More questions!!

Posted , 10 users are following.

So first bout of PMR 7 yesrs ago and now flare up after finally reaching 1.5mg pred - so  here we go again ( CRP 145).  Amazing result from uping pred dose - no pain - just normal striffness+ moving discomfort/pain -first in shoulders,then legs,next neck!! + slowness + low mood + fatigue.

People give such good descriptions of their experineces of PMR on this forum and we all benefit from their questions and the relies so many of you give.

Despite being an old hand at this, what I  would really love to know is what PMR is.  If we talk about Flu I can visualise a virus invading the baody and causing havoc ( that little green gremlin that spreads around the body raising tempreatures etc until the white knight of the body defences surround him and kick him out!!- obviousy watched too much  animated TV whilst recovering from PMR!).  What I can't visualise is how PMR affects us - I know it is an autoimmune disease that for some reason releases cytokines which cause inflammation in the muscles.  Eileen's description of climbing stairs with PMR equates to the effort of climbing a mountain, describes how i feel - but why?  I'm not in acute pain now, my muscles work, my brain works (i think) so why can't I move easier - WHY can;t I walk faster - all my movements seem slow and thought about.

My other bg question is the motivation/mood changes.  I change daily, some days being tearful, other days I get out of bed with ideas that I can do things only to find myself still sitting st the breakfast table an hour later. I can;t even do my craft work which normally i'd give anything to have the time to do.

In my pre retirement a lot of my job was spent discussing achievable targets for people so I know how to pace myself - the problem I have is getting going.  Is this lack of motivation the effect of PMR or the steroids.?

Just had a thought perhaps we should have a FAQ page attached to this forum - then poor Eileen , Mrs O etc wouldn't have to keep repeating themselves thousands of times for all the questions we ask!!  Thanks for all your research and replies - you all keep us informed - we in turn do our best to distribute the information to those in the NHS who are interested but just too pressurised to research everything as thorougly as they would wish.  

The old format of this forum when you could run down a list of the titles of the disucssion threads  used to make it easier to review topics that were pertinent to ones questions.  I haven;t quite got used to this forum layout yet - give me time!!

0 likes, 15 replies

15 Replies

  • Posted

    I have often thought we should have an 'Eileen's Corner'!!
  • Posted

    I'd be really interested in the answer to this too - sorry Mrs O, and Eileen (you ought to be on full time salaries here). Is it just muscles or is it blood vessels that supply the muscles.

    And is there any particular reason why it should be both sides of the body?

  • Posted

    Hi gillb,

    I am very new to this and can only assume that Fybomyalgia the same thing that you are all talking about only my Dr. is talking in old money......

    I had a fall and hurt my neck and everything went down hill from then on. I have suffered in the past with several spine related injuries and thay have all taken longer than normal. But this time it's been a knockout punch and it's taken 12 months for the Dr's to come up with any kind of answer and it is this.

    My pain has been debilitating but it has been centered from my neck but they don't understand the pain in my hands,feet, ankles, halfway up my shins and foreamrs,between my legs and at times the whole of my head. The pain in my fingers and toes is like someone is standing on them and won't get off. it has been awkward given that I have had knee and shoulder issue's during the same time which I have had successful surgery on both. my shoulder operation was an amazing success that had the surgeon baffelled at 9 weeks I had regained full use which he didn't expect untill at least 20 weeks, So I can recover from issue's my body has just not the one that has thrown the sucker punch.

    The other thing it has done is knock my sight, I haven't had glasses since I was 16 and that was only for reading very small print but this has altered the sight in my right eye and all of the Dr's have said that my neck injury has nothing to do with my sight issue.

    Anyway back to my original question is Fybromyalgia the same thing as PMR.

