Heaven ~ Hell ~ where does purgatory fit in?
Posted , 6 users are following.
We've discussed in quite detail about that "afterlife" and I'd like to go back and forth if you will join me. I have a puzzling question that's been with me since as far back as I can recall.
If some say there is a heaven and a hell, are we in purgatory?
Frustrated
5 likes, 256 replies
frustrated61
Posted
So, with that said, I'm confused, is there a purgatory or not.
frustrated61
Posted
SteV3 frustrated61
Posted
Les.
frustrated61 SteV3
Posted
It's been a while since I've seen you post. How are you feeling?
Please try to find it in you to explain because the group that are collectively working out issues, state opinions and some with experience with situations. There's no wrong or right, but input is always welcomed!
Thank you for posting
Frustrated
SteV3 frustrated61
Posted
At the moment I'm still on same medication at the moment nothing as changed apart from the Neurologists injecting more Botox and over 10 weeks instead of 12 weeks. This was supposed to try and get me off Tramadol, which I tried lowering to 100mg a day, but the pain increased. So I guess the Botox needs increasing more before they can get me off Tramadol.
Interesting subject, "frustrated" - here in the UK it's not really on such a large scale as it is in the USA. I was brought up in a religious house, my mother was the most religious of them all, then my younger brother and then my dad - and then there was me.
To be honest, I have to say I do not believe in any form of "afterlife" - whether it is angelic or evil. My wife and I, have open minds on the subject and we have never got any of our 3 children baptised. From our point of view, should any of them wish to go to church then we would not stop them.
My wife believes in communicating to spirits via the Ouji board, none of our children or myself have nothing to do with this either. I guess it's an odd subject in our house.
I personally, have never believed in it (the bible, heaven or hell) and I have never read the bible either, you don't know which one to believe in, there's that many renditions of it, each one contradicts the others!
The thing that really annoy's me is people that try and 'ram' religion down your throat, who call themselves "jehovah's witnesses" their views are totally beyond belief - which I'll never understand.
I am a firm believer in science fact, if I have not seen physical evidence then to me it has never existed.
Now, you mentioned the word "purgatory", I know the so-called meaning of it, but who can honestly say that it even exists? Let me put another word to you, "Perjury" which is meant by when you lie under oath. Now, my brother and his wife are going through a very messy divorce involving their child and on a number of occassions his wife has lied under oath in court - what makes this even more strange is both are reborn again Christians! To me there is no difference in what they say by lying under oath as Christians, than a person that does not believe in any religion and lying.
People say God creates the way he wants it - if that's the case why do we have so many wars, diseases, murderers and all under dictators that do not listen to the public view of anyone. Perhaps it is true what people say and it is to keep the population down - then again, people these days are having children at younger ages and more of them, and people are living longer.
I have seen so much sadness in my life, just in our family alone, even lost a nephew at 14 months old, and the cure became available just 4 months too late. After that happened my wife mis-carried our first child at 3 months - and people wonder why we do not believe in the Bible.
As I see it, we just take one day at a time because you never know what is around the corner.
Regards,
Les.
georgeGG SteV3
Posted
SteV3 georgeGG
Posted
I have seen many movies that state "inspired by", "based on a true story" - but these don't just cover horror or evil, they also cover christian-based movies as well.
The way I see is life evolved, (maybe an alien force, there's too many conspiracy theories to even rule that out!). Dinosaurs ruled the earth, we know that from bones found worldwide. Throughout the millions of years, man has evolved into what man is today. Technology now increases at an incredible rate, but it is only man that is advancing and finding out how to push technology further.
We all know that IQ's are different from one person to the next, but humans have yet to discover further matter. Bring in Quantum physics, overviews, concepts and history, and then we bring in new perspectives. Albert Einstein had theoretical issues with quantum physics and tried for many years to disapprove or modify it, but failed. And he had a very high IQ in the 1900's, these days technology is catching up with predictions that were made in the early 1980's, computers came in to homes - now look at today. We already have cars that can not only park themselves, but can also drive you to your destination by voice command.
At this rate, unless humans wipe themselves out by stupidity - living on other planets will come from fiction to fact.
I must admit I was forward for my age at school, designed and built my first radio receiver when I was only 11 years old. When I reached 16, I was working and taking my exams. I say working, I was involved in designing prototype thermocouple devices capable of measuring to -270 degrees kelvin. I went on to college, doing advanced telecommunications studing, that's when I had an accident in my early 20's - which ended everything I had been taught. An accident that could of been avoided but I did not realize what was going to happen - career ended for life. Now I take everyday much more slowly since I'm virtually unable to do anything myself without my wife, whom cares for me 24/7.
