What does it feel like to have Klinefelters' syndrome?

Posted , 68 users are following.

Another contributor wishes to discuss what it feels like to have Klinefelters' syndrome, so I thought I'd start a discussion on that topic, see what comes of it?

I'd like to be able to choose XXY as a place to put this discussion, then we can chat about what it feels like to be fat, or to have gynaecomastia, or to be sterile, and any other disease associated with being XXY.

6 likes, 399 replies

399 Replies

Prev Next
  • Posted

    hi again i have changed Endocrinologist and hospitals and i have someone finally that is a specialist, also with PhD degree in it an a professor. He tried to contact your Milton Diamond which didnt work becos M. Diamond doesnt practice anymore and refuses to deal with the general public, only sees "private" paying patients. But this doesnt matter anymore becos i am getting answers. I thought u mite want to know that i was born a male with female body inside and out, still a XXY but perhaps the Y part is dormant within me. I cant relate to the fact u mentioned about pubic hair design as i have never had any body hair whatsoever, i have hair on my head only. And according to my new doctor he said heart valve problems are common in all  XXY patients male or female but does not usually manifest til later in life (over 50), and the reason i have life threatening blood clots is becos i was taking hormone therapy in the form of oestrogen which can  cause blood clots to form, I was on oestrogen for 20 years and the resulting blood clot was the largest ever found in a living person, at least in Australia (from my big toe to my armpit, lungs, heart and other vital areas)They are still testing me for everything under the sun including trying to find my testes which i must have somewhere they said and they are backtracking my hysterectomy records for me to see if at the time they removed ovaries or testes or both and i  just wasnt told about it, which my dr said was sometimes the case years ago so as not to upset the patient with emotional or mental trauma...u know what they dont know wont hurt them so to speak. But it will be in the records somewhere, so heres hoping. thanks for your help XXY Guy, u really did help me even if you didnt believe me at first, u made me think twice about the treatment i was given or not been given which made me change doctors and hospitals. I will never be allowed to have oestrogen again and i need testosterone injections in order for my body to convert this into oestrogen..go figure that one out lol. i can have progesterone injections every 3 mths in order to keep my female characteristics .
    • Posted

      Hi, I thought I did believe you, I even passed on a link to a document written by Dr Milton Diamond about a woman similar to you, with XXY sex chromosomes, whom he described as a female with Klinefelters' syndrome.  The fact that I think the doctor is 100% wrong in regard to the woman having Klinefelters' syndrome should not be taken as a reflection of your honesty, or of my belief in what you say.

      It's really good you've found a doctor who can treat you, and advise you correctly, although you will be the very first person ever to have been found to have 2 sets of opposite gonads!   My understanding is it is completely impossible, however it is possible to have had, or have, Ovotesis, which as the name implies are gonads made up of ovarian and testicular tissue. 

      Generally people think a hermaphrodite is someone with both male and female external genitalia, but medically speaking a hermaphrodite is someone with both ovarian and testicular tissue in the same or opposite gonads. So if you do have a testicle, or did have ovotestes, you would be described as a hermaphrodite, well you would have been until recently when all the terms and names changed to be more accurate.  Dearest darling Dr Milton Diamond has described XXY males as 'male pseudohermaphrodites' even thougn the wouldn't any more owing to that change I mentioned. If he were asked I'm certain he'd say we XXY males were not real males.

      Not being a doctor I can't really comment on the therapy you're receiving,  I just hope it works out well for you.

    • Posted

      As for heart disease, or a particular disease of the heart, in XXY males. I can't see how it is possible to say every XXY male has either, or will develop either.  The most common attribute of XXY males is infertility, but it's not 100%, it is not universal.  So how can heart disease, or a particular disease of the heart be universal?  

      Heart disease in males is substantially higher than in females, but not every man will get heart disease and not every female will be spared heart disease. There are just some diseases that appear more frequently in certain population groups, and XXY males are indeed a population group.  

      Take that back to your not as smart as s/he could be doctor. frown    

    • Posted

      hi, i didnt say ALL XXY ppl got heart problems, i said it seemed to be a common thing amongst them (according to drs) so its not a certainty that u all will get it.  As for the testes scan, they have found one and are in the process of working out when i can have it out as it can turn cancerous easily ...apparently. It was nowhere where u think it mite be, was located behind my liver.  And just for the record, a PhD means only that that person is a doctor of philosophy, i myself have a PhD, so if i want to i can call myself a doctor ha ha. Elasmobranchology is my thing, and thats nothing to do with the human body whatsoever lol.Thanks for your good wishes and i hope all of you guys on this forum have a great day and dont worry, be happy.
  • Posted

    so i am not suffering from Klinefelters syndrome as i was told in the beginning, like u said its impossible but how was i to know this, u sorta believe what the dr says dont u? I have another thing that hasnt been given a name yet, there will be one but they not sure which one as of yet. I am not CAIS altho they thought so at first. Complete DNA testing is been done in Tasmania as Adelaide has no such testing centres haha, backward Adelaide
    • Posted

      Do I believe what doctors tell me?   Well I used to.  When I was first diagnosed I did.  It was when they began withholding information that I became suspicious. They started withholding infgormation from the very beginning.