    • Posted

      No Graham - fibromyalgia and polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR) are not the same thing. There are a lot of symptoms that overlap but there are some very specific differences - the biggest being that fibromyalgia is not improved at all by a moderate dose of prednisolone but PMR will respond with a 70% improvement in the symptoms within a few days of starting taking a dose of 15-20mg/day of prednisolone. This is because PMR is an inflammatory condition and fibromyalgia is not. In addition, for some people amitryptiline or pregalbin will improve their symptoms from fibromyalgia - but has no effect for the vast majority of patients with PMR.

      Fibromyalgia can occur at any age whilst pMR tends to be found more often in older people - over 50 mainly but younger people can also demonstrate teh symptoms.

      The Arthritis Foundation says:

      "Polymyalgia, or polymyalgia rheumatica, is an inflammatory disease of muscle. The cause is uncertain but it is believed to be an autoimmune disease in which the body’s own immune system attacks the connective tissues. The primary symptoms are severe stiffness and pain in the muscles of the neck, shoulder and hip areas. People with this condition also may have flulike symptoms, including fever, weakness and weight loss, and approximately 15 percent develop a potentially dangerous condition called giant cell arteritis – an inflammation of the arteries that supply the head.

      Fibromyalgia is not an inflammatory condition. It is caused by abnormal sensory processing in the central nervous system. People with fibromyalgia may be extremely sensitive to pain and other unpleasant sensations. To be diagnosed with fibromyalgia, one must experience pain on both sides of the body and in both the upper and lower half of the body. They are also typically tender points throughout their body. Other common symptoms of fibromyalgia include fatigue, difficulty sleeping and concentrating, irritable bowel syndrome and headaches."

    • Posted

      Thank you EileenH, it is difficult to get information and while on the hunt for answers I have crossed path's with the two conditions some how.

      I do have an appointment with a specialist in liverpool so hopefully I will get some more answers to help with the pain I am now in.

    • Posted

      Before I was diagnosed with PMR - on the basis of the pattern of symptoms and the response to pred - I wondered if what I had could maybe be fibromyalgia. I had some of the typical painful spots, but not quite enough, and if you touched my biceps firmly it hurt and I could still feel the place 5 mins later.This site almost certainly has a page about each of them, both for patients and also more complex for healthcare professionals. as do Arthritis Research UK and NHS Choices. These 3 will provide accurate and sensible founded information - unlike some sites who will claim whatever you have can be cured if you just do this or that. No - there is no cure for either as yet but both can be managed to allow you a better quality of life.
    • Posted

      Wow eileenh -i have just read the extenive reply to gilb on PMR  and picked up on the side effects of higher doses of pred .although iwas started on 15 mg (4years ago)  not a really high dose but when i tried to explain to my family -i was met with look of disbelief.i still dont understand how people can make an evaluation of how much pain you  have by just looking at you and   why do they look at us with PMR and assume 'you look ok so it cant be that bad'why do they ask us  'are you ok'  if they really dont want to know.I JUST SAY IM OK because i dont want them to think im mardy -isoldier on in silence -but their insensativity hurts.it makes me feel as if they think im faking it.its still a battle and am trying the early 6am pred instead of early paratcetamol and then pred after breaky -am still doing the 5/4 alt days -will report on this in few days -sorry for moan ---but a couple of other PMR people commented on the reactions of others to our illness and felt i had to put my pennith in too! good wishes to all .
    • Posted

      No one gets sympathy for the "invisible illnesses" - depression, arthritis except maybe RA because it used to leave patients with deformed joints, even in a wheelchair, and many more. The only people who know are the ones who have walked the walk.

      Don't make light of it - because when you say "I'm fine" they believe you because they want to. Especially when you go to the doctors - if you are in pain, TELL THEM! Otherwise they will try to get you to reduce your pred dose when you are not yet ready to do so. 

