Do you need more sleep in winter?
We've all done stupid things on New Year's Eve. But could arguing with a friend that I only needed five hours of sleep a night - and that I could prove it - be the dumbest of all?
As someone who'd never really been the best of pals with sleep, changing my habits had been something I'd been mulling over for a while. Even after the heaviest of nights out as a teenager, I'd be up with the larks while my peers dozed until gone noon. And as I grew up, life took its toll and a mobile phone became inseparable from my hand, so that getting to sleep became a lengthy process too.
Why can't we just sleep?
Wouldn't it be frustrating if every time you plugged in your phone, it took 10 minutes before it started to recharge itself? The art of getting to sleep is one that some people struggle with greatly, and it's a self-perpetuating problem as the more you worry about it, the less likely you are to be able to achieve slumber.
The average person spends around 33 years of their life in bed. 26 of those years are spent sleeping. That statistic is surprising enough, but when you factor in a further seven years of tossing, turning and trying to get to sleep, that's when it really hits home just what a dent it can be on your days on Earth.Up all night
“Around a third of the population have trouble sleeping, including difficulties maintaining sleep throughout the night.”— theconversation.com, Did we used to have two sleeps rather than one?
Is it best to sleep at night?
The vast majority of people operate on a monophasic sleep cycle. Mono means one, so you go to bed at night, wake up in the morning and your sleep for the day is considered complete.
However, some major countries operate a biphasic sleep cycle (bi = two) where sleep is split into separate chunks.
- In China, it's a constitutional right for workers to take a break for an hour-long nap after lunch.
- In Italy, the riposo is a common practice, with many businesses and public buildings closing for a couple of hours in the early afternoon.
- In Spain, the siesta is widely adopted and often accommodates eating and socialising as well as napping.
There's a lot of historical evidence that suggests this used to be the norm around the rest of the world too in the pre-industrial age. References to a 'first and second sleep' have occurred in many forms of literature, with people getting up in the middle of the night to sew, chop wood, read or have sex. The 'waking period' was considered a very fertile time to conceive.Lost in history
References to the first and second sleep started to disappear during the late 17th Century. By the 1920s the idea of a first and second sleep had receded entirely from our social consciousness.— bbc.co.uk, The myth of the eight-hour sleep
Be in control of your body clock
A complete sleep cycle lasts approximately 90 minutes Here you'll go from the lightest stage through the deepest stage of sleep and back again.
If you sleep for 7.5 hours, you'll have gone through five cycles, each with its own characteristics in terms of depth and dreaming. So if you only really get a decent sleep during the first two cycles, are the subsequent 270 minutes a waste of time?
Further research into this area led me to the practice of polyphasic sleep (poly = many) which is becoming a popular option for many, with a vibrant online community.Segmented sleep
Polyphasic scheduling is an experimental art and science designed to increase quality wake time without sacrificing wellbeing. The essential strategy is increasing the frequency of sleep.— polyphasic.net, Popular sleep schedules
This struck a chord with me. I don't work an average 9-5, I can be productive at any hour of the day, and I'm starting a new business venture (deskvillage.com if you're interested) so could do with a few extra hours in the day.
As well as biphasic sleep, there are various alternative sleep schedules to select from:
- Everyman - one core sleep accompanied by up to three top-up naps.
- Dual-core - similar to biphasic sleep, but two periods of core sleep sometimes with an additional nap.
- Tri-core - three sleeps of roughly equal duration.
- Dymaxion/Uberman/Tesla - extreme methods of four to six 20- to 30-minute naps throughout the day.
The 'everyman' option seemed the most suited to me, offering both flexibility and a longish core sleep so the transition wasn't too jarring.
So since 2019 rolled around, I've enjoyed an average of 4h 56m of sleep, broken down into a 4h 05m core sleep and a couple of naps averaging 26 minutes each. Here's how that has developed over the course of the month so far:
The practicalities have taken a bit of getting used to. I've tried sleep tracking apps with inbuilt alarms, automated screen downtime, and even an attempted (an ultimately fruitless) nap-lap around the Circle line. The past few weeks though have taught me that two things are important: flexibility and an eye mask.
Has it made me healthier?
Personally, I'd say yes. Especially in the mental health department. The long hours spent trying to get back to sleep, and all the worry that brings, have disappeared. I have a better relationship with sleep, and I'm more in control of both my day and my body. I certainly feel healthier knowing I'm going to get five hours of sleep instead of trying (and invariably failing) to get seven.
I discussed my schedule with Professor Adrian Williams of The London Sleep Centre.
"It's not necessarily about the number of hours you get per night, but the number you get per day." he says. "While being able to function well on anything under seven isn’t within the normally accepted range, everyone operates in a different way. Good sleep reflects itself in better physical well-being and weight regulation, so if you're not showing 'adverse' effects in any of those areas, then there's no reason why it wouldn't be a healthy option.”
We also discussed the various studies that have been done into the subject. For obvious human and animal rights reasons, no controlled observations around sleep deprivation have been conducted in recent years. However, some of the pioneering research into the subject in Russia found that dogs survived longer without water than they did on no sleep, and rats who didn't get adequate amounts of REM became hypersexual.
"Is it then that the siesta, with its association with less REM sleep, is in part responsible for the stereotype of a Latin lothario?" comments Williams.
The nights are spent writing or researching, and a 6 am nap means I'm freshly risen for when the kids wake up. The second nap has taken some getting used to (both in terms of switching off and finding a suitable time slot) but as the graph above shows, there's an equilibrium becoming clear.
Can you function on five hours sleep a day?
Well, it's 3:34 am and I've just finished writing and proofreading this article. You be the judge.