I'm weighing up surgery on my thumb joints
Posted , 148 users are following.
I have osteo arthritis of both thumb joints. I'm 70, still very active ( currently on a skiing holiday) and work full time in my business. My condition is getting increasingly painful. I get by with painkillers. I have seen a surgeon but I'm really concerned about the long recovery time.
Has anyone here had basal thumb surgery and if so would you mind describing...briefly...what the surgery and recovery like and any complication. I would be most grateful.
Cheers.
10 likes, 917 replies
diana05210 caringbah
Posted
I have been posting about my mini "tight rope surgery " on October 8th but my post must have been deleted. In them I mentioned my doctor and my hospital - I guess that must be against the rules???? So now I am at almost 4 weeks. My hand is still sore and weak but very flexible. At 4 weeks I will be able to add a couple more exercises with 25% pressure on my flat hand. They want to make sure the incision has heal prior to a lot pressure. I am so excited to be able to flatten my hand!! I have been able to do all PT at home and only wear my brace at night and when I might be in a dangerous situation. Typing and those types of activities are easy!! At six weeks I return to doctor and PT and will find out what the new rules are!!! So far VERY happy!!!
caringbah diana05210
Posted
Hi Diane, your mini tight rope proceedure sounds very promising. I dont know why they deleted your post....they've made changes which are a pain in the neck. Just typing a post is tedious with no spelling correction or grammer correction.
Keep us posted.
Rodann25 diana05210
Posted
thanks Diana, please keep the updates coming,
Roger
nancy132911 caringbah
Posted
Yesterday (November 13, 2108) was six weeks since my CMC LRTI surgery on my right hand. For the past two weeks I have been wearing a very small neoprene wrap-around splint. It is so nice not having the cast covering up my hand and arm. It is also great being able to remove it. I take it off when showering and when doing exercises. If I am sitting and reading I take it off.
I have had four physical therapy/occupational therapy sessions so far. All is going extremely well. I have almost no pain in my thumb joint. It is so nice to see that the bulge of bone is gone and my hand looks normal again. I have some swelling every morning, but after exercises and ice it is back to normal. My therapist is working on my thumb and my wrist. The wrist lacks normal movement after being in the casts for four weeks. It is getting better every day. The therapist measures the angles of my thumb, wrist, hand and I am recovering my range of motion.
My therapist said that I still should not use my thumb to pinch or grasp anything other than very light weight. She has me picking up marbles with my thumb and finger to get mobility back in the joint. I can grasp a plastic cup. I no longer need assistance bathing or getting dressed. I've been doing that for the past two weeks since the cast came off. I am preparing easy meals that are mostly heating up the food. No serious chopping or stirring yet. I can't pick up pots with food in them as they are too heavy for my thumb. But every day I can do more! As others have mentioned, doing the physical therapy is very important. I do my exercises three times a day without fail.
I did make one mistake that I want to share with you. I asked my surgeon for dissolvable sutures as in the past it has been extremely painful when I have sutures removed. I thought the dissolvable sutures would be soft, like thread. But they were stiff and spiky. They rubbed against my splint. My therapist cut them down, but they were still irritating me, especially when massaging the incision to prevent the scar tissue from building up. I had about 8 sutures (16 holes with spiky bits). By last weekend all but one had gone away. The last one went away today. That made me very happy! It would have been better to have a few minutes of pain while having regular sutures removed than two weeks of irritation. I will definitely have regular sutures when I have my left thumb surgery in a few months.
Bottom line.........I am very happy that I had this done. I am also happy that I did it on my dominant hand first. I am sorry to hear that some of you are having problems after your surgery. I wish you well. I hope that those of you contemplating this surgery do as well as I am doing.
JohnBall caringbah
Posted
Has anyone had the "mini tightrope" CMC surgery? The surgeon removes the trapezium bone but does not harvest a tendon. Instead they use a very small wire to attach the thumb to the index finger. This acts as a splint inside the hand and allows faster recovery. Not many surgeons do this surgery because it is new (about 7 years). However the results are encouraging so far and recovery time is half compared to when the tendon harvested surgery.
gregory_02122 JohnBall
Posted
I had the cmc arthroplasty on my right
hand about seven weeks ago It's the procedure you are asking about. So far so good. The post surgical pain is pretty brutal. I can't say that I'm pain free but i was back at work within two weeks. I'm pleased with the results.
Let me know if you have specific questions. Good luck!
JohnBall gregory_02122
Posted
Thanks Greg, I am glad you are pleased with the outcome! Did you have much swelling? Also, who did your surgery?
gregory_02122 JohnBall
Posted
Scott Levere with RESURGENS Orthopaedics did my surgery he is in metro Atlanta, Georgia. I was in a soft cast for two weeks so I don't know about postop swelling but after the staples were removed I had minimal swelling. I still have a little pain but nothing like the pretty constant pain I had from the OA in the joint.
JohnBall gregory_02122
Posted
Thanks Greg,
I'm just starting to get the hang of this site, so maybe you can see what I posted to Diane. At any rate, I'm glad you are doing well!! Do you know of a way to find surgeons who perform this, how did you decide on your surgeon? I can travel, and it may be worth having the surgery out of town.
diane88458 JohnBall
Posted
HI john I did not have the minitightrope but had the lrti using the apl tendon transfer and trapeziotomy on aug 28. It is now 3 months and I feel great almost like new. I did have some pain a couple of weeks ago but thats gone. Alot of occupational therapy which i think is a MUST. But the hardest thing was patience especially when you think the healing isnt going as fast as you want. Did rt thumb. Picking away at my guitar! Good luck!
sheila34560 diane88458
Posted
i have been waiting to hear from folks who had mini tightrope done. ive been holding off until i movem interesyed in University of Kentucky as that is whete im moving.
JohnBall sheila34560
Posted
the surgeon I am going to have my consultation with is Maureen O'Shaughnessy at University of Kentucky. She did her fellowship at Stanford, so I'm thinking probably does the mini.
sheila34560 JohnBall
Posted
keep me posted and good luck
Rodann25 diane88458
Posted
Roger here,
what hand did you have done? your guitar fretting hand?
my surgery set for 30th Nov, still worried about it.
troybike JohnBall
Posted
hi John, I am also in Lexington and looking for someone experienced in mini-tightrope. please share your experience over the past 19 months.
thanks
JohnBall troybike
Posted
Hi Troy,
You are fortunate to live in Lexington. Dr. Maureen O'Shaughnessy at UK Med Center 740 S. Limestone is who I saw and I recommend her highly. She did her fellowship at Stanford where the tightrope procedure was developed, so she is fellowship trained in this procedure. However, even though I am definitely a candidate for surgery, she recommended steroid injections, and it was game changing for me. Dr. O'Shaughnessy is also extremely smart, down to earth and easy to talk to. She referred me to Dr. Kimberly Kaiser, who specializes in ultrasound guided injections, and the results have been excellent!! Dr. O'Shaughnessy has to refer you to Dr. Kaiser the first time, then after that you can make your own appointments as needed. I really believe I will be able to avoid surgery with this treatment plan. As recommended by a therapist, I wear my splint on my thumb when I sleep, but very rarely in the daytime. Apparently a lot of damage can be done at night when you have no idea you are even doing it.
I also visited Dr. Marc Richard who is head of the department of arm and hand surgery at Duke University. Dr. Richard has done a tone of mini tightrope procedures, and is just a great guy. Even though he is at Duke, Dr. Richard would be someone to consider if you want a second opinion. Dr. O'Shaughnessy knows him, and thinks highly of him.
Let me know if you have any other questions.
Best of luck!