younger or wait to see if I need the surgery in the future but possibly risk more damage???

0 likes, 2 replies


2 Replies

  • Posted

    Hi, my experience was so different than yours . My left knee got so painful I couldn't walk on it anymore. Took a while to find a good knee surgeon. He did my left knee first, I didn't want both knees at once. 1 1/2 yrs later I had the right knee done. In recovery now. From what I've been through I say SURGERY!

    Report Reply
  • Posted

    I had similar a knee problem like this although my kneecap always slide back in after dislocating. I have seen over five physical therapists and had two successful surgeries to fix my right knee.  Surgery would be the best option since you seen no improvement with other treatments. I hope you can get your knee fixed and not have to live in pain anymore!
    Report Reply

Join this discussion or start a new one?

New Discussion Reply

Report as inappropriate

Thanks for your help!

We want the forums to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the forums are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the forums is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.