Best foods for a happy gut - and why you need them now
Noom and mindful eating: Can food psychology-based apps help you make healthier decisions?
Since it was created in 2008, the health coaching app Noom has become increasingly popular with people trying to improve their eating habits. Unlike traditional calorie-counting diet plans, Noom emphasises the use of psychology-based techniques to help users understand their behaviour when it comes to food. But is the programme based on pseudoscience, or can psychology really help people make healthier decisions?
Can food psychology help you eat better?
The way we feel and think and our eating habits are closely connected. When we feel sad or low, many of us reach for comfort foods to boost our mood. When we are anxious or upset, we may not feel like eating at all. Often, we create emotional connections to certain foods, such as meals we ate in childhood. Our emotional state can also lead to emotional eating and unhealthy eating habits, such as eating too much or too little.
Research shows stressful situations can lead people to make substantial changes to their eating habits, such as binge eating. We may even overeat to boost temporary feelings of joy or to activate our brain's reward system.
With our emotions clearly linked to the way we eat, psychology may also help us make behavioural changes and create a more positive relationship with food.
"At its heart, psychology can help people to make better food choices and find a level of control over eating behaviours," says Lee Chambers, a psychologist and well-being consultant. "It can also help us become more aware of the feelings generated from the foods we consume. An increased self-awareness of our triggers and eating behaviours can provide the ability to choose empowered responses."
Why are apps like Noom gaining popularity?
Traditionally, the diet industry has focused on foods themselves - often labelling items as 'good' or 'bad'. This is often an unhelpful approach as it means we place moral labels on food, leading to guilt and shame when we inevitably reach for a biscuit or some chocolate. It can affect our mood and subsequently what we eat next.
"With a diet industry that has turned certain foods into either good or bad, often individuals struggle to embed their nutrition as an interconnected element of living," explains Chambers. "By understanding our motivations, strategies that work for us and how we can create positive coping methods for our challenges, we are more likely to be able to embed healthier choices with a concrete appreciation of why we are and the value of doing so."
Psychology-based health programmes tend to avoid this binary approach to food. There is also a greater focus on why and when we choose certain foods and how we feel when we are eating. The aim is to create more awareness around our eating habits, so we can make mindful, healthier decisions. For example, if we are more likely to eat unhealthy foods when we're sad, happy or bored.
Focus on eating behaviour and food psychology
"Apps like Noom are gaining popularity for a number of reasons. While society's obsession with appearance and well-being continues unabated, there has been an increasing rebellion against the traditional dieting services that focus on food types, points systems and strict plans," says Chambers.
"There is a feeling that they address the surface issues, but do nothing for the underlying behaviours, meaning they are likely to not be effective in the long term. There is also an increased desire for hyper-personalised services, rather than a standard meal plan."
Apps also give us an element of accountability and control. "There is also a level of education behind the psychology of eating that these apps feed you, and the feeling of support being only an app click away," adds Chambers.
The overall aim of Noom is to create a calorie deficit to aid weight loss: food is categorised into green, yellow and red, based on their calorie density and concentration of nutrients. Foods with the lowest calorie density, highest concentration of nutrients, or both, are considered green. No food is off-limits, but higher calorie ones with fewer nutrients are 'red'.
Rather than aiding temporary weight loss, these apps aim to help create healthier long-term habits.
What are the downsides of apps like Noom?
Like many apps, there are downsides and groups of people who will find them ineffective or even potentially dangerous. Apps are impersonal and don't suit everyone's needs. "For those with underlying medical conditions that impact weight loss, the app can easily cause frustration and even feelings of helplessness," says Chambers.
Additionally, any diet, weight-loss app or programme can contribute to disordered eating or exacerbate existing eating disorders, making recovery more difficult. Users may think food psychology-based apps are safer or more holistic than traditional calorie-counting diets, but they can still be harmful.
"And there is the reality that it's an application that keeps you on technology, and doesn't go shopping, do the cooking, or complete the exercise that it suggests," says Chambers. "Sometimes it can be a barrier to changing environments and the external factors that influence the interconnected aspects of weight loss. It can narrow the focus to weight loss, when that is just one aspect of overall well-being."
Healthy living support
While apps can be a helpful tool to help us think more about what they are eating and why, it's important to remember that there are limitations to these programmes. Apps such as Noom won't work for everyone, but there are plenty of other ways to make lifestyle changes too.
If you're concerned about your health or eating habits, your doctor will be able to offer advice - especially if you have an underlying medical condition. It's important to contact your GP or practice nurse before making any significant dietary changes.
Dietitians can also offer personalised, professional support and advice. Some people can access dietitian input on the NHS, but sadly services are often limited to those with certain medical conditions or over/under a given body mass index (BMI). It's also important to speak to friends and family who can help you along the way, too.
Sometimes, in-person groups can provide helpful support to people trying to make positive changes in their lives. You can find these groups on social media or in local community centres - and they're a good way to meet others too.