Red Wine

Posted , 14 users are following.

after a couple of glasses of red wine my pmr worsens. anyone else experiencing this?

0 likes, 69 replies

69 Replies

Prev Next
  • Posted

    I had a glass of red wine at a Christmas music entertainment which also included cheese, andother good things to eat.  I was quite choosy, and even foraged for some water after my wine was gone.  No good.  had a headache overnight ant=d into the next day. sad

     

    • Posted

      and I need to proofread. 

       

    • Posted

      Oh, it was not a good experience!

      Was this one the first time you had a headache after a glass of wine?

      I am interested because now and then as I said yesterday to someone here I have one glasse or half a glasse of Pinot Grigio - the white one with my broiled salmon.

      Never had any headache.

      I have GCA and in daily basis follow a sensible diet.

      Now I go for my cup of green tea.

      xxxx

    • Posted

      Hi iellen32.  No, I've developed a headache every single time I have had beer, wine or sherry since I started pred in June.  MInd you, I think I tend to get headaches from alcohol anyway, but not evey time and certainly not as severely.  On the plus side I have been getting far fewer headaches generally.  Except last night just before I went to bed I suddenly felt as though my left eye had exploded.  I got up around 5 and took some aspirins.  Later I took tylenol, but have felt headachy all day.  This one I blame on the weather, but I've felt so tired, it was a wasted day.
  • Posted

    One problem that alcohol poses is that it reduces the liver's capacity to regulate carb's entering the bloodstream from the gut, so in effect it is as though the alcohol were a dietary carbohydrate, in terms of it's net effect on blood sugar control and thus, inflammation.

    As well, alcohol makes regulating one's food intake more difficult, in part because it makes it harder to remember and keep track of what is being eaten and drank over a period of time, so poor dietary choices tend to result and may be forgotten.

    There are some for whom having a drink might get them on the dance floor or outside chopping a pile of wood, but when this doesn't happen, one's dietary control may simply become insufficient to maintain a healthy balance of diet and exercise in the short term, so a headache with heightened pmr symptoms might be the result the next morning.

    In this way, alcohol works counter to the inprovement in blood sugar regulation that one sees: A) during a period of weight loss, B) during/after a period of exercise, or C) during a period of maintaining one's personal healthy (i.e. low enough) weight, where regulation by means of storage capacity of the liver cells, muscle cells and fat cells is at it's best. Weight loss doesn't change one's number of liver or fat cells (why lipo method by removing fat cells isn't healthy), so weight loss leaves one's liver and fat cells in a better state to respond to the smallest insulin signals, thus keeping insulin and blood sugar from approaching systemic inflammatory levels!

    Suffice to say that the ability to metabolize alcohol is tied in with one's capacity to uptake (regulate) carbohydrate. This, in turn, strongly affects the body's inflamatory response and the level of hunger or food cravings (for more carbohydrate) that one experiences. Thus, extended periods of exercise are thus a good counter to the effects of eating and drinking too much.

    • Posted

      Are you talking about light and occasional alcohol intake as well?
    • Posted

      These issues with the body regulating/metabolizing carbohydrate and alcohol, and with symptoms response, are all just quantitative variables that may or may not allow one to indulge one way or the other without negative consequences.

      I do a bit of drinking myself, but try to keep it in line with the "credits" I have earned in terms of my ability/capacity to indulge without regret.

      My point was to explain how it is the combined capacity of liver, muscle and fat cells to properly assimilate the combined load of carbohydrate and alcohol which needs to be managed to some degree such that we avoid pmr flare-ups while also avoiding the conditions that tend to lead to metabolic syndrome, i.e. the oft-associated ailments of pre-diabetes, heart disease and arthritis.

      Exercise (accelerated fasting) gives the body a boost in it's capacity to handle the kinds of food and drink that we enjoy without causing symptoms of over-indulgence.

