Strontium for bone density?

Posted , 8 users are following.

Hi, I'm wondering if anyone has ever used strontium supplements instead of bisphosphonates for bone density, and if so, any good results?

 

0 likes, 9 replies

9 Replies

  • Posted

    Hi Sarah. I was on Strontium Citrate for several months until I got prescription Strontium Ranelate in 2011 and have been on it ever since. After 2 yrs on SR my bone density improved by approximately 10%.  Even allowing for the technical error of as much as 50%, I was still happy with this result. 

    Remember though that bone health is not just about improving your T score, as this doesn’t  reflect the actual bone flexibility which is just as important as the density.  

    This is influenced by the state of the collagen protein, bone matrix ie framework.  

    For this we need quality protein in our diet to provide the building material for its constant repair and renewal.  This protein  is also required for muscle strength.    Resulting in bones having strength and flexibility.  We are therefore less likely to break bone should we stumble and fall.

    The book  ‘Vitamin K2 and the Ca Paradox’ by Kate Rheaume Bleue explains how Mg, D3, K2 and A retinol work together to aid the absorption and utilization of Ca.

    While the following discuss the importance of protein.  http://blogs.creighton.edu/heaney/2014/07/25/the-paradox-of-osteoporosis-irreversibility-2/   

    Best wishes

  • Posted

    Hi Sarah,  do you mean the prescribed medication Protelos?  If yes, I was on it for a couple of years but my GP took me off it, as there was some doubt that it triggered heart attacks.  Seems they all have some potential nasty side effects. Regards, Stefania
  • Posted

    Thanks for the responses and info. I guess I just meant strontium as a supplment you'd get in a health store. I notice though, that it's not easy to get in health stores. 

    I had read about the heart side effect and that did put me off somewhat. I'm being asked to go on fosamax and I just can't pluck up the courage. But also, I'll be having a thyroidectomy soon, which was the cause of my osteo to start with, so I'm looking for something to tide me over that may be beneficial but isn't bisphosphonates. Seems like there's a downside to everything biggrin 

    Thanks for the above links. I'll read those...

    • Posted

      The heart and circulatory events that occurred, were infact in folk who ALREADY had  these health issues BEFORE  starting SR.  They were also elderly and immobile.  The figures were something like 1.9%  events with SR and 1.6% on placebo.  They were at risk anyway due to immobility!      In my opinion a storm in a teacup.    Best wishes.
    • Posted

      Hi, I was prescribed Prolia which is not bisphosphonates. Its injected in the thigh every 6 months. I had the 1st one and didn't go for more...latest research shows side effects are nasty after a couple of years use. I have had bad falls and nothing broke ( I am slim so it wasn't a question of fat protecting bones.) I daresay if I had broken something  I would have continued it.

    • Posted

      Google health unlocked my osteoporosis journey.  There are some links in that little essay which you could find helpful.  Research has proven that nutrition, including some supplements, and appropriate exercise can help improve bone health.
    • Posted

      Hello Anhaga just a big thanks due to your advice I think I am now on the right road to fight road natural supplements for my osteoporosis. If you remember o am in pradaxa for blood clots and having tests for heart and lung problems. My doctor did a john clease when I mentions k vitamins

      His arms were all over when I asked about them. Well just got my results and heart and lungs are ok and chest specialist says k2 is no problem with pradaxa as you had already said

      I have read the book with the rh author along with other books and find it to be the best and now following it. Thank you so much.

    • Posted

      Glad you seem to me getting good support from chest specialist. All the best!

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.