Well, that went a bit off course...lol Nevermind, you got part of my bio! lol I'll come back.
Regards,
Les.
georgeGG SteV3
Posted
jessie51 SteV3
Posted
so sorry, you read about folks careers being cut short and when they are so knowledgable, as yourself we feel the world has lost a great deal.
I can only begin to imagine how frustrated you must get, am pleased you have a lovely wife to get you through the days.
Wish you all the best, and like George look forward to your next course - hey I am real good at wandering off the path myself lol.
Take care and be well
Jessie.
frustrated61 SteV3
Posted
First and foremost, I'm sorry to hear you're still struggling with your health and I hope the doctors can "figure" out your treatment to get you off of tramadol. Are you taking it for severe pain (if you don't mind me asking)? If so, have they tried any other kind of pain meds? Or if that's not the problem, I hope they can accomplish a good outcome soon.
Second,
You've brought up so many topics, I'm not sure which I should address first. I understand you and your wifes desire to set yourself aside from any religion, it's been done for many years and most likely will for so many more. I too, was brought up a certain religion and did go to church every day while young then when older, every week. Every day going to and from church and never once understanding what the heck was going on as the Priest spoke in latin. He could have been reciting the dictionary and I'd follow along and do what everyone else did. As I grew older, I had a strong desire to understand my religion and to this point, I'm still a student. I learn more each day not but the Bible but by how others treat others ect...I learn more by example. A visualist.
Regarding Purgatory, I'm in beliefs and this has nothing to do with any religion, but I believe we are in purgatory. On the religious belief, purgatory, a place or state of suffering inhabited by the souls of sinners who are expiating their sins before going to heaven. As describes were we are almost to the T. This is my opinion. I believe we are all "lost" souls trying to figure out how to live amongst, murderers, rapists, pedophile, child abusers, adult abusers etc...the worse among those who are seemingly innocent. It's a difficult task. Especially since the media seems to dwell on the most evil of humankind. Very rare that you hear about even one person of the unknown, who's gone over and above the call for the sake of others. Not going to sell if it's always good news. Sad, but true.
I'm assuming your wife knows what she is doing with that Ouji board and knows what doors she is possibly opening, right? I see that you and your children do not support this and I won't dwell on that issue as I'm sure you already know. I will keep you my my thoughts.
It is unfortunate that those who "find" religion or their "God" feel a need to shove it down everyones throats as they should know for years and centuries etc..this type of behaivor doesn't work with exception, those who are in need of something to fill an emptiness. My cousin did just that, he preached and preached. I told him that it doesn't take one to preach on a subject that they "only just learned about" to think they are in the right of way. They could be but they need time to search it out for themselves before preaching to others. One day I told him, listen, if you want anyone to respect what your beliefs are now, then walk the walk and stop talking the talk. People want to "see" a change, not be told about it. Am I right or way off base? I could be and I would be the first to step up and find out why.
I'm sorry for the loss of your nephew and your own child to be. I, too, have lived through a lot of sadness. I lost a child while 7mths pregnant, the thing is, I had to go through the entire process of delivering a child that wasn't even alive. I had a tubal pregnancy and lost a tube and ovary from this and was told I'd never have a chance of having children because "it's almost always "normal" once a tubal preg. another one could happen". I didn't see that word "normal" I only saw "could" which to me, meant I just may indeed be able to have children. After two more miscarriages, I finally had a child; I had one more miscarriage after the first birth and then our second child was born. Then my oldest daughter had the same kind of first pregnancy as I did and had to deliver while 7 months pregnant to a child that only lived 30 minutes. She was advised of this action as this child had a chromosome disorder and had left this child with half a stomach, half a brain and would never survive an entire 9 mths preg. and would die in that process (she had very qualified doctors and she herself was in the field as an ER nurse so she knew what was happening with her child; the tragdey went on with details. Her son live only 30 mins and that broke all of our hearts. Unfortunately, that kind of a loss defines a person it doesn't have to, but it did; their marriage did not continue on. Two of my sister in laws, one from my husbands side and one from my side committed suicide w/i weeks from one another, both of them had children they left w/o mothers. I could go on with more of our sadness but this will suffice. What I'm trying to say is, I don't hold my God, responsible for all that mess. It was obvious that each of my sister in laws made that decision to end their lives. The defect in the births, was just that, a defect. Did you know that most often than not, those who have a miscarriage in the first trimester also had that chromosome problem as it's not exclusive to my family. It's kind of natures way of taking care of the body. It's also sad, but true. I cannot hold my God responsible for this. My God wants everyone to be happy and to find peace. My God is kind and caring and loving. War, many wars are because of the "religion" and each beliefs in "their God". It's all complicated but I'm guessing it will continue on until the end of time.
