iol EDGE-GLARE anyone?
Posted , 20 users are following.
The term "edge glare" (edge-dysphotopsia) can relate to many problems. Usually it's light on the side of the eye (a window during a sunny day, a lamp on the bedside table in the dark room, ceiling lights in shops) causing the side of the eye flickering, seeing half-arcs, peripheral glare/flare. All things never happened when I had my natural lens and it's my curiosity to know why this is happening to some people and some don't. It's usually goes away if u cover your sides with hand, so the light MUST coming from the side to produce that annoying condition. But it's really something related to the edge of the lens? Or the reflective index of it? Have read tons of researches showing that the problem is absolutely caused by the truncated edges of the iol and a high-reflective lens doesn't help either because reflects badly the light inside, making it bouncing internally.
Any thought? Experiences with that? Did someone solve the problem by changing the lens for a "less problematic", with different features and design? Please answer.
0 likes, 62 replies
Sue.An adlibi
Posted
I believe this also has to do with size of IOL (some are smaller than others) as well as pupil dilation.
Nizza594 adlibi
Posted
I still have it after 3 and a half months. It's not a major issue, but I would prefer it not to be there, it's definitely not bad enough to get my lenses replaced, I got Carl Zeiss trifocals and my vision is excellent!
Night-Hawk adlibi
Posted
I've heard thats related to the optical diameter of the IOL (usually around 6mm) and the individual person's pupil size when undilated which varies. If your eye undilates to a larger pupil size it can pickup light from outside the edge of the IOL.
adlibi Night-Hawk
Posted
During the night is of course more visible but even during the day it happens with straylight from the side in the form of so called flickering. It's probably a squared-edge issue.
lin59 adlibi
Posted
I have some glare but I don't think it's necessarily edge glare and it's definitely not as bad as what you're experiencing (mine is only in very low light indoors). My IOL is a monofocal 360 degree posterior square edge, 3 piece neutrally aspheric silicone lens (vs negatively aspheric).
adlibi lin59
Posted
lin59 adlibi
Posted
Then I guess if you can't get used to it you should have a lens exchange to that lens you researched that doesn't cause as many problems.
adlibi lin59
Posted
true. the problem is what lens use. I was about collamer but my surgeon doesn't use it. I see surgeon use the same lenses, no matter if someone has very strong glare and other annoyances from it.
peter88910 adlibi
Edited
adlibi peter88910
Posted
crowd00198 peter88910
Posted
Would like to get an update from you. Do you still see the edge glare after several months?
Thanks
cr
soks crowd00198
Posted
Want to make this thread active. Not many replies so this may not be a common problem.
I have this at night. Has anyone tried the alphagan drops? Can anyone share the pupil size and age chart that Nighthawk has shared in the past?
Did this really go away or reduce for anyone?
crowd00198 soks
Posted
hi soks
Mine has not gone away and it has been 6 months since my surgery
i did try alphagan drop and it did go away but i can't tolerate the drop due the side effect
cr
soks crowd00198
Posted
hi crowd
what side effects did you get with alphagan?
how do you see the iol edge glare?
i see it at night outside the house. it is circles and arcs.
crowd00198 soks
Posted
i see cobweb like circles of light and streak of lights at night
it is quite debilitating
when did you have surgery?
cr
soks crowd00198
Posted
I had my surgery 12 days ago.
I see the concentric circles but they are very light and only for some lights. My problem is one large circle per light which is much larger than the concentric circles. Multiple arcs shoot up from various light sources. They disappear with an oncoming car or overhead lights that constrict my pupil.
I installed micro led lights in my car that shoot blue light on me from 3 directions. This prevents the arcs from appearing or if they appear they are gone almost instantly.
Now I need to find a solution to when I am walking in the dark.
Sue.An soks
Posted
hi soks - have you had a follow-up visit with the surgeon? Hoping the arcs diminish with time.
Nizza594 soks
Posted
I had both the dark crescent arcs and the light glare at the edge, it lasted somewhere between 4-6 months after the surgery and then all of a sudden i just realised that it wasn't happening any more!
If it is then I definitely don't notice it! Almost 18 months since my surgery now and no problems really at all, other than the stuff that is simply just a compromise of the procedure, needing good light conditions and having to read at a certain focus point etc.
