Betain HCL

Posted , 4 users are following.

This discussion has been locked due to a period of inactivity. Start a new discussion

Has anyone taken betain? If so please kindly tell me why you took it and how you got on with it and if it sorted out the problem?

A lot of people whohave certain symptoms assume they have too much acid and look for an acid suppressor when in fact it might be that they have too little acid and the symptoms are the same but the treatment has to be different. Some take betain HCL for low acid but it is also used for many other things.

1 like, 7 replies

Report

7 Replies

  • Posted

    Hi Carmel

    There is a simple test you can do at home to see if you have high/low acid which involves drinking bicarb and timing how long before you burp.

    You can also do a test using Betaine HCL while eating. Just google home test for stomach acid and look for the SCDlifestyle website (should be quite near the top)

    Hope this helps

    Report
    • Posted

      Unfortunately moonbuggy it is not a case of how it is the same for all. Have read all about this test and other tests.

      Most are surprised and have never heard of someone wheezing when they take bicarbonate of soda, so the reaction is not guaranteed to be this or that in each case. And I wanted to find out more about betaine and other peoples' experiences with it before I spend money on it. Have thoroughly researched what is on the websites already. Already have a huge mountain of supplements which were a total waste of money. Any fool can rush out and buy this and that but it makes more sense to research it first.

      Have been told to buy melatonin and at least a dozen other things which will not rush out and get either.

      Report
    • Posted

      Carmel,

      You are wise to ask others.

      I too have a ton of natural alternative that haven't worked, or I lost faith in them and am no longer using.

      I have to betaine HCL too, 250 mg.

      I will say get the lowest dose as possible.

      Previously I bought a 500mg dosage and took 2 without any symptoms. But stopped.

      The best time, inu opinion, to try this method is when you are in control of your reflux and not in a crisis.

      Each time I tried was in a crisis and not a good results cause I was already miserable.

      I do something think, and I was considering trying again soon, because antacids, Gaviacon, makes me burn more at night. Then I have to take DGL to relieve the antacid burn.

      This is an individual course. Usually, one has to try for themselves to see.

      Wish you well

      Report
    • Posted

      Hi Dreaming. It does get a bit samey when you post about something and someone suggests you read this or that website. I have read them all. I can research fine without any help. Knowing other's experiences is a different thing.

      Do you have a low stomach acid problem? Did you get relief by taking this? I wont take gaviscon or antacids. Did try the pp1s and pp2s but had bad experiences that were far worse than the illness when taking them. Others suggest liquorice dgl and bicarbonate, but when I took bicarbonate it helped a bit and then gave me wheezing and coughing even if a small dose.

      How are you now?

      Report
    • Posted

      Carmen,

      I was told by the doctor that I have acid reflux based on the fact that most people with the auto immune challenge that I have usually suffer from it. It well known.

      Now the symptom that I complained about even he said did not sound like acid reflux.

      He completely ignored the fact that the endoscopy report performed by another doctor showed hiatus hernia.

      He did a stool sample for Hpyloric which was negative. The previous doctor said I has it per endoscopy.

      Now, I am leaning toward the hiatus hernia being the issue.

      I have a fullness in my right chest and bringing up clear mucus. Not stomach pains or real acid burning at all kn the left side

      Clear mucus comes more after drinking or eating.

      I am learning to control mucus by waiting for an hour after eating before drinking

      I eat small meals and chew my food a lot.

      I take mastic gum, beginning today and DGL with mastic gum and other items to support digestion.

      I take digestive enzyme and pay attention to what triggers my symptoms.

      I am feeling so much better.

      I am allowing for the healing to happen.

      What are your symptoms?

      Report
    • Posted

      My symptoms are simply waking up wheezing and having problems breathing feeling coughy, this goes off most of the rest of the day with just a touch there. I did have other symptoms but have got rid of those by taking biotics.
      Report
  • Posted

    Hi Carmen, I'm taking Betaine and it appears to help.   I've only been on it about a month. Will provide more status later. 

    Report

Join this discussion or start a new one?

New discussion

Report as inappropriate

Thanks for your help!

We want the forums to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the forums are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the forums is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.

newnav-down newnav-up