Bunion Surgery is it really worth it???

Posted , 10 users are following.

I am now awaiting a appt with my specialist re my bunion, but reading all of the FORUMS I am beginning to change my mind as everyone seems to be in pain and it doesnt look good, so is it best to put up with the pain now or is it really worth it ??????

0 likes, 45 replies

45 Replies

Prev Next
  • Posted

    I think that if you are in pain now than its worth trying to do something about your bunion! My dad is a very young 84 . He has horrible bunions. He has had to have 2 toes removed in the last 5 years because of them. I asked if he could do it over would he have had surgery at a younger age, and he said yes definetly. 
  • Posted

    Hi Sharon

    I had a bilateral scarf and akin procedure about 1.5 years ago.  It does take a while to recover but my results are good, straight toe and no pain !

    The surgery is major and does take at leave 10-12 weeks to recover and with some swelling for up to a year.

    It was worth it for me.

     

  • Posted

    hi Sharon I went to two specialists for opinions and also lastly my family dr hoping one of them would at i didn't need the surgery. I am still in numbing block stage so all has gone well so far but that's supposed to change today. My dr had to operate on my second and third toes bc of damage done by bunion already and the right side of my foot was hurting bc it was overcompensating for the imbalance created by the bunion and my bunion was only getting larger slowly so I did it. Everyone i know personally has said it was totally worth it and the pain will pass. I was scared and today I'm very anxious awaiting the pain to set in but it can't be worse than I've set up in my mind and think about it like pain with a purpose. You and I will be better for it.

    • Posted

      Thank you so much I've just been up the mall contemplating not going through with it and trying on shoes that I can no longer wear thank you again

      Let me know how you get on honey

  • Posted

    Dear Sharon

    ?I only had bunion on one foot, it had become more and more painful, especially if standing around and was finding it more and more difficult to buy shoes.  I had to have Toe Fusion which is more radical that ordinary bunion surgery, I was in plaster for 6 weeks and had to keep off foot.  Rehabilitation is slow with this but I just would not go back to how it was before, I run and play games with the grand children.  I can't wear high heels for long but the foot looks so much better and the pain has gone and although it still takes time to select shoes that will work with me I would not hesitate to recommend if you have pain - I put up with mine for years as I was like you, worried I might be worse off.  I had mine done at Ipswich Hospital in Suffolk (UK) when I was around 55 years, am now 61.

    • Posted

      Hello. I also have my toe fused. I'm 3 weeks post op. How does your toe feel now? Does it touch the floor? Did you get any physiotherapy ?

  • Posted

    I have been going around and around with myself on surgery as well. I have tailor's bunion's on each foot. I have seen mulitple doctors on the issue over the last year and a half. Family doctor, podistrist, and an orthopedic surgeron. I have done all of the conservative stuff and I get no lasting positive results from them. So I have been researching over and over again on this. I too have seen all of the posts, but I am leaning towards getting them fixed. The reason why is that I am 40 and they are pretty big in my eyes. I don't want to wait 10 to 20 years for them to get even worse. They always red and irritated. They are painful the more I walk, even worse when running and jumping. Good luck on your decision. 

    • Posted

      Hey

      I'm 42 also and am thinking the same it's only going to get worse isn't it and I want to be able to run again

      We must brave it

    • Posted

      I'm 49 and probably could have saved surgery on third toe at least if i had done it sooner. Still numb so far but will update by tmrw.

    • Posted

      I am a very active person too. Back in 2011 I weighed 278lbs and had a few health issues because of the weight - high blood pressure and sleep apena. I had to make a change and I turned to Fitbit to help lose the weight. Today I am 168lbs. I have done an extreme amount of walking over the last few years along with running and other outdoor activities. I don't want these bunions to slow my progress any further. I am willing to cut back on steps for awhile to get the problem fixed. I can do some with with IT bands and light weights a week or so after the surgery is done.

  • Posted

    I know how you feel, it is such a hard decision to make as it could be life changing if it is not successful.   I am hoping that there will be a miraculous minimally invasive operation one day. If there are people on this site who can give us more information on a more simpler bunion operation which ever country you are in please let us know. People will travel if it is a better and simpler option.
  • Posted

    I don't think there is an easy solution! I am 51 and very active. It was a hard decision to make. My bunions have been getting worse over time. I ran a half marathon last year and that did my right foot in. I tore a quarter inch hole in my plantar plate under my second toe in that was very painful. Very common with bunions. In fact I probably would not have had surgery if it weren't for the pain that this was causing. My big toe was pressing so much on the second toe that it made that second toe carry too heavy  a workload. I opted for the lapidus athrodesis surgery. No weight bearing for two months. I had a second opinion and was told that was a good choice for me. I also had an osteotomy ( shortening of the second toe in). They were unable to repair the tear. Long term I should be able to resume an active life style. Probably no more half marathons. I am now a firm believer in cross training! 

    • Posted

      Wow you've had quite a lot done on your feet but I'm guessing it's worth it in the long run x

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.