  • Posted

    The dance floor for me every time, even if all I can do is stand there and sway.
  • Posted

    I love red wine, and probably drank too much (almost certainly) and would drink every day if I could get away with it (Mr Flip puts his foot down, not my health!) i can't drink at all now I'm on methotrexate but it was the only thing that made me feel 'normal'.  I'd stop thinking and worrying about being sick and tired all the time and just relax and be 'me' (according to Mr Flip this was not actually the case!).  

    Who knows, it may well be responsible for my recent major flare, and consequent depression

  • Posted

    Hello nervebyte, reading the long discussion on red wine, I asked to myself- what else could I add?!

    Having my GCA and sure, on Pred , I take one, or 1/2 a glass of Pinot Grigio , now and then with a salmon dinner, I prepare.

    I do not feel any bad though, however it takes another month or more for me to do the same again.

    As far as know based on patient' s testimonies and having had my experience taking care of my husband who had Parkinson's ,whatever the illness may be, medicines don't agree with alcohol when taken in regular basis.

    We know our limits though - our system let us know for sure in a very clear way ....

    Cheers! Merry Christmas!

  • Posted

    Wow, lots of discussion here! Nice to read.

    i just want to add...because I don't want anyone else to have my problem...

    I drank red wine probably too much first 6 months of pmr. Trying to feel good, and I did.

    But now have very bad acid reflux and lost my taste buds for a while, I did have a couple of glasses this weekend, and now regret it again. 

    So sad, I live in Texas wine country!!! 

    Was as wine the culprit? I don't know, but it doesn't taste as good as I remember now.  sad 

    • Posted

      It sounds like the alcohol is just enough to put your body's regulation over the edge.

      The liver cells act as a sort of nervous system in control of digestion and hunger, and can for example send chemical signals through the bloodstream which act on the digestive system to slow the absorption of nutrients that you have already eaten.

      Receptiveness to the taste of food and drink, along with a slowing of the digestive system are the first sort of response to signals the lever sends out that it is at capacity. The slowing of digestion manifests as reflux.

      It is the combined effects of alcohol and nutrients that the liver responds to, the total "caloric load" if you will, that challenges the liver's uptake/storage capacity.

      Fat cells help balance the liver's functioning by responding to the insulin signal from the pancreas.  The fat cells absorb converted carbohydrate and so reduce the liver's need to absorb as much, which spares some of the liver's capacity to regulate the entry of nutrients and alcohol into the bloodstream.

      One's fat cell count does not change after the teenage years, but the responsiveness of fat cells to insulin changes with one's body weight.

      Thinks like alcohol or the seasonal reduction of physical activity thus both act to reduce the body's capacity to consume nutrients, so symptoms of acid reflux, inflammatory responses and even the lack of a taste for good wine can thus be more common around this time of year.

      In addition, when fat cells become more saturated and thus less responsive to insulin, and/or when one's muscle mass is reduced (thus also less able to absorb carbohydrate in response to insulin), a continuously-elevated level of insulin results that is associated with cyclic blood sugar swings and loss of energy. In this way it can make for a sort of chain-reaction scenario, where carbohydrate cravings  and a loss of energy for exercise are both acting to further challenge the natural regulation of blood chemistry. At the limit, certain individuals will be at risk for diabetes, which so often goes hand in hand with cardiovascular disease.

      It should be obvious then that any intake of alcohol may need to be balanced against reduced macro-nutrient intake and/or increased levels of exercise, so as not to disturb the body's critical system of regulation.

      It should also explain why wine tends to taste better before a meal than after. I've stopped at wineries during hours-long bike rides, and I can tell you that the wine never tasted better, with even the dry wines tasting almost sweet!

    • Posted

      Dan, thirst helps.  I learned to like beer one evening after a long dehydrating day!
    • Posted

      My goodness Dan, thanks for info.  I'm not sure I understood it all, but have always had bad Reactive Hypoglycemia, so much I can't eat fruit not sugar without consequences, yet wine and straight alcohol never affected my blood sugar.  Now with PMR and all these drugs I can't tell sometimes if it's hypoglycemia or just fatigue.  I'll eat sugar stuff or fruit hoping to gain more energy!!! but it never works! 

