Carpet tunnel on both hands
Posted , 3 users are following.
I was diagnosed with carpet tunnel and arthritis on both hands mainly arthritis on my right hand., i am 60 years old. I don't feel the carpet tunnel pain yet, the insurance at work is willing to pay for the carpet tunnel surgery now. My question is; should i do it? if i don't do it now i am gonna loose the chance through my lawyer. i do diesel mechanical work and is the right hand i don't have the strength i used to have, but that is the arthritis pain, the doctor said. should i do the carpet tunnel surgery? it would be free and i don't have to worry about it later,
0 likes, 9 replies
joy32895 Fixwingman
Posted
Were you diagnosed for the carpal tunnel by nerve conduction studies done at a neurologist's office? Plain xrays will show arthritis. If you truly have confirmed carpal tunnel syndrome do NOT wait because waiting like I did I may not get all of my feeling back in my fingers. I am happy to report that 2 months post op most of it has returned. I was told I would not know the final outcome for maybe up to a year. I was able to do most everything I normally do after 3 weeks-1 month....so not much down time.
jeremydpbland Fixwingman
Posted
Fixwingman jeremydpbland
Posted
Nerve conduction study has been made and found both arthritis and carpal tunnel,
i understand your point, earlier is not necessary better for surgery. but, lets say you go on with surgery, is this going to in any way make things worse?
thanks,
jeremydpbland Fixwingman
Posted
About one person in every 20 who has the operation done in ordinary NHS practice tells me that they are worse overall after surgery - there are a variety of things that can go wrong to cause this. Opinions vary about whether the length of time between first symptoms and operation is actually a poor prognostic factor. In my view it is very much tied up with other variables and may not be significant in it's own right. We have a new multivariate study of prognostic factors which should be published in 2018 sometime which tends to support this view. CTS progresses at very different rates in different patients, and may even reverse itself without treatment in some cases so if yours happens to be a rapidly progressive one then delay may be a bad idea, but if it is a self limiting case, or one that is running a mild relapsing-remitting course, then delay may be a good thing. As usual in life it turns out to be a bit more complex than simple 'rules of thumb' might lead one to think. Dr J Bland
joy32895 Fixwingman
Posted
The doctor is right in that nerve conduction studies are the only real verifiable diagnostic tool. My doctor told me I should have come in when I first had symptoms. I was in his office to have my total knee check and said oh BTW, my hands are numb all of the time, he immediately sent me for nerve studies. I didn't know it was carpal tunnel, thought maybe a reaction my one of my many Blood Pressure medications. My doctor just said the longer the nerve is compressed the chances you may NOT get full feeling back but I'm happy to report that after 2 months, I have MOST of my feeling back. Some spots of numbness yet, and my doctor said wouldn't know the final outcome for maybe up to a year...but because of having the problem for so long, sometimes the feeling never does completely return. Different doctors have different opinions, obviously
joy32895 Fixwingman
Posted
Obviously, Dr. Bland is an experienced physician in this area of carpal tunnel syndrome. I can only speak from my own experience. I suffered for probably 2 years, not knowing I had carpal tunnel, thinking it was one of my BP medications causing the numbness and tingling, especially at night laying down and when I would hang my arms over the side of the bed and the circulation "seemingly" came back...I never once thought I had carpal tunnel, since I'm retired and have never done any repetitive type work which is supposedly one of the causes. When my ortho doc was doing my every 2 year check for my total knee, I just happened to mention to him my hands were numb thinking I had cervical compression causing it...he said immediately without pause, it's carpal tunnel and sent me for the nerve studies which on my left hand I watch the computer image barely moving when the electrodes were activated...and I'm right handed. I then had bilateral carpal tunnel repair and within about 2 weeks times, no more nighttime numbness and tingling and now most of my feeling has returned. My doctor did say the left may never get full feeling back because of the length of time I had compression of the nerve. I can feel numb "spots", but for the most part 2 months post op, I'm happy to report all is good and I'm sure a lot happier. There is no question that people are all different, their symptoms and their post op outcomes are different...I am only speaking for my own experience and if I had known all along that my problem was carpal tunnel, I would have been in the doctors office immediately.
jeremydpbland joy32895
Posted
I think that story just illustrates some of the problems caused by the popular perception of CTS. It's not primarily due to work/occupation and even when work is playing a part in causing it it appears to be strenuous manual occupations which are a factor, especially when using vibrating tools, and not spending all day on a keyboard. Because the condition has such a popular image as being something to do with typing however, people who do not have such occupations tend to assume that their problem cannot be CTS, as you did. If the daily mail would stop writing articles about it illustrated with pictures of people at a keyboard it would help considerably. Dr J Bland
joy32895 Fixwingman
Posted
I am probably like a lot of people who "love" to self diagnose...I was pretty convinced I had cervical compression because my girlfriends husband had the exact same symptoms I did with the numbness, etc...and he did have cervical disc surgery. I have severe spinal stenosis, lost 2 inches in height from my youth...so just made sense to me that I had a cervical problem, never dreamed it was carpal tunnel... Retrospect, learned that I should have "mentioned" my symptoms to my doctor when I first was noticing them. Live and learn as they say.
becky0812 Fixwingman
Posted
Back this past July I suddenly developed sever Carpel Tunnel in both hands. Extreme pain. Started out going to primary doctor who thought it might be RA, so I was given a referral, and waited 6 weeks for an appointment. Extensive blood work ran, all came back normal, and no RA. Then back to primary doctor in September, and I had to tell him that I wanted a nerve conduction test. I had not slept more than 4 hours a night for two months because of pain. Nerve conduction test showed sever carpel tunnel in both hands. I had first surgery end of September, and was a great relief! Other hand done end of October, and feels some better with a little finger numbness, and slight pain. The hand is stiffer too, not as flexible as the hand I done first. Is this normal after two months? There is a noticeable difference between the two hands. When I asked my Ortho what makes severe Carpel tunnel just come on suddenly out of the blue. He told me that thyroid problems can bring that on or sudden swelling of the body. Before all my hand pain my feet and ankles, and hands had suddenly swelled up, and lasted for a few weeks. I still don't know what caused that, and may never know. My Carpel Tunnel just came out of no where.