The way I see it is, were are only promised the time we have now, tomorrow could mean the difference. As hard as it is, we have to try to live in harmony. Is that even possible?
Frustrated
georgeGG frustrated61
Posted
frustrated61 SteV3
Posted
Please do come back as I find you fascinating! You stated your "life" stopped after an accident, may I ask what kind of accident? Clearly your mind hasn't stopped working. I mean that in a good way, too.
Hope to hear more from you.
Frustrated
frustrated61 SteV3
Posted
Frustrated
I'm curious as how other's may explain their feelings on this.
SteV3 jessie51
Posted
Sorry about the interlude, but I cannot stay in one place for too long without being in pain, then my wife served up dinner. That’s why I finished so abruptly, I’ll carry on where I left off and side-tracked.
@Jessie – After the accident I did not know where to turn, since it took doctors and professors to diagnose what was wrong with me over a 2 year period. I self-taught myself in various programming languages, and started coding websites, it was far below anything I had tried in the past and my hand tremor just added to problems. So, I went looking at websites behind the scenes, so to speak and offered ways that they could make drastic improvements in there coding, I didn’t offer to do it though. That was a job I wanted to stay away from, because of what I was reading from numerous websites.
If I take you back now to my previous post and in particular this paragraph “At this rate, unless humans wipe themselves out by stupidity - living on other planets will come from fiction to fact.”
We already know in the US, 5 people are being sent to the red planet, taking 9 months to get there as well. Once there, they life in pods which are all prepared for them to live out their lives! Why on earth (no pun intended) would you want to go to another planet to live the rest of your life out! Well, there’s more to it than that – it’s called ‘Reality TV’, yes people can watch ours die on another planet – what is the point? Very simple, TV ratings, Social Media and everything else that is destroying lives right in front of us. So, 5 people dying on another planet is going to make no difference if they lived here, times are changing rapidly…. More importantly, we should be looking at our own children and thinking “What was I doing at their ages?” Probably, playing in parks, climbing in trees, catching butterflies, etc – Now take a look at your children and think what are they doing, unless you are very clever and lock down the internet from major websites, they will grow up thinking my life is all on my phone!!
Have you ever wondered if your child or teen have been uploading to websites? Look at today’s news for just one example, Snapchat has been involved in a hacking issue, but it is not them at fault, it is third-party apps which hackers embed in other apps. Then they post your child’s photos on Russian paedophilia websites. Children these days are not taught enough in my opinion about the internet, phones and tablets. One thing that is really annoying is many companies allow image uploads, but what about deleting… well, there’s another button for that – but the fact is, by pressing delete doesn’t actually delete the image at all – even though your image looks like it’s gone – believe me, it’s far from it. Ask anyone in software server security, or hard drive RAID setups, they will all say the same, only the reference is removed, the image can be called back at any time. Sorry, if I just bored you to death, but all the aforementioned is true. My wife and I are very cautious what websites she goes on, or apps and we restrict her completely from some. Facebook was recently comprised and numerous images were taken and posted on Russian paedophilia websites, and these images may look innocent of our children.
Let’s look at the world from your perspective… you probably have a TV, Mobile phone, tablet, radio and maybe a newspaper. Probably a few main world stories, but how do you know it’s the truth, you’re only taking what is front of you as gospel. Look at last week an advert appeared in newspapers stating that you could charge your mobile phone iPhone 6 easily in the microwave, as long as it was under 90 seconds! More than 600 iPhones exploded and microwaves damaged. Another reason not to believe in what you see or hear in the media!
My wife believes there’s a spiritual world, which you only see when you are not returning, once you leave this world then you would be in heaven. Yet she does not believe in the way people are born into the light of this world.
I, we’ll have a totally different way and look on life, considering I have nearly died 3 times and survived I must be something different…lol Consider the scientific factor, the amount of atoms in the universe never changes, as all humans have a body mass (not weight) of 99% of 6 elements namely oxygen, carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, phosphorus and calcium which equals just one atom (If you wondering what the 1% is, well that’s a very large number of small numbers ( this is actually a very small trace in mathematical terms )). Without going in to complex mathematics, when one person passes away, it is replaced by the same amount of body mass as a percentage elsewhere. How can a person go to heaven when there is no such place, which has been confirmed? And where would this appear in the atom table, and by the way the amount of atoms in the world is always the same as the number of living humans, if you take into consideration the 6 elements alone.