Good luck!
soks Sue.An
Posted
Hi Sue,
My surgeon is out of state so if I go there I will go for the 1 months post-op visit. He referred me to a local surgeon. He is going to prescribe the alphagan drops.
soks Nizza594
Posted
That's really good to know. Thanks for posting it cleared especially when you were still experiencing it after 3 months. There is a paper from University of Utah Moran Eye Center that talks about this problem. When it resolves itself it is due to the IOL edge becoming opaque after healing.
soks crowd00198
Posted
hi crowd
what sides effects of alphagan did you experience?
adlibi soks
Posted
I can reply if you want: it has a myopic effect (you see blurred), eye strain, headache, it burns.
soks adlibi
Posted
hi adlibi
thanks for sharing. i do not get the myopic effect. i get slight headache which lasts for not more than 5 minutes. it is a weird kind of headache and the doctors are calling it brow ache.
i think there is eye strain. no burning but the pupils are visibly tiny dots. but these are from using 0.2%. Alphagan P is 0.15%. and Aphagan Z (not available in US) is 0.1%.
adlibi soks
Posted
After a while the eye gets used to the drops so the effect is limited to few hours or even less.
soks adlibi
Posted
that would be disappointing and would make me want lens exchange.
but would the glare persist with a monofocal?
adlibi soks
Posted
I have two different material monofocal iol and with both I have annoying, not to say debilitating, glare. They have both squared, truncated edges. One has frosted (the Tecnis zcb00) but does not help at all with flickering. Reducing pupil masks the iol edges so less glare and halos.
Sue.An soks
Posted
I am pretty sure from reading I have done that these symptoms (edge glare and pupil dilating beyond IOL) would be present regardless of lens type if they have a square edge - round edge ones would help but then you might encounter pco sooner.
I tried to research the pupil constricting drops and couldn't find anything that would suggest/indicate that with prolonged use they would lose effectiveness. A good question though to ask your doctor.
Sue.An adlibi
Posted
adlibi where did you read that the eyes get used to the drops and this becomes less effective over time?
soks Sue.An
Posted
my surgeon's colleague from my city who prescribed me the drops asked to use them daily for an year. he said i would not need them after an year.
Sue.An soks
Posted
Yes think for majority of people this lessens with time.
adlibi Sue.An
Posted
Or it shrinks the pupil permanently?
Sue.An soks
Posted
soks - tead there are medications prescription and no prescription that can cause pupils to dilate: I wasn't aware of some of these on the list.
Here is a copy and paste:
The following prescription and non-prescription medicines can cause your pupils to dilate and affect their ability to react to light:
Antihistamines
Decongestants
Tricyclic antidepressants
Motion sickness medicines
Anti-nausea medicines
Anti-seizure drugs
Medications for Parkinson's disease
Botox and other medications containing botulinum toxin
Atropine (used for myopia control and other medical purposes)
Sue.An adlibi
Posted
As far as I am aware there is no lasting effects from using the drops to temporarily constrict the pupils.
If light coming from the side is the issue for flickering have you considered a pair of glasses that would restrict light from entering from the side? Like blinkers for a horse.
Might be worth a try to see if that is indeed the cause.
adlibi Sue.An
Posted
of course it's the cause, even just putting fingers around eyes helps. the cause is peripheral light. why is this the cause is not known, a still I think the cause is the iol's edge
Sue.An adlibi
Posted
unfortunately even with a successful cataract surgery and IOL is correctly placed edge glare occurs for some patients. Predicting who experiences this is often a mystery for surgeons. Statistically I read it happens less than 5% of the time. Although a low % doesn't alleviate the frustration for patients that experience this.Although it often disappears or diminishes but given it had been do long in your case it appears it may not. Given length of time it may also be too late for a lens exchange bit you might want to consult with an expert who specializes in exchanges to inquire whether it can be done.. B&L silicone lenses have round edges and likely eliminate this flickering you are experiencing.
I have a square edge IOL myself and recall having a bit of this flickering after my 2nd surgery on LE. For me it did go away.
adlibi Sue.An
Posted
Which B&L silicone has round edges?
soks Sue.An
Posted
which one? positive or negative? i don't want to cross the time where lens cannot be exchanged.
soks adlibi
Posted
The doctor said it will shrink the pupil permanently before the age related reduction.
Sue.An soks
Posted
The positive. And from article I read it doesn't appear to resolve the issue 100% of the time for whatever reason and the trade off could be glistenings with a silicone IOL and earlier pco. Really is a crap shoot and wish there were more diagnostic tools available which would indicate which patients ate more susceptible to PD and ND. You'd think at least for pupil dilation there could be some way to measure that before surgery to determine diameter of pupil in various dark settings.
soks Sue.An
Posted
i think the number that 5% are affected is because these 5% are younger patients with larger pupil sizes. and since the number is small no one cares about them.
Sue.An soks
Posted
I think that perfectly explains it and disappointing it hasn't come about that the IOLs can't be made larger to accommodate that. Some articles I was reading dated back to 1998 (20 years ago) for those suffering from just what you describe. I wonder what they do for the poor children born with cataracts.
soks Sue.An
Posted
they should make larger iols (7mm) for younger patients with additional refraction for near. these patients would lose little bit of their near vision when their pupil size decreased due to natural aging just like presbyopia.
children get 100% PCO so they do vitrectomy for children and remove the posterior capsule during the surgery or some specific technique. I believe capsule in combination with the pupil and iol play key role in dysphotopsias.
deborah08304 peter88910
Posted
Hi, I believe I have the same problem as you do. How bad was it right after surgery? Mine is in the left eye and noticeable when I look to the right. It's annoying, but I guess I can live with it. Would appreciate any input you can offer. Thank you.