      I've lost 22 lbs. only weighing 117 now.  I crave fat! And salt now.  So I'm wondering about what you said about the fat cells. The Pred has really atrophied my muscles and perhaps fat.

      I worry some about diabeties, since my pancreas has worked overdrive most of my life.  Funny how stopping the gluten and grain carbs I am doing better with blood sugars.  

      But I also read lately blood sugar can relate to low thyroid /Hashimoto's as well.

      thanks for your interesting post.

    • Posted

      You seem to be quite knowledgeable regarding the physiology of what you are describing. Are you working in the field of medicine?

       

    • Posted

      I'm the same way with sugar.  If I have two margueritas with my taco dinner, I leave the place feeling hungrier than when I arrived!

      Drinking a rich Starbucks blended drink does the very same thing, so it's not the alcohol that makes my blood sugar plummet.

      The alcohol will perhaps exacerbate one's intolerance of sugar however, as it limits the liver's effectiveness at mopping up a load of sugar, so the pancreas then has to produce more insulin to control the inrush of sugar.

      The insulin stays araound for a lot longer than it is needed to control the sugar, this because the system isn't calibrated to handle such high-glycemic foods as modern humans ingest.

      As I understand it, about a quarter of the population can tolerate high-glycemic foods, while another quarter of the population is quite intolerant of high-glycemic foods.  The other half are in the middle, tolerating high-glycemic foods in moderation.

      There are times when my daily exercise has been going to plan when my glycemic response seems normal, suggesting to me that this is when my liver's and muscles capacity is at it's best, haviing been largely emptied of excess carb uptake due to the hours of daily bike riding.

      BTW, the liver and muscles store carbohydrate in the form of glycogen, which is an oxygen-boosted carbohydrate molecule which can allow the muscles to deliver higher power output without taxing one's limited respiratory capacity, as when fleeing a tiger or perhaps hunting wild game. So this could benefit survival, and so has become part of our metabolic system's ways, whether or not our present lifestyles benefit or are perhaps hindered by it.

      Since you have lost weight, your fat cells are probably working more efficiently in response to smaller infusions of insulin from your pancreas, but if muscles are atrophied then this muscular form of regulation capacity will have been reduced. So be sure to exercise any and all muscles that will tolerate exercise, and adjust the routine as needed. An adequate dose of pred that allows one to get their exercise routine up and running should allow one to taper as quickly as the pmr will allow.

    • Posted

      So hard to exercise. I love mornings, that's when I used to be able to exercise, now with PMR I really fear it due to pains and fear harming the tendons inflammed and I'm SO tired now. So frustrating. I have to take thyroid meds before breakfast so I can't get my Prednisone in until later and it doesn't take affect until probably noon.  Bummer. 

      But today I painted a fence! Hope I didn't over due it!

      take care. Happy cycling! I hope someday to do that again!!! 

    • Posted

      Google this Layne

      Effects of Evening vs Morning Levothyroxine Intake A Randomized Double-blind Crossover Trial

      They actually conclude "Levothyroxine taken at bedtime significantly improved thyroid hormone levels. Quality-of-life variables and plasma lipid levels showed no significant changes with bedtime vs morning intake. Clinicians should consider prescribing levothyroxine intake at bedtime."

      There is also a thread on this site discussing the concept of taking thyroid meds at night:

      https://patient.info/forums/discuss/taking-levothyroxine-at-night-improved-my-life--226315

    • Posted

      No, I'm not working in any medicne-related field right now, though I do have a pretty good understanding of biochemical-related topics from having worked in a hospital blood lab and having worked in mainly process development (as an engineer) within the pharma industry.

      I've had an interest in diet and exercise for a quite long time and have done a lot of reading on these subjects.

Report or request deletion

Thanks for your help!

We want the community to be a useful resource for our users but it is important to remember that the community are not moderated or reviewed by doctors and so you should not rely on opinions or advice given by other users in respect of any healthcare matters. Always speak to your doctor before acting and in cases of emergency seek appropriate medical assistance immediately. Use of the community is subject to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and steps will be taken to remove posts identified as being in breach of those terms.