From Carbimazole to PTU due to hive
Posted , 7 users are following.
Me again...
I was on 20mg Carbimazole since 5 weeks ago following Graves diagnosis. The medicine was working really nicely on my hyperthyroidism symptoms up until 2 days ago when I developed a nasty hive and a very sore stomach. For one day I was lethargic, completely unable to do anything else then be in bed (which was a massive change from the hyperthyroid life I had! I haven't slept in the afternoon in years!). Today I feel much better but the endocrinologist by email suggested this is an allergic reaction to Carbimazole and told me to stop immediately.
When I told her how disappointed I was, she suggested I could start PTU straight away instead.
I am here looking for experiences of people going form Carbimazole to PTU. As well I would like to know how can I be sure this reaction was induced by Carbimazole and not by something else?
Thank you
0 likes, 33 replies
Karmaway rita87269
Posted
Hey Rita have you had a recent blood test? Sounds like you're swinging to hypo x
rita87269 Karmaway
Posted
Why do you say that? The lethargic feeling was not simple exhaustion, was a full blown allergic reaction drowsiness, I was seriously afraid of falling asleep in the office so I had to leave. I am the usual person full of life today, ran 10k and will go to the gym now. So I don't think it's thyroid relate but rather allergy/stamin related.
I have taken a blood test yesterday but I won't have results until tomorrow or the day after.
Karmaway rita87269
Posted
rita34417 Karmaway
Posted
grayesthistle rita87269
Posted
Hello rita,
I'm in the US and had an allergy to methimazole twice. The first time 2 months ago I was taking 20mg and broke out in a rash and had itching all over so they lowered my dose to 10mg it went away. Then I stopped taking methimazole and resumed again 2 weeks ago on 10mg. Guess what l? A week later I got the itch and hives. So I've been off it for a week and doctor wants to switch me to ptu and I really don't want to take it.
So my only advice is maybe lowering the dose would help you because it helped me the first time.
rita87269 grayesthistle
Posted
grayesthistle rita87269
Posted
Please update us on whether you will be taking the PTU. I'm in the same predicament and am considering other options because of the scary black box warning on this drug. How long have you had graves disease?
rita87269 grayesthistle
Posted
Can you please tell me more about the black box warning? I know nothing about it.
I will update this post or open a new one when I have decided/taken it.
Karmaway rita87269
Posted
grayesthistle rita87269
Posted
If you are allergic to methimazole your chance of being allergic to PTU is 50%. If you take it for 12-18 months possibility of remission is 40%. Most serious side effects occur in first 3 months but they can happen any time to any one. Rare complication is liver failure 1 in 10,000 which does not depend on dose or age or physical condition. Another side effect is agranulocytosis. This is from the thyroid org site " A rare but serious complication of antithyroid medications is known as agranulocytosis. Researchers have yet to discover what exactly causes agranulocytosis, but they do know that is a reaction characterized by attacking immune cells, called granulocytes. These cells protect the body from outside "invaders," such as bacteria. Without granulocytes, the body is defenseless against bacteria and infection.
Agranulocytosis occurs more in patients taking PTU than Tapazole—twice as often, in fact. Regardless of their dosage, patients taking PTU have the same risk of developing the condition. With Tapazole, on the other hand, the risk is likely dependent on the dosage. The lower the dose, the lower the risk."
So while these side effects are rare this is something to think about. PTU does not cure the disease but gives you an opportunity to go into remission.
rita87269 grayesthistle
Posted
linda187 rita87269
Posted
Were you on antibiotics recently? There is a similar reaction that happens to some people when they take certain antibiotics.
Please keep us posted on your condition.
rita87269 linda187
Posted
Hi Linda, no I was not on antibiotics (I am allergic to many antibiotics molecules thou, since I was a child).
I haven't stopped taking Carbimazole yet, I took it this morning and received the email from endocrinologist suggesting I stopped just 3 hours ago. So I will stop tonight by not taking my evening dose. The hive is all over my chest and arms, I notice it on my neck too just now. It is a lot less red/inflamed than yesterday and the day before but it is still there.
linda187 rita87269
Posted
If the hives do not disappear after 24-48 hours after you have stopped taking it, I would then go to an Emergency Department. While I have heard of many patients who have had this reaction to Carbimazole/Methimazole, I have also had a condition called Serum Sickness with hives all over my body not abating until I was given a week's worth of steroids to take. Many docs even do not know about this condition. I have had it twice, once due to a bee sting and second time due to antibiotics I had finished taking 2 weeks prior.
grayesthistle linda187
Posted
Karmaway linda187
Posted
rita87269 linda187
Posted