Osteoporosis - Thin bones?

Posted , 9 users are following.

This may be a dumb question but here goes.  Eight months ago I broke my wrist in a bicycle accident. X-rays showed extreme arthritis and when the fracture healed my thumb was fused and very painful. X-rays also showed a 2nd fracture at base of thumb which ortho ignored and I'm convinced this contributed to the thumb issue. Went to 2nd (excellent) ortho who performed arthroplasty and fixed the thumb.  During surgery bones kept crumbling but he finally pinned them and later removed the pins successfully.  Advised that bones are extremely thin & I should ask my PCP about osteoporosis meds.  (Bone density scan showed T score of -2.5).   Ortho kindly suggested any fall would likely result in a fracture of something.  PCP isn't concerned and did not prescribe osteo meds.  I'm not a big fan of any medication but am even less of a fan of fractures.  Between the fracture and later surgery I was one-armed for 6 months and that got very old.  This fracture was NOT caused by osteoporosis but by hitting the pavement from a bucking bicycle; however I sure would like to avoid any future breaks.  I'm 73 and pretty healthy, took no regular prescription meds until a couple of years ago.  Here's my question (finally): Does anyone have suggestions re. whether or not I should press for osteo meds?  I do take calcium+D3.

Thanks for your thoughts.

Thanks.

1 like, 10 replies

10 Replies

  • Posted

    Ask if you can see a osteoperosis specialist! No one wants to live with the threat of falling that could become life changing. Sometimes we have to be aggressive with doctors and press for our own health and become our own health advocate. 

    Do as much research as u can and be ready to follow up with your doctor ! 

     

  • Posted

    -2.5 is osteopenia not osteoporosis and there is much you can do naturally to help your bone health.

    Vitamin K2 puts the calcium onto the bones. Further support by having calcium rich foods like leafy greens, bones in sardines, yoghurt, cheese until you reach a really good level of calcium. Magnesium has also been named to help as people who have broken bones have been found to have a lack of magnesium.

    A diet rich in fruit and vegetables is also recommended.

    Prunes,  broth made from bones, avocados and skin of cucumbers are other sources of nutrients to help bones. 

    Research online about nutrients for bone health.

  • Posted

    That choice is yours, there should be enough information on this site about arthritis for you to be able to decide what you want to do about it and what treatment you want to try.  You will see that some people prefer to supplement with magnesium, vitamin K , zinc, etc. and others opt for conventional medicine.  No one can decide for you though, the choice is yours, but it sounds as though you need to start something asap. X
  • Posted

    You call that a dumb question?  You need advice and you have asked.😏

    Take Kathleen’s  advice - she is the expert on this forum I believe.

  • Posted

    I'm with Kathleen . We don't take pharmaceutical osteoperosis meds but take the natural route. Lots of fresh fruit, lots of green leafy veg especially Kale (great in smoothies). Calcium enriched food like cheese milk yoghurt.

    Vitamins calcium + vit D, magnesium, vitamin K2 from Natto, fish oil.

    Lots of fish like salmon, mackerel, sardines. Prunes are great too.

    I have two fractures L3/L4 the co-codamol the doc prescribed made me very ill. I stopped taking them and

    For anyone interested I have discovered that the mineral from the frankinsense tree called Boswellia has high anti imflamitory properties with out any side effects. It is so much better than ibuprofen. My pain has reduced to hardly any within a week, my fractures are healing faster. I am amazed at the speed of this natural product and hardly anyone has ever heard if it.

    So Linda it's really up to you which route you take but at least there is plenty of information and advice from this group. Good luck.

    • Posted

      Thank's Evelyn, that's really useful information for people like myself interested in natural medicines.

      Can you tell me the best place/manufacturer to buy this from.

    • Posted

      Ladies

      I've replied to Ruby using the message service here as the admin don't like us advertising where we purchased our supplements etc

      If any one else is interested in Boswellia let me know.

    • Posted

      Interesting about boswellia.  It looks like reputable sites say it is an effective anti inflammatory.  We need to check for drug interactions if we are on any other medication.  Think I may try it.  Thanks Evelyn.
  • Posted

    With your reading you do not need to press for OP med.  You MUST eat food which will support good bone health, basically a healthy diet low in refined carbs and sugar and high in vegetables especially leafy greens.  You should consider taking Vitamin K2 as well as Vitamin D3, and calcium if you feel you may not be getting enough from your diet.  Fermented foods like some cheese, kefir and yoghurt are better for calcium absorption than plain liquid milk.  Get as much appropriate exercise as you can manage - weight bearing like walking, you don't need to go to a gym unless you want to!

    Best wishes!

  • Posted

    Hi Linda

    If you are osteopenic, (not osteoporotic) exercise should be weight bearing, and unfortunately, although good cardiovascular exercise, riding a bike does not fall into this category.  Walking, running, weights in the gym are all good for conserving bone density. 

    Good luck with your research, but diet and exercise can both certainly assist against further bone deterioration.

    Caro

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.