Skip to main content
Pear Shape CVD

Being 'pear-shaped' may lower risk of heart disease in women

A new study of postmenopausal women has shown that women who are 'apple-shaped' rather than 'pear-shaped' are at greater risk of heart and blood vessel problems.

The study, published in the European Heart Journal, found that even in women with a healthy body mass index (BMI), carrying a greater proportion of body fat in the legs (pear-shaped) rather than around the middle (apple-shaped) significantly reduces the risk of heart disease.

The researchers studied 2,683 women over 18 years, all of whom had a normal BMI and had already been through the menopause.

The team found that the greatest risk of cardiovascular disease occurred in women who had the highest percentage of fat around their middle and the lowest percentage of leg fat. Women who stored fat around their middle were three times more likely to suffer from heart disease than women with the opposite body type.

However, the researchers stress that the study does not definitively show that the location of body fat causes an increased risk of cardiovascular problems, only that there is an association.

It is not yet understood why leg fat may be protective, but it is thought that it is because it is not causing problems elsewhere in the body. Fat stored around the abdomen, particularly the organs, is already known to increase the risk of conditions like type 2 diabetes and cardiovascular disease.

Lead researcher Dr Qibin Qi, from the Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York, hopes that the findings could be used to encourage people to understand regional body fat, as well as BMI and body weight, particularly in practice. At the moment, measures of BMI and waist circumference are taken to predict heart disease risk but the study suggests that practitioners should also be looking at the location of stored body fat.

However, it's not known if the findings apply to different groups of people. "It is important to note that participants of our study were postmenopausal women who had relatively higher fat mass in both their trunk and leg regions. Whether the pattern of the associations could be generalisable to younger women and to men who had relatively lower regional body fat remains unknown," he explained.

Qi highlights that, although there is no known way of relocating body fat through exercise or diet, reducing stomach fat is the best way to reduce heart disease risk, according to the study.

In a comment for the BBC, Dr Sonya Babu-Narayan, associate medical director at the British Heart Foundation said: "This study uncovers an interesting link between where fat is stored and your risk of heart attack and stroke, but can't tell us why it exists. Future research to uncover how the distribution of body fat is related to these diseases could reveal important new ways to prevent and treat the world's biggest killer."

This study was published in the European Heart Journal.

Article history

The information on this page is peer reviewed by qualified clinicians.

symptom checker

Feeling unwell?

Assess your symptoms online for free