  • Posted

    mrsmop. I might be wrong but i think Eileen. has her own corner on north east suport group.gillb i have a good idea where you are coming from,my pred brain can be soul destroying.hope you get some answers. All the best.
  • Posted

    I dislike this new "improved" forum layout too! If you follow this link (apologies if I have already given it to you):

    https://patient.info/forums/discuss/pmr-gca-and-other-website-addresses-35316

    you will find further links to the northeast of England support group website which has loads of info that is permanently there. If you follow the second link it will take you to the forum associated with that support group - it is open to everyone and has more members than here. The format is different, possibly confusing until you get the hang of it, and we have a locked thread with my older posts that were felt to be very useful, some of them combine answers from MrsO and others too and there is also a FAQ section for beginners. There are seperate sections for various topics, like "medication and treatment" or "diet and exercise" which we sort of stick to but each thread tends to run like a normal conversation with changes of direction in the middle! What is best is that it isn't just a few of us with the accumulated wisdom of years and you will get founded responses from several others as well which gives a better chance of someone having experienced what you are asking about. We even have a section for jokes, one for photos of the garden, grandchildren and pets and a general "Chatterbox" where ANYTHING goes!

    So mrsmop - I do have a corner (not a naughty corner I hope ;-) ) but you'll have to come to the other coffee shop to find it!

    Anyway, this isn't a scientific explanation but simply an illustration of why you feel rubbish with an autoimmune disorder.

    When you have flu or a cold your immune system gets the message when the white cells in your blood come across the virus in your blood. Viruses can only increase when they get inside your cells, they can't do it on their own, so they get inside your tissues - and multiply. So the white cells increase in number and start to attack the bits of virus they find but that takes some time and the presence of the virus means the way your body is working is disturbed and you feel ill. If the virus changes it's overcoat quickly enough then the body's own immune system doesn't "see" it quickly enough to catch it and it can get worse and worse - as ebola is doing in Africa. Eventually though the body gets the upper hand, the infection fades and you feel better.

    In an autoimmune disease something upsets the body's immune system and it fails to recognise that your own tissues are "Self". It thinks the cells are foreign bodies, like viruses or bacteria, and starts to attack them. More white cells rush to the scene - and instead of finding a real foreign body they find a playground scrap going on and dive in too. And make the damage worse. There are two sorts: organ-specific and non-organ specific. An example of the first is Type 1 diabetes - the cells that make insulin in the pancreas are damaged, there isn't enough insulin and blood sugar levels go haywire. Another is Graves disease which affects the thyroid. Others are directed at connective tissue, skin, joints.

    Immune system cells called T lymphocytes (T cells) use special receptors on their surfaces to identify foreign microbes, such as bacteria and viruses. Usually, T cells that react to the tissues of the body are destroyed by the thymus, an organ of the immune system located behind the breastbone. The 'self-attacking' T cells that escape destruction may be activated by a trigger. The exact triggers are unknown, viral infections and hormones are among the suspects but there is no real consensus on this and in some cases viral infection has been rules out. The rogue T cells then instruct B lymphocytes (B cells) to make antibodies against the particular tissue, organ or system. Such antibodies are called 'autoantibodies' and can sometimes be identified in the blood by tests - not finding them doesn't mean there aren't any, it just means they haven't been identified yet. There are about 80 different autoimmune disorders, some are quite distinct like diabetes or RA and others are sort of mixed up and show signs of two or three different illnesses. Most of them are named by the doctor who notices a set of symptoms occurs in a few of his patients - but what is often forgotten is that patients with an autoimmune disorder can have bits of several different descriptions from the textbooks. Many were identified years ago before there were the diagnostic and scientific tests we have now and some are being renamed, realised that a and c are actually the same disease or that b comes in a wide range of versions. 

    In giant cell arteritis something happens to make the body create giant cells which can grow so large and numerous that they actually narrow the space in the middle of the artery, restricting blood flow. In a large artery that is perhaps less significant but if these cells get to the arteries in the head they are much smaller and can even stop the blood flow. Typically that happens in the arteries supplying the optic nerve, it is starved of oxygen, bits die off and if too much dies the optic nerve stops transmitting signals to the brain and you go blind. In some ways it is a stroke or heart attack but in the optic nerve. 

