
The arousal paradox
All about desire. Why do some things turn us off when they should turn us on?
Authored by Thomas Andrew Porteus, MBCSOriginally published 8 Dec 2025
Meets Patient’s editorial guidelines
- DownloadDownload
- Share
- Language
- Discussion
- Ask Patient
- Audio Version
- Add to preferred sources on Google
In this series:Coming, ready or notLust or bustVictims and villainsMe-topia The Big O... Oh No!What is sex anyway?A dangerous liaison?Losing it!
When Porn or Hollywood are your sex educators, it can get confusing when things don’t work that way for us!
Why is it that the things that are supposed to turn us on, sometimes turn us off? How come we can be so different from our partners?
Clare and Janet mine the myriad of contradictions in partnered sex.
This podcast contains explicit language and content of a sexual nature.
In this episode, Clare and Janet unpack what they jokingly call the arousal paradox - the confusing, frustrating and very common mismatch between what we think should turn us on and what actually does.
They explore why so many of us measure our arousal against unrealistic Hollywood scripts or porn narratives, and how this creates anxiety when real-life desire doesn’t follow the same plot. From mismatched libidos to the myth of “the normal one”, they reveal why partners can feel out of sync and how that misunderstanding can spiral into shame, self-blame or conflict.
Drawing on clinical experience, they dig into the “story behind the plot” - the biological, psychological and relational factors that shape arousal. Clare and Janet explain spontaneous vs responsive desire, the impact of stress, medication and menopause, and why conditions like environment, timing, mood and communication matter far more than we’re taught to believe.
They also introduce concepts from sex science, including accelerators and brakes, and share everyday examples of exciters and “icks” that influence how desire rises and falls. Above all, they highlight a reassuring truth: most couples aren’t mismatched — just different. And understanding those differences is the starting point for better sex, less pressure and more connection.
Patient picks for The Sex and Relationships Podcast

Healthy living
LGBTQ+ people share their personal conversion therapy stories
It's still legal for LGBTQ+ people in the UK to be subjected to conversion therapy, a harmful practice, which aims to suppress or 'cure' people's sexual orientation and/or gender identity. While many of us may be aware of the existence of conversion therapy, much of it happens underground. Therefore, we might not fully understand how it truly affects LGBTQ+ people in the long term.
by Emily Jane Bashforth

Heart health and blood vessels
What happens to your blood pressure when you're not measuring it?
Think about the last time you had your blood pressure checked. Perhaps you were sitting in your GP's surgery, waiting for the cuff to inflate. Seconds later, two numbers appeared on the screen. Those numbers provide useful information about your blood pressure at that moment. But blood pressure changes throughout the day and night. Some people even have higher readings at the GP's surgery than at home - known as white coat hypertension - while others have normal readings in the surgery but higher blood pressure elsewhere (masked hypertension).
by Hilo

Treatment and medication
What is psychodynamic therapy?
If you're thinking of trying therapy, the number of different types can seem overwhelming. Although therapy is a catch-all term, approaches and styles can differ considerably - and the kind you may benefit from can depend on lots of factors. This series will look at the various options, so you can find the therapy suitable for you.
by Lydia Smith

Treatment and medication
What is dialectical behavioural therapy (DBT)?
Adults with diagnoses characterised by emotional dysregulation (such as borderline personality disorder) run a much higher risk of self-harm and death from suicide. For people with these diagnoses, evidence-based therapies like DBT can be life-saving.
by Ellie Broughton

Podcasts
What is sex anyway?
Sex is everywhere, right? Clare and Janet kick off the season by discussing the fundamentals about sex… why do we do it and what is it for?!
by Thomas Andrew Porteus, MBCS

Treatment and medication
Don't sweat it: 5 sauna health benefits in the hot seat
Sauna bathing is a time-honoured trend that dates back to 2000 BC. Its spiritual, mental, and physical benefits have passed anecdotally through generations - and now, science is beginning to back them up. We turn the heat up on 5 sauna health benefits, and what you need to know.
by Amberley Davis
Share your thoughts or experiences with others in our patient communities.
Sign up to the Patient newsletter
Your weekly dose of clear, trustworthy health advice - written to help you feel informed, confident and in control.
By subscribing you accept our Privacy Policy. You can unsubscribe at any time. We never sell your data.
