I'm weighing up surgery on my thumb joints

Posted , 148 users are following.

I have osteo arthritis of both thumb joints. I'm 70, still very active ( currently on a skiing holiday) and work full time in my business. My condition is getting increasingly painful. I get by with painkillers. I have seen a surgeon but I'm really concerned about the long recovery time. 

Has anyone here had basal thumb surgery and if so would you mind describing...briefly...what the surgery and recovery like and any complication. I would be most grateful.

Cheers. 

10 likes, 917 replies

917 Replies

Prev Next
  • Posted

    Hi everyone! I passed my one year mark post trapeziectomy on my left hand. Aug 16th was one year. The right hand is December 16th. my left hand is amazingly stronger and less sensitive than my right so those few months make a difference. 

    I use my hands a lot. We currently are getting ready for a big Halloween party in our barn and I am moving and lifting heavy items and using a drill, etc. They work pretty good for the most part but I cannot grasp very strong still. 

    Overall I am happy with my results and glad I did the surgery. They are still stiff. I do wake up sometimes at night with pain but it is typically fleeting. Nothing like I had before the surgery. 

    I would do it again in a heartbeat. Glad to be out of casts and all that jazz. wink

     

    • Posted

      Good luck with Surgery #2!  - I found it is a little easier as you know what to expect.  Hope all goes well!
    • Posted

      Thank you! I had it done last December. It will be a year in December since surgery #2 was done so the hard part is behind me.

       

    • Posted

      Thanks for the encouraging words Michelle. I'm finally scheduled to have the trapeziectomy on my left thumb on March 27th. I've lived with the excruciating pain in both thumbs for so many years and I've finally found a surgeon that has given me confidence in the procedure and potential results. There are so many horror stories on this site and others that it's nice to see someone with positive results. I know we're all different but most anything is better than what I'm going through now.

      Hoping if all goes well to have the right done in Sept so my recently retired husband and I can hit the roads in 2019 for travel and some fun in the sun.

      If there are others that want to offer words of encouragement or caution, all are welcome. God Bless

    • Posted

      Ali,

      So many of us know that pain in the thumbs.  I broke my wrist in May and it either directly (or indirectly from the cast) really did a number on my arthritic thumb.  It was literally fused and so painful!  First ortho offered no remedy for it so I sought a second opinion.  Like you, found an ortho hand specialist I really trusted and he did the surgery.  Bones crumbled and he put 3 pins in which were removed at 6 weeks.  The worst part for me was the casts.  The best part is a functioning thumb.  Be sure to do the therapy and stick with it.  It's a slow process but I'm so glad I had it done.  As someone said, it's not perfect, and may never be, but SO much better than before.  The main problems I have now actually result from the fractured wrist rather than the surgery.  People heal differently but a positive attitude and a good surgeon are definitely in your favor. Get a one-handed can opener and some small plastic bags, which I found easier to use than the shower sleeve.  Patience...patience...patience.  You'll need a lot of it but the payoff will be worth it.   Best of luck to you.  Please keep us posted.

  • Posted

     I just had basil thumb  surgery on October 6, 2017.   Today’s date is November 4, 2017 my surgery was one month ago I am now on my third cast this one is a removable cast. Recovery has been slow but I can do all exercises as needed. Surgery went very well. Pain level has decreased from a 10 to a one. However I wear my removable cast all the time except for taking showers. Dr.  says  it will take one year from my thumb to back go back to normal. 
    • Posted

      Hi Debra, sounds like we’re about on same schedule, had mine on 9/25. On my second cast, also wear 24/7 except for exercises and bathing. Getting third cast on Tues. which I’m told will be shorter (not up to elbow) and think that will be a 24/7 also, until Jan. And then down to a hand brace which I think will be worn when working around the house, driving and at bedtime... I’m just going with the flow. Pain is not totally gone (2-3), especially after exercises (4-7). Do some of the exercises in warm water or in shower which seems to help, rarely take Rx or OTC but will use ice after for pain if needed. Hoping what pain I do have is part & parcel with the healing and will lessen over time. Also told it’ll be about 1yr. to know for sure how much mobility/strength is back...looking for 100%!!  Hope you continue to do well. It’s a long haul but will be so nice to get our hands back!

    • Posted

       Dear Kathleen I am now on my third cast it is a removable one. It has been exactly one month since my surgery. I remove the cast during the day while I’m at home and resting. I wear the cast every night to bed. I still have a little pain but not bad. I am taking ibuprofen. I go back to the doctor on December 14 for my six week check up after yesterday and then I will start occupational therapy . I have taken off from work until after the first of the year. That will give me three months of rest in therapy. 
  • Posted

    how does one function with one hand, cooking, cleaning, bathing if have no help
    • Posted

      Having been through this 10Months ago I know how you feel but we adapt. I did, but now it is all good.
    • Posted

      I am glad you are doing well. I had the surgery 6 weeks ago and I am doing very well. Actually the surgery pain is much less than the joints pain. I do physical therapy at home by myself 4 × a day and in clinic 1 × a week. Good luck to everyone.

    • Posted

      I managed quite well one handed. I learned to hold things under my arm on the surgery side. I loosened bottle caps before I had the surgery so I could twist easily one-handed. For shampooing etc I squirt a drop of the product on something with my good hand, then scoop it up with my good hand to use. You will learn a lot as you go on. Good luck!
    • Posted

      I bought a shampoo and liquid bath soap dispenser I could operate with one hand, and a toothpaste dispenser I could operate with one hand as well!! 😁

    • Posted

       It’s a little tough to handle everything with one hand. I suggest you practice before you have the surgery that’s what I did. Don’t wear blue jeans with zippers and classes. We are pull up pants and forget about wearing a bra you’ll never get it on. You’re gonna have to take it easy for a couple months it’s kind of a long haul for recovery but it’s well worth it considering the pain before. After you have your surgery you have to use a bag over your arm and you’ll have to shave your legs and wash your hair with one arm only. you have to do that for a month. After the month is up they will give you a removable cast that you can take off to shower or bathe. However I suggest wearing the removable cast as much as possible during the day.  especially when you’re sleeping.  without the cast you feel like your thumb  is loose. It feels safer in the cast. You cannot do any lifting, no pinching, no gripping. Do not try to open up a jar or anything because the bone above the one that was removed could collapse until everything heals that’s why they want you immobile for three months.   I know it’s a long haul but it is worth it. The pain I had before surgery was so intense that would stop me in my tracks and I had to stop doing whatever I was doing. Now the pain that I get is more of a nerve pain that the nerves are trying to heal and that takes time. Good luck to you and prayers are with you. 
    • Posted

      THANK you for all the great advice!!! I do plan on practicing. I even found a you tube on how to put on a bra with one hand!!!
    • Posted

      Hi! I am having the surgery Dec 28th. I bought a toothpaste dispenser I can operate with one hand, and also a combo shampoo, conditioner and Bath soap dispenser that can be operated one handed.  Also, a back brush so i can wash my arm pit of my GOOD arm! I won't be able to do that! LOL! I have also been trying to do things one handed to practice, and think of things I do every day to find a solution. There is a video on line where a woman shows how to put a bra on one handed! I hope this helps!

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.