TAR surgery in near future
Posted , 4 users are following.
I've read the ankle replacement forum for some time now (about 20 pages worth). My wife had a tri-malleolar break four+ years ago. The cartilage is gone. She's a candidate for TAR, and has investigated two docs here in Virginia: Dr. Cooper at Georgetown and Dr Schipper at Anderson (Schipper operates out of Inova Fairfax). Cooper performs the STAR replacment; Schipper installs the Infinity. I would be very grateful to hear from those with personal experience -- which hospital is better, which surgeon, which system. She (and I) are tending toward the Infinity because it is a fixed bearing system. I did do some research on the Zimmer system -- the significant improvement might be the highly crosslinked poly as opposed to the ultra molecular poly alone (for the spacer), but I'm not an engineer nor a doctor...just doing due diligence. Thanks for responses in advance - John.
0 likes, 11 replies
david31086 JDNo6
Posted
I am also moving towards a TAR using Infinity but in Atlanta. It is best to make sure the surgeon has done at least 100 TAR's or more and get testimonials. And then trust God for the rest
I about killed myself doing research about TAR's and in the end have delayed it now hoping for a natural healing or "holding". I wish you the best and will pray for you and all TAR folks
David
tim32886 david31086
Posted
lauren87463 tim32886
Posted
So sorry to hear of your bad outcome. That truly sucks. No way to have it redone by a different surgeon? 😬
lauren87463 JDNo6
Posted
JDNo6
Posted
Well, after much more research and reading technical papers, my wife has decided to go with the Vantage TAR -- and Dr. Mark Easley at Duke as the surgeon. He was one of the inventors of the device two years ago. Her first appointment is in a couple of weeks, and we'll see if she is even a candidate for the Vantage. I think that's one of the problems associated with Implants Gone Bad -- that the surgeon chosen is effective for a particular TAR device -- but it may not be the right one for that particular patient. Of course...no one owns up to this dirty little secret. But that will be our first question to Dr. Easley, and we'll evaluate his answer carefully. Thanks for the replies -- Lauren, your reply especially convinced her to go with a more experienced surgeon.
- John.
lauren87463 JDNo6
Posted
I totally agree re: the dirty little secret. Docs often get trained on one device and stick with it bc they’re comfortable with it. That’s why I liked my guy: he’d worked with 4-5 different devices and knew a lot about 7-8 of them. Also, here’s a 2013 list of who the ankle docs would go to if they needed ankle surgery. Top 26 foot and ankle surgeons in North America. There’s one in Charlotte, NC if u decide to meet more surgeons. And not that this list is the be all end all. Also, Duke itself has a strong reputation and is a research hospital so they’re likely always researching the latest and greatest. And—you’ve done a ton of research. Since the Vantage is so new, I’d dig into how they know it won’t fail, etc. since it hasn’t been around long enough to have a proven track record. That said, could be that they created it by making improvements on already proven devices, which would be a good thing. Me, I’m a tad nervous of those who were involved in inventing it bc they have a built in bias. Doesn’t mean they’re not damn good surgeons with a damn good implant. Just worth noting. Best of luck to your wife. And you—because you’ll be waiting on her left and right for a couple months since she’ll be non-weight-bearing or on crutches and unable to carry stuff. 🤪
JDNo6 lauren87463
Posted
lauren87463 JDNo6
Posted
lauren87463 JDNo6
Posted
P.s. Any chance your wife's doc at Duke is Dr. Easley? If so, some folks are saying good things about him in the Total Ankle Replacement Group on Facebook. Just an fyi.
JDNo6 lauren87463
Posted
lauren87463 JDNo6
Posted