That is how I see it, okay its very complex because you also bring in protons, neutrons and electrons. If worked out it is fairly complex, but you would need to apply the formulae’s, which is based on atoms, not weight.
I know it sounds too complex to even look at let alone work out for each person, but in Applied Mathematics it gives the correct answer, but to reach that in the first place you would need the complete number of atoms in a split second.
Regards,
Les.
frustrated61 SteV3
Posted
SteV3 frustrated61
Posted
You could always look at it this way:
An example:
A man weighing 90 kg body would have approximately 9 x 10 to the power of 27 atoms.
That is, 9 followed by 27 zero's which is answer for one person.
BTW, this is the easy way which is called scientific notation, with a scientific calculator you might just work it out. To this day, I do not think anyone has ever worked that calculation.
Regards,
Les.
georgeGG SteV3
Posted
frustrated61 georgeGG
Posted
Frustrated
peter_a SteV3
Posted
georgeGG frustrated61
Posted
marey georgeGG
Posted
SteV3 peter_a
Posted
We do sound much alike in health respects, and yes I tend to go off subject not just on the internet, but IRL as well, I am always being asked "What are you referring to now?" - the thing is I know what I am referring to but the way I got to the point is where I have lost people.
I must reply to a question "frustrated" asked me a few messages back.
@frustrated,
I'll quote the actual paragraph and question. You asked me this:
"Please do come back as I find you fascinating! You stated your "life" stopped after an accident, may I ask what kind of accident? Clearly your mind hasn't stopped working. I mean that in a good way, too."?
The way I worded that perhaps gave the wrong impression to many people. I was referring to "Life" in the sense that I could no longer work, and my disorder just become worse overtime. I cannot blame anyone for the accident which may or may not of triggered my life to change so drastically at that point.
It was a hot day in July 1993, my mother asked me if I could 'pick' some cooking apples from our garden tree, to make a pie. I got the ladder out and wedged it between 2 branches and climbed up and started picking the apples. I heard a crack, which came from one of the branches, the ladder itself snapped causing the ladder to flip diagonally, so I let go as it twisted holding my weight, and jumped off. At this point I felt fine, like nothing had happened, put the ladder away and took the apples in for my mother.
The following day I woke up, but noticed I had a pain in my neck (the type of pain you get when you crick your neck). As the day went by the pain gradually became worse throughout, my father phoned my doctor whom come out quickly, but by this time my whole head was jerking to the left shoulder, causing severe pain. My doctor arrived, and the first thing he did was checked my arms to see if I had been injecting illegal drugs, because he had never encountered any person in his life with my issues (I even said to him that I have never touched illegal drugs), after doing further checks he phoned for an ambulance and I was admitted.
Well, my local hospital ran numerous checks and failed to find anything wrong, I was then transferred to a specialist hospital, again nothing came back with conclusive results. By this time, there was an American Neurologist Professor whom was well known at the time. They arranged to move me by ambulance to London which was about 130 miles away. Many tests were done by MRI scans (at this time these were expensive machines and only a few were in the UK), further tests were done. Yet, still nothing conclusive - for nearly 2 years I kept having to attend meetings with Professor David Marsden and his US Neurologist team. Just before the end of the 2 years I was diagnosed with Focal Segmental Dystonia, even my own Doctor had never heard of it, because back then I was only the 7th person to have this disorder in the UK.
I was placed on medication to control the disorder, but I was given the option of an operation that could reduce the effects, but the success rate was very low, and it was dangerous if anything went wrong.
Since I had been through so much already, and with the Dystonia which affects the nerve system, caused me to have seizures, Epilepsy and Functional Episodes - I would rather put up with the way I was, at least it could not get any worse, so I thought. But in 2008, I had cancer then 4 years later 2 more life threatening operations - and yet I still get people asking if I drink or smoke!! It makes me wonder sometimes....
As it stands now I'm classed under Generalized Dystonia, Epilepsy, Functional Episodes and taking well over 140 tablets a week plus BOTOX injections every 10 weeks!! Now, waiting to see if the Pain Clinic can do anything, I give anything a try to get off Tramadol.
=================================================
Okay, getting back on track...
Considering I only believe in facts - in other words I must see something in front of me, not on TV, or any media (this can all be trickery from my perspective!), or anyone else.
It is like comparing fact or fiction, something could be both. That is what most people would assume.. but there is a third state, the cover-up or the conspiracy theory, but for this to work the conspiracy must be planned in advance. Now, look at purgatory again and where would it be? Then again the first Moon Landing has been questioned many times, again was this a conpiracy?