    When GCA affects other larger arteries the blood flow is restricted but not entirely stopped, so at rest we aren't too bad but when we try to exercise there isn't enough blood getting through for the increased amount of oxygen required and we get cramp-like pain which comes on when you do things, fades when you stop doing it but comes back again when you resume what you are doing. The pred you are given shrinks these inlammatory signs caused by the enlarged cells and reduces the risk to your vision.

    For a long time it has been thought that PMR and GCA are similar but different, similar because GCA patients often have PMR symptoms and different because they hadn't found the giant cells. GCA has been known as temporal arteritis for many years - because that was where you could SEE swelling and could remove a bit of it and identify the giant cells that give it its name. In recent years improving imaging techniques have meant that it has become obvious that other arteries suffer in the same way. If the brachial artery which supplies the arms, is affected then the biceps develop signs of claudication in response to repeated or sustained actions - like cleaning windows or holding a phone to your ear. But you can't easily take a chunk of that artery out and look at it so that remained unknown. Because of these improved diagnostic tests, using special CT scans and ultrasound, is is now known there are far more connections between PMR and GCA than was originally thought. GCA has been classified as a vasculitis for a long time: vasculitis is inflammation of blood vessels. More recently it has been suggested and is fairly much accepted now that PMR is also due to vasculitis, but not in the larger arteries. In PMR it is the microcirculation, the very small arteries, that are affected in a similar way, restricting the flow of blood into the muscles they are supplying with oxygen and then picking up and removing the lactate, the stuff muscles produce when they work. Lactate in muscles is what makes your legs sore after running, your arms ache after digging the garden, especially when you are not used to it: in training. Whatever it is happens in the blood vessels makes your muscles unable to tolerate acute exercise - it takes much much longer and in very tiny steps to persuade your muscles it isn't too bad climbing those stairs. When my PMR first started at the beginning of the ski season I could only manage half a short run before my legs ached - but I persisted, skiing a short run, resting on the lift, skiing again, only doing a few runs and then resting for a few days before repeating it, increasing the number of runs each week or so and by the end of the season I could ski several times as much as at the beginning.

    As long as that autoimmune disorder is active you will have the symptoms, either of GCA or of PMR. Like all autoimmune disorders they can range from mild to severe and PMR can sometimes be managed by lifestyle changes and even some ordinary pain killers - never did for me but for 5 years I managed - by always using the car to go any distance for example, if I couldn't drive and park nearby I couldn't go. I changed my gym to one with a pool - I could do aqua aerobics if I modified it a bit but I couldn't do a step class. By doing an aqua class every morning I managed to keep fairly mobile but there were things in my Pilates class I could no longer do and I could barely manage the movement classes the council organised for over 50s. My doctor just kept saying "your bloods are normal..." But what was happening ot me wasn't normal for someone in their early 50s. Then it hit like a 10 ton truck - and I was stopped driving for another reason. Then I realised how restricted my life had become. Now I couldn't get anywhere - public transport was a nightmare.

    Eventually I worked out what it was - including via this site - and told the GP who referred me. The rheumy wasn't interested in my story, normal bloods, too young, blah blah, but he did give me pred - and it was a miracle, everything worked again within hours. He wasn't interested in continuing the pred - but another GP listened and wrote the prescription.

    Pred reduces inflammation, by altering how and which proteins are made by the cells. Reduce the inflammation and the blood can flow again. Possibly not perfectly but far better than it was. And most of us have realised that staying at 15mg would be the physical answer if pred didn't have side effects! Recently it has been found that there are a lot of neutrophils, a specific white blood cell, present in GCA - and they reduce as the inflammation reduces but are still present in small numbers even after 6 months on doses of pred above 20mg. The question is: is this the reason people with GCA have flares even though the blood tests and symptoms appear OK? Are these cells also present in PMR patients - is there more involvement of the bigger arteries than was thought in PMR? Are the neutrophils showing cause or effect? Either way, they may form a better way of monitoring the inflammation because they are more specific. It does suggest a mechanism for the effect of pred in both GCA and PMR - one of the effects pred has is on neutrophils. And that opens up possibilities for developing treatments - only when you know the cause can you find a cure, or even an effective long term treatment or prevention using a vaccine for example.  