      Dr Risely at Kopata Medical Centre, Lower Hutt, told me, "we think you have another chromosome, we think you have Klinefelters' syndrome"  and after a while, and an examination he said "if you ever want to talk about anything I'll always be here."   It took me a while to find something to talk about as all the nitty gritty, really important stuff he failed to mention!  My parents were told more than I was at the very beginning!  My grandmother knew more than me when I was first diagnosed. I was very annoyed to discover I was the talk of the family before I KNEW anything.

      So; do I believe what doctors say, not really, I believe what I can independently discover, and get them to confirm it if necessary?      

  • Posted

    Also the previous Endocrinologist is been investigated by the Medical Board based on what treatment and wrong advice he gave to me and also a couple other patients of his. Flinders Medical Centre is a teaching hospital and mainly has still learning doctors  treating the general public. I now go to Royal Adelaide Hospital and see a proper more knowledgable Dr who specialises in Chromosomal Abnormalities, and teaches other doctors about it. He has worked in USA, England, Europe and now in Australia.
    • Posted

      Well this is what you did say exactly,

      "And according to my new doctor he said heart valve problems are common in all  XXY patients male or female but does not usually manifest til later in life (over 50),"  

      So something common in all XXY's is ALL to me, what does "all" mean to you? rolleyes I'm over 50 and I don't have heart valve problems, yet, and I sure am XXY, have been all my life, and I do mean ALL in this instance.  cheesygrin 

      I think some doctors just get carried away with themselves.  In reality MOST XXY's are never diagnosed at all, as the worldwide studies done in the 60's, 70's, and 80's to determine incidence of XXY, (and every other aneuploidy) and the prevalence of Klinefelters' syndrome diagnosed in older men has a strong realtionship?  The doctors do like to tell us XXY is KS!  One study I have from that era  lists all the karyotypes found with additional X's, or males with no Y's, as "Klinefelters' Syndrome" and has an incidence rate of 1:596 (live male births).  No XXY females were found in that study, which tested 34,910 newborns between 1969-1974 & 1980 -1988.  

      Even when my Endocrinologist says something about XXY/KS these days I ask 'got anything written down about that?'  Maybe your brand new Endocrinologist has more up to date information than me, and maybe s/he can provide a copy of it, as if it exists it will be written down. lol

  • Posted

    yes i know i said ALL becos the drs told me nearly ALL XXY ppl, male or female have heart valve problems as a common ailment... whether this is true or not i do not know i was only quoting what i have been told personally. I am also over 50 and i do have heart valve defect which they "tell " me is due to the fact that i am XXY. I have also had a heart attack induced by a Cardiologist on purpose to see how much exercise i could take before one happened, which i do not agree with either, but its already happened.... 5days ago to be exact, last friday. So now i am recovering from that. I do no longer believe anything anymore whatever dr says what and this and that i just nod and say oh yeah.... each dr/endocrinogist seems to have their own opinion and ideas on WHAT  sort of human being i am, but since this all started, every single drs report from anywhere, including those for nothing to do with XXY have all stated in the gender part....Male which doesnt make me feel so good. I mite be genetically a male but since i have never had any male parts to my knowledge then i dont consider myself to be male and i do NOT want to be male. I have only said things to you and anyone else in this forum as i was told it to me. Before this year i had never heard of Klinefelters syndrome.... i believed what drs told me years ago about me having absorbed my twin and collected DNA from him...silly me but i never thought any different until this year when all hospitals listed me as having Klinefelters and kept asking me when my trans gender operation was performed...... it nearly killed me mentally i mite add but now i just disregard whatever i am told becos i dont know what to believe anymore. I really dont trust the medical system at all now. 
  • Posted

    since you yourself have no evidence of heart disease, i hope u never get any, its not very nice.
    • Posted

      Oh I don't?  I didn't know that!  biggrin  I did have 4 heart attacks in one afternoon, does that qualify?  4 days after I was admitted to hospital I signed myself out as I hate being in hospital and felt fine. They had me walk a treadmill for a few minutes, 15 or 20, or something, and decided I was right, I was fine.

