To abstain or not to abstain, that is the question?

Posted , 11 users are following.

I read a book some years back (I will look it up if anyone asks) by a psychiatrist specialising in helping people with Alcohol Use Disorder. His guidance for deciding if you should abstain completely was to ask his patients to set a limit for how much they drink on any single occasion. If they broke this more than two or three times in a year, then he advised they should consider abstention as the only option. Is this setting the bar a little too high, and if you think it is, what would make you consider abstaining completely from alcohol?

0 likes, 51 replies

51 Replies

Prev
  • Posted

    Mixed report on first fortnight. The issue is the week-ends and two or three binge evenings. Without these I would be fine. Habit of a lifetime really. So about 40 units each week in total, which may not seem much to some here, but I don't feel in control. A bit like a car with faulty brakes. Not a good feeling and I just lost half a night's sleep. Usually I'm a good sleeper but that is the effect of last night's binge.

    • Posted

      I did really well this past weekend.  Had a "girls" weekend Fri night to Monday.  Friday from 3 pm to midnight I had about 8 beers and some sipping on tequila.  I know that is definitely over the limit and I felt it the next day but wasn't terrible as it was mostly beer.  The next 2 nights I was able to keep it at 2 cocktails each night and felt fabulous the rest of the weekend.  I now feel more resolved to keep at this pace or maybe even stop altogether......

      Sometimes I think that as my psychologist says, it happens when it's supposed to happen, and it comes naturally at that time.  I sure wish that had happened sooner as I am 57 years old, but it's never too late I guess.  Feeling optimistic.  Tired of the merry go round that alcohol  has been in my life.

  • Posted

    I am pretty clear on the issue for me. Two or three drinks and stop - fine (say 5-6 units). More than that and it is an open question on where it ends up. Usually in double figures. That's a binge. I think the short term enjoyment of the binge is often to compensate for other stuff bringing me down. Some of these may be running in our lives for decades. But, of course, adding alcohol use disorder to whatever other disorder there is in life just makes for one more issue to resolve. So I enjoyed the beer and the bottle of wine with dinner last night but it shortened my sleep and leaves me full of regret this morning. It does feel like a merry go round that isn't very merry; and on one or two binges per week, I need to get off.

    • Posted

      good and honest message....perhaps it is time to stop complete this year? I felt guilty and kept wondring IF I could stop and kept looking for more and eventually did mange to stop...up to you. Do not forget to pamper yourself IF you manage to stay sober for one week....Just an idea...Robin
    • Posted

      Thanks Robin. I do dry days but I have never been able to face up to complete abstention. Frankly, I doubt I could do it after decades of drinking. 'Staying sober for a week' is an interesting expression. Most days I am sober. Just a couple of hours when the units creep up (always with food) on maybe one, occasionally two, evenings at week-ends. I don't even have a hangover the next day. So I'm reluctant to commit to something I couldn't achieve as that would probably be a bit demoralising too. Anyway, I appreciate your thoughts and I will keep weighing up the options.

    • Posted

      Hi Thomas! I'm curious as to what issues you encounter while binging as I can't imagine a binge without a hangover. Tou said you are regretful the next day.....is that from becoming unruly the night before or just feeling low from the over intake?

    • Posted

      Honest reply again! of course it is hard and perhaps even impossible to stop completely after 30+ yrs drinking? ?I am guessing here....gradually drinking less is an option and some day off is also great..we are all different and you here on this Forum and chatting with us...Super! Robin
    • Posted

      Hi Dee. My binges may not be high up the scale compared to others but I just don't like not being in control. I don't really encounter issues. I just enjoy the buzz and with a tendency to depression, I find alcohol alleviates that in the short term. I know it can also contribute to depression in the long term too.

    • Posted

      Thanks Robin. Managed a dry day today so my weekly intake is only double the recommended 15 units for this week. Many might think that is hardly a problem but I would just like to drink less and be in control every time I have a drink.
  • Posted

    Not a good week so far. 2 dry days and 2 'binges' which lost me sleep. Over 6 units or so and I wake after 3-4 hours sleep and then just doze so it costs me half a night's sleep. Yesterday I had a couple of beers - even counted the units on my Drinkaware app - and then made a bad decision to buy a bottle of white wine at the local shop which I shared, but had two-thirds. Units in double figures and another half night's sleep. I know whole bottles of white are a bad idea but something just said: 'I don't care. I'm going to enjoy this.' Which I did! Till I woke at 4 am. This feels like addiction or a habit that I seem to just want to give in to at times. And yet I know the consequences. Very odd behaviour. I suspect something underneath it all - I get depressed at times - is causing me to look to alcohol for relief. And, of course, in the short term it works. So drinking too much is not entirely irrational.

     

    • Posted

      Well I'm having issues also ugh. A binge once each week past two weeks.  Taking the bull by the horns and going AF.  Seeing a counselor and doing a lot of reading.  Good book This Naked Mind by Annie Grace I think is her name.   Very interesting and different  from the few other books I have read. I won't tell myself never again… But I am telling myself that I need to do this and definitely to see what the outcome is in my heart and soul and mind.   I'm posting mainly in the FB page Club Soda now; check it out.  

  • Posted

    Not a good week-end but if the week has lapses then the total for the whole week is usually too high. Getting on for 50 units. If only I could always stop at 5 or 6 units. I do sometimes but I feel like a car with faulty brakes and you wouldn't want to go for a drive in one of those! And another half night of sleep. For me too much wakes me up although I know others in these forum find alcohol helps them to sleep. I discovered what is happening to me on 6+ units is called glutamine rebound where the liver counter acts the effect of too much alcohol by producing something to keep the system going. It's like strong coffee and I can feel it buzzing through me lying awake in bed. It can last all through the second half of the night so it's 3 or 4 hours poor quality sleep followed by dozing in between buzzing. Honestly, why would anyone want to put themselves through this just for an extra two or three glasses of wine? I guess that is why it is called a disorder.

     

  • Posted

    I am going to go AF.  Joined the group on FB called Club Soda and love it.  Reading This Nake Mind - excellent book on why we drink....so much good and new information to me in there.  Some of it makes me pretty angry about how we are conditioned and about the alcohol industry.  Think about going AF?  I'm giving it a go.

    • Posted

      I hope it goes well for you. I'm persevering with my original plan. Keep us posted how you get on.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.