TURP verses Everything Else

Posted , 15 users are following.

I have read for several years the Patient blog looking for the correct way to handle my enlarged prostate issues. I have learned a lot and am grateful to those that went before me and posted their experiences. The idea of a TURP scared the hell out of me, especially after reading some experiences, all negative. Instead, after an examination by my Urologist, I decided on a PAE. He told me that I was not a good candidate for a Urolift due to an enlarged median lobe. He offered a procedure called a Greenlight Laser. I went for the PAE. The procedure for the PAE was effortless and for about 6 months after the procedure it seemed like I had made the right choice. It was not to be. I switched Urologist for a number of reasons and found one that I could talk to and discuss my feelings and how I may have made a mistake with the PAE. He was very accommodating and a good listener. He started off with a cystoscopy, my third one and uncomfortable. His opinion was a TURP was the only way to go. Not what I wanted to hear, yet, I decided just to get it done because of all the problems, UTI on a continuous basis. After the procedure, I could urinate like I was 20. A feeling I had not had in some 30 years. He also told me my median lobe was the primary culprit of my problems as the prostate was not as enlarged as he thought it would be and was rated at 43 grams, which is rather small compared to most people that have posted on here. The median lobe was really enlarged and elongated (something unusual). I was drawing close to having a catheter as my only relief. The TURP turned out to be entirely painless and not one instance of the discomfort I had read so many times about. The catheter was left in me over the weekend (3 days) and removed first thing Monday morning. I was put on a new drug called Uribel for pain and as a antibiotic. It turns your urine a beautiful color of blue. My TURP healed with no issues. Urinated blood one time after four weeks and it never repeated itself. I am off all prostate medications. My urination has slowed a little and not the firehose effect I initially had after the TURP, but so much better. My only issue is a flair up of inflamation of the prostate every once in awhile. Working on that issue. After all the aggravation and making decisions, do the TURP and get it done correctly. There is retrograde ejaculation and for those that want to father children that may be a show stopper. For me it was not. Also, I was put on Finasteride 5mg (generic for Proscar) to prevent my prostate from regrowing and eliminating another TURP years from now. Warning: Proscar can cause an aggressive form of prostate cancer in some people so make sure you discuss that with your doctor. The trade off at my age is worth it since my PSA have been consistently 0.9 prior to using Proscar. It also causes your hair to grow back, a side benefit for some. Best of luck to everyone.

2 likes, 18 replies

18 Replies

Prev
  • Posted

    Henry

    your information was very helpful to me

    I have gone through all the same experiences that you have but I chose PAE over TURP because I was very fearful of all the TALK about SEVERE side effects and also the talk about PROSCAR causing prostate cancer .

    I'm still hoping my PAE results will be good but after reading your discussion I’m not so fearful of getting the TURP next time.

    In North Carolina we have an expert in robotic surgeryIn North Carolina we have an expert in robotic surgery which is a more simple version of TURP which is a more simple version of TURP

    thank you and have a good day

    • Edited

      andrew 80762 , please name the doctors to whom you refer in NC.

      To all who read this thread , i am working on a decision between TURP , HoLEP, and Aquablation.

      As is common to all of us, I fear permanent Incontinence the most. secondly, i fear ED. I can deal with RE if necessary .

      i have read this forum posts for several nights. The more I read the more confused I become .

      My prostate is 60 grams. So far I'm not retaining urine after voiding . flow weak, especially after awakening during the night. stream is especially weak, unlike during the day. i wake up due to bladder pressure every 1 1/2 hours . i limit fluid intake after 6 PM.

      I'd appreciate any input .

    • Posted

      I had been suffering from BPH for several years with a couple acute retention episodes. I decided to get the Rezum procedure in April 2022. That procedure, supposedly minimally invasive, but done while you are completely awake feeling everything, was awful. The recovery was not too bad, but there was minimal affect on my flow and symptoms. I had a brief period maybe 1-2 months out where I thought things were improving, but then they just returned to my old normal. I wasted another year and a half trying to decide what to do next, again suffering a few acute retention episodes. My prostate size was only 35, and I decided to consult with a remote urologist that did Aquablation. His frank recommendation to me was that given my size, I'd likely have similar outcome from a TURP. I eventually decided to go ahead with a bi-polar button TURP which is what my local urologist recommended. I'm just over 3 weeks out and am so glad I did it, and wish I would have done it right from the start and not wasted more time. I'm peeing like a 20 year old and actually have not experienced retro so far, but even if I do at a later time, the trade off is absolutely worth it for me. I was knocked out for the procedure and was sent home same day with a catheter. I had no pain other than the discomfort of the catheter. The only unfortunate part was that I was instructed to remove the catheter the next day, and when I did I had some obstruction due to clots or material, and could barely get anything to come out. I had to return to the clinic in distress and had another catheter painfully installed, which I kept in for 3 more days. Once that was removed I was doing great. There's so much FUD out there about TURPs, but based on my experience so far, it seems like a very effective and easy procedure. Hope this helps.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.