In a scientific state there is no space for Heaven or Hell, so where does Purgatory come from. The number of atoms never change in the universe, so where can Heaven, Purgatory and Hell actually reside? Years ago when science fact was not so well known, yes people may of believed in such places. As man developed and started applying science and mathematics, people started to see from a new perspective, and one that could be shown, thus fact.
If you start comparing religions, then you get mixed views, variations on the Bible, as of yet none of which can be proved as correct.
Purgatory from a scientific point of view, really cannot exist, it dates back only in certain religions and not others. In science an atom is 1 or nothing, the same as body mass and percentages (not weight). An example, say you placed an ice cube in a jar and sealed it totally, the atoms inside the jar do not change in body mass, the structure changes.
Much you read about is in the media, but this is always filtered and many more people these days are questioning certain news reports.
Unless I can literally see something in front of me, I do not believe in theories, only facts which can be seen. And before anyone asks, yes I have seen several planets when I was into astronomy and the sun using a special lens filter.
When I was young all we had was libraries, these days anyone can access virtually anything for referencing at schools. We only had a video player reel-to-reel....yeh, those were the days!
Regards,
Les,
peter_a SteV3
Posted
marey peter_a
Posted
peter_a marey
Posted
marey peter_a
Posted
I have often wanted to speak to a slaughterman to ask if the animals are dispatched with compassion. Do you feel that that is the case?
marey peter_a
Posted
WEll literally. Did you attend court?
I'm glad you did receive due compensation but gosh aren't these things complicated. I am sorry for Mr T but he would have understood. Was he not insured however?
Anyway Peter its as if you are a manifestation. I used to be vegetarian....specifically because I could not go through with visiting a slaughter house. I did turn up and made the attempt to enter....but just could not go through with it. I do not feel its right to let others do such difficult things...but now for health reasons I'm eating meat again. So if you don't mind I 'd really like to ask your more about your experience. Where you a slaughterman yourself? Or were you there as a technician or for some other reason. I would really like to know that staff do their best for the animals and dispatch them with compassion. Is this off topic anyone?
peter_a marey
Posted
frustrated61 peter_a
Posted
That had to have been a "rock and a hard place" for you to be in. However, your life was changed in ways that no one should have had to endure. I'm thinking that part of the payment was made through his insurance but that really isn't debate. Your situation caused you so much more than losing a business. That, true, was an unfortunate issue that you had to also deal with through your guilt but really, someone wasn't doing their job correctly and because of that, you suffer. I'm so sorry about all that has happened to you.
Again, I'm sorry for your struggles.
Frustrated
peter_a marey
Posted
marey peter_a
Posted
had to hide behind my hand ...before cautiously reading about the sheep....so difficult ...for you. but did they forgive you?
i am glad there was improvement to the premises...and well ok the boss didn't hold a grudge but neither did you.
i think you were both very stoical.
impressive that the boss kept to those scrupples...kosher remains contentious and for what benefit is that method used?
was this your purgatory or your transistion?
peter_a frustrated61
Posted
peter_a marey
Posted
marey peter_a
Posted
as a nurse i completely understand the post epilepsy issues...and hey were you prepared and efficient. I have never known such a positively brilliant attitude....wow again!
frustrated61 peter_a
Posted
Frustrated
marey peter_a
Posted
What did you go on to do after your degree?
peter_a marey
Posted
peter_a frustrated61
Posted
peter_a
Posted
frustrated61 peter_a
Posted
Yes, it seems to be of interest to many! I was hoping I could get good insight with everyone else's input and seems like that is happening! WOW, 220, you get the winning prize! lol
Anyway, you've included your well informed posts into this discussion and for that, I'm very grateful for. I've started a few other new discussions but none have taken off like this one.
Thank you for being a part of this subject as I hits close to my heart.
Warmly,
Frustrated
frustrated61 peter_a
Posted
Indeed you do have more to offer. You're a very intelligent, wise person that loves to write and it shows, you are of excellence!
Thank you for your posts!
Frustrated
peter_a frustrated61
Posted
Peter :D
marey peter_a
Posted
i so admire all that you have done.
anymore nonsense from the home get onto the regulators and advise that your activities are being restricted....the care council....but i think their name has been changed. ask for some support with activity organisation.
don't overdo your efforts peter but know that you are appreciated. enjoy rest and quiet times too...but you are the one for a bit of fun...good for you!
peter_a marey
Posted
frustrated61 peter_a
Posted
I'm so happy that you were able to do that, what a feat that is! And yes, to accomplish something like that does humble one. You are awesome!
Frustrated