Can fitness trackers help boost activity levels in adults?

What does a fitness tracker do?

Fitness trackers and activity trackers use sensors to track orientation, movement and rotation. The devices collect data and convert it into a variety of measures depending on the tracker. Different devices may give information on steps, other exercises, standing time, calories, sleep quality and the general activity a user performs throughout the day.

Various companies, including Apple, Samsung and Fitbit, now sell fitness trackers. They have become increasingly popular and are now available in multiple customisable designs and colour schemes. They can be bought for as little as £20, or more expensive ones can set you back hundreds of pounds.

In a nutshell, fitness trackers give you an insight into your day-to-day activity levels. Basic designs might only track your number of steps per day, while more advanced devices support other exercises and sports, such as running, cycling or swimming. Some even have heart rate monitors and offer smart notifications, such as text messages or emails. Some devices also have built-in GPS for when you're out walking or jogging.

Pros and cons of fitness trackers

Pros

• Allow you to set personal goals.

• Monitor your progress.

• Act as a source of motivation.

• Hold you accountable.

• Some trackers:

  • Encourage healthy eating and a balanced diet.

  • Monitor heart rate.

  • Track sleep.

Cons

• Can cause fixation.

• Can lead to obsessive calorie counting or exercise monitoring.

• Accuracy can be questionable.

• Can be expensive.

Do we need encouragement to exercise more?

From November 2019-November 2020, 27.1% of adults were considered to be inactive, doing less than 30 minutes of exercise on average per week. Men (70%) were more likely to be active than women (65%).

In the UK Chief Medical Officers' guidelines, it is recommended that adults (age 19 and over) do at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity activity or 75 minutes of vigorous-intensity activity per week, or a combination of both. Adults should also aim to build strength on at least two days a week. The high proportion of the population doing less than a fifth of this amount of excerise suggests that many of us need encouragement to exercise more, which fitness trackers could help with.

Personal circumstances

Everyone's circumstances are different. Therefore, regular physical exercise can be difficult to incorporate into your daily routine. However, regular exercise offers a multitude of benefits, especially in terms of disease prevention. The National Centre for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health Promotion says regular physical activity will improve your health, as well as your fitness and quality of life. It also helps reduce your risk of:

• Type 2 diabetes.

• Heart disease.

• Many types of cancer.

• Depression.

• Anxiety.

• Dementia.

Do fitness trackers increase physical activity?

A recent study has found that physical activity monitors and fitness trackers can indeed boost levels of physical activity in adults.

Modern fitness trackers have the potential to change people's behaviour, but studies looking at their effectiveness have often reached different conclusions.

To address this uncertainty, researchers in Denmark searched databases for trials comparing activity levels in adults who received feedback from wearing a fitness tracker with control interventions in which no feedback was provided.

Patient picks for Exercise and physical activity

How to run a 10k with no experience

They found 121 randomised controlled trials involving 16,743 mainly healthy 18 to 65-year-olds. The average age of study participants was 47 years, with a higher proportion of women than men.

Overall, the interventions showed:

• A moderate effect on physical activity (equivalent to 1,235 daily steps).

• A small effect on moderate to vigorous physical activity (equivalent to 48.5 weekly minutes).

• A small but insignificant effect on sedentary time (equal to 9.9 daily minutes).

For all outcomes, fitness trackers that provided feedback were more effective than those that did not.

Limitations

The researchers acknowledge that the trials included in this study varied in design and methods. This may mean the results can't be compared directly with each other, so the conclusions reached by lumping them together may not be as reliable. In addition, they may not be relevant for all populations - results may not be applicable to lower-income countries, for example. Nevertheless, this is the first review of collated evidence across different patient populations and different types of physical activity monitors and fitness trackers.

Researchers are calling for further studies to investigate how fitness trackers can be used in combination with other behavioural change strategies, or how they might affect sedentary (resting or inactive) time.

Are fitness trackers safe for everyone?

While fitness trackers can be a way for people to monitor their activity levels and achieve goals, they may not be suitable for everyone.

If you are struggling with or trying to recover from, exercise addiction or an eating disorder, it is not recommended that you use a fitness tracker.

Martha Williams, a clinical advice coordinator at charity eating disorder charity Beat, explains.

"Fitness trackers can encourage a fixation on exercise and numbers, which can be very harmful to people with, or vulnerable to, eating disorders. For instance, trackers may have the option to measure distance travelled, time active, and the number of calories burned. This can motivate people with an eating disorder to continue harmful behaviours and become more unwell.

"At Beat, we would never recommend that somebody in recovery from an eating disorder uses a fitness tracker. We know from the people we support that calorie counting or consistently tracking exercise can create a feeling of control around their diet and delay their recovery from an eating disorder. However, every person's experience of recovery is different, and what is unhelpful for one person may be helpful for another."

If you're worried about your own or someone else's health, you can contact Beat, the UK's eating disorder charity, 365 days a year on 0808 801 0677 or beateatingdisorders.org.uk.