One versus the other

Posted , 18 users are following.

What exactly is posterior surgery?  Mine was on my side flank.  Although highly educated, I am still ignorant in regards to this.

2 likes, 29 replies

29 Replies

Next
  • Posted

    There are two main types of incision are posterior and anterior. The posterior is as it implies more to the back of the hip, this is the old tried and tested way. It tends to have a larger scar and there are supposed to be more initial restrictions on movement for a few weeks. The anterior is more modern and the incision is at the front of the hip. The incision tends to be much smaller. The disadvantage of the posterior is that muscles need to cut, while the anterior they do not, however because the surgeon has less room to manoeuvre nerve damage and tendon damage can happen more easily. I had lateral posterior and in fact had no restrictions for some unknown reason, I think they are improving over time. I went out for lunch five days after surgery, although I think I may have been slightly over enthusiastic as you do get quite tired initially. 
  • Posted

    Just behind the hip, along the outer buttock area  approx 4–6 inches. Larger incisions may be needed for larger patients and those with previous surgery or abnormal anatomy. It's the most common approach. No clinical studies prove which of the many approaches is better. 

    • Posted

      Again, mine was in the side, where my hand hangs.  Scar around 6-7 inches. I don’t know what you would call that.  It would seem that posterior would even prevent sitting?
  • Posted

    The posterior approach surgery has the incision on the side of the hip, just behind the greater trochanter, the hip bone that people feel on their side. That sounds like what you had. It cuts more muscle and soft tissue supposedly than the anterior approach, which has a much smaller incision on the front of the hip. My understanding is that with the anterior approach, you do have much faster healing and less soft tissue/muscle damage to contend with, but a slightly greater risk of nerve injury. There is also the slightly less invasive mini-posterior approach which is what I had supposedly. Again, supposedly the muscles at the back of the hip in this approach are separated rather than cut and the incision is a bit shorter than the traditional posterior. I'm no expert Ducksoup, but I hope this is what you were asking about. 

  • Posted

    Yes Duck, you had posterior. My scar is about 9-10” and proud of it. My surgeon only does posterior approach and has over 40+ years experience. I sense better long term results with posterior but a few more restrictions first 6 weeks 
  • Posted

    Hi Ducksoup... I had what I thought was called a lateral THR which like yours is a vertical scar approximately 6inches in length. My friend had a posteria and it was as it says on the tin. Scar starts above the hip and as it goes down it runs along the bottom of your buttock (Cheek) Anterior is in the groin. Think lateral (vertical) incision is more commonly used NHS.

    • Posted

      Kim, I had anterior, but my scar is definitely not in the groin area. It is more to the side.
  • Posted

    Just as ptolemy says .... there are many medical terms used to blind the non-medically trained.

    Posterior - Rear incision for THR

    Anterior - Frontal incision for THR

    Lateral - Side incision for THR

    Proximal - closest to the body - i.e. the top of a leg

    Distal - most distant part - i.e. the bottom of the leg

    • Posted

      I am still confused! To me lateral indicates side, and posterior back! My incision for total right hip replacement is on my side. It runs exactly right down the right seam of my jeans and where my shoulder bag would rest. The scar is about 7 inches. To me that is the side of my body!
    • Posted

      im glad youre confused too because i am ,mine sounds like yours,so have we got laterals?doh!xxx
    • Posted

      My lateral posterior runs round my hip parallel to my waist well nearly it goes up a bit at the back and down a bit at the front. I was told I had no restrictions. The scar can hardly be seen, it healed incredibly quickly and I had no problems with it except for a bit of bleeding when they took off the plaster.
    • Posted

      Posterior isn't 'right around the back', it's at about the 8 o'clock position on me if straight ahead is 12 o'clock.

  • Posted

    DS-

    There is  surgeon in Seattle whose website has a very good description and graphics to explain several of the most common procedures.  You could google J Pritchet Orthopedic Seattle and find some good information.

  • Posted

    From what I can understand it is not describing the position of the incision but the aspect that the surgeon approches the hip joint from ie front or back of the hip the position of the incision is a result of this
    • Posted

      Hi m05, you are absolutely correct. It seems to be more common and easier for non medical people to talk about the approaches in terms of the incision. But that’s what it’s all about, where the surgeon approaches the hip joint from. Thanks for bringing up this important point.
    • Posted

      The way to definitely determine exactly what approach was used is

      1. Ask your surgeon, not the nurse or P.A.

      2. Get a copy of the Oerating report from the surgeons office or the hospital. It will be right up front, right after he or she describes the prep and positioning. 

      As I understand from my surgeon, all hip surgeries have some muscles cut. The restrictions have to do with what muscles were cut, as they need a longer time to heal and the risk of dislocation is high.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.