      Anyway, all I'm prepared to say for a certainty is that ALL XXY's are XXY.  I can find reports that indicate educational difficulty for XXY boys, and adult XXY men who say they never had any educational difficulty and are offended by the suggestion.

      The reason there is wide viariability of effect in XXY's could be the X inactivation they have, in that it is skewed.  Usually people with 2 X's have random X inactivation, and they're usually female,  So the X from the mother and father is turned on and off roughly evenly, whereas those of us with more than 1 X, and male, and with the genes that say 'make a male' so 46XX males also qualify,  have groups of X's from the same parent turned on and off, or not random at all.

      How you came about, well that's more speculation in order, it may be thyat you absorbed a twin, and it may be that you came by the X in a perfectly ordinary way, and obtained the Y by accident?  Obviously the 'make a male' genes are not present or not functioning.

      You're much more unique than any of us regular XXY male types. rolleyes          

    • Posted

      15 mins on a treadmill?? thats pretty good i only lasted 4.5mins and ive been breathless ever since, even while resting. They also tell me this is due to been XXY which im really sick of hearing..i told em all u dont know what ur talking about, u only know what another person has said which is wrong. They then said to me well ur just a patient what would u know, and i replied probably not much but more than u guys i reckon. And then i also walked out. I dont want to be unique i just want to be me but ",me" at the moment is a bit lost
    • Posted

      walked out haha i didnt exactly walk out lol, i stayed in hospital overnight becos i could hardly breathe let alone walk, and next day i got sombody to come pick me up and i signed myself out.
    • Posted

      I hate being in hospital. I'm the governments friend when it comes to health care and hospitals, they want to wheel em in and wheel em out the same day if possible and I agree!   I have work to do, a life to lead, I don't have time to be laid up in hospital... unless I'm in severe pain, and it has to be severe!  

      The ICU nurse said to me on the way in, 'this drug we want to give you might kill you, but you will die if you don't have it, and we need your consent to give it to you.'  So I gave INFORMED consent. rolleyes So I was pretty sick, I reckon... and 4 days later I was not sick at all, so I signed myself out.

      In the mean time I've been back several times for what was an unknown 'mystery' illness.   It turned out to be my gall bladder, so that was whipped out a few months ago.... and I tell people my fat belly is because they pumped me full of some gas for the key-hole surgery, and my muscles haven't settled back down yet!  biggrin  Any excuse will do other than 'I eat too much and exercise too little!'  eek

      Heart disease as a general topic is common in XXY's, but in this day and age specific types of heart disease will be hard to prove on the basis of  karyotype as we (people in general) know that males are prone to heart disease whatever their karyotype.  Then there's smoking, what relationship does that have to karyotype, other than XXY tend to be anxious, and prone to risky behaviour, like smoking tobacco.  

      Oh and it's not the smoke and tar and gunge that's the problemn but nicotine itself, it causes inflammation!

      I'm from New Zealand, we eat lots of red meat, even though I don't anymore, but I have done, and I drink alcohol, another cause of heart disease.  The flavour is in the fat, and I still eat the fat in meats, and my testosteorne I take is transported round my body in fat, and I'm advised to take it after a meal....so is it the testosterone or the fat that's the problem? 

      I know therer's a genetic link to heart disease, simply because males are more affected than females, so it could be that your Y is an aggrovating factor, but I'm pretty sure there'll be plenty of other aggrovating factors also. 

      I wish this place had a spell checker!  redface

    • Posted

      Someone here was mentioning breast cancer, how XXY males have the same risk of breast cancer as females, now why would that be do you wonder?  Do you think it's the extra X, or could it be the lack of exercise, the obesity, the lowered testosterone, and the out of sync testosterone/oesrogen ratio?

      Do you have an out of sync testosterone/oestrogen ratio?  Do you check yourself for lumps? We're advised in some publications to check ourselves, well those of us who've never had bilateral mastectomy that is.

      I used to have a massive level of estradiol, that's the male version of oestrogen, what testosterone is converted into I understand.  Males need oestrogen too, and they need it all their lives, and since they don't have ovaries, they have to it converted from testosterone, and if there's not enough testosterone, there is not enough oestrogen too, and they get very tall as a result.  

      Did you know that is why females are shorter generally, than males?  Females get a large dose of oestrogen in early puberty and their long bones stop growing, but males don't produce sufficient testosterone to be converted until the end of puberty, so generally they're much taller than females.

      So how tall are you?  

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.