    So is it muscles or blood vessels? Probably the plumbing to and from the muscles but possibly also something in the muscle too. Research is starting to look at the microcirculation - funding has been made available for that. And the side-effects of pred are being looked at, how can it be used most effectively. Personally I think it is more important to optimise the way we use pred, how to reduce better, rather than messing about with other fancier and more expensive drugs that the GPs won't use as pred is cheap as chips and they know it works. It would work better if they learnt how to use it properly! When they know how PMR and GCA are caused, then they can look for proper ways of dealing with it.

    And why is it bilateral? No one knows, it just tends to be typical. It does differentiate it from an injured shoulder or hip I suppose. RA joint pain also tends to be bilateral apparently - but can be just one-sided. I think it probably just reflects the "all over the body" multi-organ aspect of autoimmune disease. 

    And because the underlying autoimmune disorder is still ticking over in the background with pred being used to control the SYMPTOMS and not the illness itself we still feel a bit ill, some people more ill than others. Pred isn't innocent either - it can make you feel a bit dozy. The vasculitis can cause brain fog because the brain isn't being supplied with enough oxygen maybe, but pred does it too. Pred works by attaching to receptors on the cells - only then can it do its job. At higher doses all the receptors in the hypothalamus, part of the brain, are occupied with pred molecules and that can make you feel quite high and energised. Then the left over pred starts to circulate - and makes you "drunk", confused and it affects memory. This does improve as the pred dose falls and you get to the amount that controls the symptoms without enough floating around to cause other effects.

    I hope this wasn't to confused - this tiny post box is a pain, you used to be able to see far more lines at one go! If I didn't answer your question in full - ask and I'll deal with the bits I didn't.

    As i said, this isn't accurate science, that is far too complicated to deal with here. But it illustrates it fairly well - I think ;-)

    • Posted

      Wow - thsnks for that fantastic explanation eileen.  Will take my time and digest all the information in small bytes!!  To have a written reply is so appreciated as i can review and review at my own pace.  Funnily enough I have just reviewed my discussions from years back ( gradually findingmy way round this site) and found I asked a very similar question back then but didn't get anywhere near the same quality of reply - you were obviously just trying to cope with your own situation then and are so much more knowledgeable now.  At least knowing I felt the same way 7 years ago and knowing that I got over it and was able to live a very active normal life again has reminded me it is at least something i can achieve again as long as keep takng the tablets!!  Thanks again - will try the other site when my head clears abit, 
    • Posted

      I wasn't here 7 years ago - I found the site just over 5 years ago and was still reading my way through the historical posts 5 years ago - I am probably the only person who has read EVERY post on this forum! There was a certian amount I knew because of my background but the rest has been accumulated since. I learn something new every week I think. Someone asks a question and I go to look for an answer. It certainly keeps the brain working ;-)
    • Posted

      That is a brilliant explanation Eileen.  Copied & will print out.  Thank you.  I even mentioned you on my favorite political website where a nurse was explaining how little research was being done on a certain disease.  A few people with willingness & knowledge can do a lot to educate & help the many.  Many thanks to you & MrsO.  There are so many questions & ups & downs with this disorder & I feel sure most all of our GP's & rhemys would not have the time or patience to deal with them & sadly many of them just don't know the answers.
  • Posted

    Hi, I had PMR for almost 2 years before I was diagnosed and like you I love my crafts, strange thing was I had no interest in anything, never touched my jewellery making, then was put on preds , and wow!! made 3 bracelets in first week have only been on them for  4 weeks but  am back to how I felt before the PMR, so am sure it is the preds that have worked this magic, maybe you need a higher dose than you are on, I know very little about it only how it affected my whole life and took the quality away, i was so scared of taking the preds but they      have been my life saver.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.