Let's talk about Cataract surgery choices and outcomes.

Posted , 17 users are following.

I'm a retired opticain who just had my first cataract surgery. I love to talk about the EYES.

3 likes, 233 replies

233 Replies

Next
  • Posted

    Right now I would be happy to talk to anyone. I take care of my Mother who is 81 years old. I live on Long Island, NY. I had taken her to a Doctor who was very pushy to do Laser Cataract surgery and wanted to charge her 1596- per eye. I did not care for him so I took her to someone else who she has seen the past and was recommended highly. I was told he would not push the laser. He said her Cataract is almost a 5 degree which is the worst/most difficult cataract to remove. He pretty much insisted on doing the Laser otherwise the outcome would be questionable. He is charging her 1400- per eye. She is getting no specialty lense. In reading I just discovered that the Doctor is not supposed to even charge for using the Femto Laser. All he is doing is using the laser to remove the cataract. I understand that if the laser is used for something other than the Cataract removal they can charge. I realize now when she was examined he said she has an astygmatism(which she was never told before) and that he would fix that. By saying this he can now charge for the use of the laser. I just feel these Doctors are really taking advantage of patients. To make matters worse I get a phone message asking for payment now. I have never heard of paying until all the papers are sent into Medicare and her supplemental insurance. I am just so upset. I am just so worried sick for my Mother. Thsnks for listening.
    • Posted

      I meant...Thanks... Also she is set to have the Surgery on 10/12
    • Posted

      Hi Jillie280; with so many questions and lingering concerns, I personally would hold off the procedure if it were my parent.  It is not an emergency surgery and the condition is not life-threatening (assuming caution is being taken with respect to driving, and minimizing falls, which can be especially serious at her age). It sounds like you need more answers pertaining to her specific situation that you can only get from someone directly involved in her care.  Medicare does pay for most of a basic cataract surgery, but as to the additional services being recommended, I have no idea. I know it's a pain, but I'd put some time and even extra money into another opinion.  Anyone here know the best Yelp-like service to locate and evaluate good eye surgeons in her area?  Feeling pressured is a red flag in my opinion, having had experiences with elderly parents.  Good luck!

    • Posted

      Definitely find a better Opthalmologist. I paid my copay of $250 at the surgery center on the day of the surgery. Your mom is looking through coffee colored lens and just a clear non toric lens will change her world. After surgery she can get one free pair of Medicare glasses to correct her astigmatism. How much astigmatism does she have? You can tell by looking at her eyeglass prescription.
    • Posted

       The Doctor who is set up to do the surgery is supposedly a very good surgeon and was highly recommended. I even spoke with the surgery center about all the problems and the woman I spoke to said he is very skilled. She has already seen 2 Doctors and they both said Laser was the way to go. The day did get worse today when the office called and said if I do not pay them 1400- today for the Femto laser that they would have to cancel the surgery. I said I do not want to cancel. My Mom is already frail recovering from a stroke.

      It is very hard getting out of the house. She already had to go for an EKG for surgery clearance and started the pre op drops. I am just so upset that they never told us payment was due before surgery until 3 days before. I figured they would submit the bill to Medicare and I would pay after. My Mom is not a typical 81 yr old. Her mind is that of a young person. Her mind is better than mine. She justs wants to go forward with the surgery on Thursday. If it was me I would go somewhere else but she just cannot handle starting over with the exam, the medical clearance, the eye drops. It is too stressful for her. She is comfortable with the Doctor but after what happened with asking for payment today I am not. He even now said since I did not want to pay today that he would just do traditional surgery, no laser. He was adamant that the outcome would be risky without the laser.So in the end I feel bullied and I did what my Mom wanted and just paid him the 1400-. I just want Thursday to come and my Mom be OK.

    • Posted

      She has not had an eyeglass prescription filled in many years so I have no idea how much it is. I know the first Doctor I took her to never mentioned that she even had astigmatism.

      She said she does not remember ever being told she has one. I do not know for sure. I was going to call the last place she had glasses made to see if they have a record of it but since it is almost 10 years they may not be able to tell me.

    • Posted

      The surgeon knows how much astigmatism she has. You are probably having to pay so much because she is getting the toric implant. Medicare will not pay for the toric unless something has changed. Personally, I wouldn't be interested in a toric implant unless I had at least 2 diopters or more in cylinder correction. Advanced cataracts deprive the eye of a tremendous amount of light. Light deprivation alone can cause depression and sleep problems.

    • Posted

      She is just getting a regular implant for distance. No special lense.
    • Posted

      Cataract surgery can be done on advanced cataracts without femto laser, therefore Medicare does not cover it. The only way you would not have to pay for it is if the doctor did it for free and didn't submit the paperwork for it to Medicare. Doctors do charity cataract operations in other countries on people with very advanced cataracts without using laser (like in Burma - for anyone interested, google "Restoring eyesight with a simple, inexpensive surgery" to see the 60 Minutes episode on it).

    • Posted

      Using the femto laser just made his work a little easier (although the actual surgery supposedly takes a bit longer when they use laser) and also lined his pockets at the same time.
    • Posted

      I know the cataracts could be done on advanced cataracts without a laser. It has been done for a very long time. It is funny you mentioned that 60 minutes episode. We watched it. We were thinking about all the eye drops she has to use and were they given all those drops that cost hundreds of dollars? We were just made to feel that the outcome would be questionable and the surgery very risky if we went the traditional route. I just felt if we went the regular way and the outcome was bad I did not want the Doctor to say" I told you the outcome may not be good" I care about my Mother more than anything and I was not taking any chances so I said ok to the Femto. Yes...he lined his pockets in I feel a not so honest way. 

    • Posted

      Nina, you are such a wealth of information!!!  I really enjoyed this article...thanks very much for sharing it.
    • Posted

      Referring to Nina's link about cataract surgery in Burma.

    • Posted

      You're welcome Leslie and there's a video of the segment that was on 60 Minutes. I'll send you that link privately since we can't post links here.

    • Posted

      I know, I thought the same thing about the eye drops in the 60 Minutes episode. Probably all those drops aren't even necessary (and I paid $360 for both eyes for the eye drops alone which was probably around half the total amount I paid for the surgery and that's with a discount coupon and insurance!). It's done now, all you can do is hope for the best.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.